Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 20;36(13):1757–1765. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2018.02.048

Table 1.

Model input parameters.

Parameters Distribution Mean SE Ref.
Pneumococcal meningitis incidence per 100,000a [4], [7], [8]
 Aged <1 Beta 131.69 15.37
 Aged 1–4 Beta 12.85 2.39
 Aged 5–14 Beta 7.55 1.07
 Aged 15–19 Beta 4.60 0.36
 Aged 20–49 Beta 4.60 0.88
 Aged 50–64 Beta 4.11 1.33
 Aged ≥65 Beta 5.32 15.37
Pneumococcal bacteraemia incidence per 100,000 [10]
 Aged <4 Beta 11.1 1.84
 Aged 5–19 Beta 1.4 0.33
 Aged 20–49 Beta 1.9 0.28
 Aged 50–64 Beta 4.6 0.79
 Aged ≥65 Beta 13.6 2.02
All-cause pneumonia incidence per 100,000 [4]
 Aged <1 Beta 19117.07 340.31
 Aged 1–4 Beta 7373.52 109.60
 Aged 5–14 Beta 708.28 20.21
 Aged 15–19 Beta 277.82 8.32
 Aged 20–49 Beta 277.82 36.02
 Aged 50–64 Beta 809.48 61.77
 Aged ≥65 Beta 1339.13 340.31
All-cause AOM incidence per 100,000 [4]
 Aged <1 Beta 5267.77 188.32
 Aged 1–4 Beta 3000.88 70.83
 Aged 5–14 Beta 2395.54 37.01
 Aged 15–19 Beta 1507.20 19.31
 Aged 20–49 Beta 1507.20 49.23
 Aged 50–64 Beta 1517.35 57.39
 Aged ≥65 Beta 1155.00 188.32
PCV13 efficacyb
 Vaccine-type IPD (3 + 1) Beta 89.00% 3.57% [12]
 Radiologically-confirmed pneumonia (3 + 1) Beta 25.50% 8.72% [13]
 All-cause AOM (3 + 1) Beta 6.00% 1.53% [12]
PCV10 efficacy
 Vaccine-type IPD Beta 92.00% 10.71% [14]
 Hospital-diagnosed pneumonia Beta 28.00% 9.95% [15]
 All-cause AOM (3 + 1) Beta 19.00% 6.89% [16]
Vaccine serotype coverage in Bhutan
 PCV7 Beta 31.58% 10.39% RCDC
 PCV10 Beta 47.37% 11.16% RCDC
 PCV13 Beta 57.89% 11.04% RCDC
PCV7 serotype coverage in US [17]
 %Coverage in aged 10–39 Fixed 71.30%
 %Coverage in aged 40–64 Fixed 65.40%
 %Coverage in aged ≥65 Fixed 69.70%
%IPD fall among unvaccinated population in US [18]
 %Fall in aged 20–39 Beta 40.00% 4.59%
 % Fall in aged 40–64 Beta 14.00% 4.59%
 % Fall in aged ≥65 Beta 29.00% 3.57%
Probability of developing sequelae
 Epilepsy after pneumococcal meningitis Beta 10.34% 5.56% [9]
 Hearing loss after pneumococcal meningitis Beta 3.45% 3.33% [9]
 Neurodevelopmental impairmentc after pneumococcal meningitis Beta 34.48% 8.68% [9]
 Hearing loss after AOM Beta 5.10% 0.06% [6]
Case fatality rates
 All-cause pneumonia Beta 0.60% 0.07% [4]
 Pneumococcal meningitis Beta 7.74% 1.43% [4]
 Pneumococcal bacteraemia Beta 9.52% 3.67% [9]
Direct medical costs (USD) VPDP
 PCV10 cost per dose Fixed 3.05
 PCV13 cost per dose Fixed 3.55
 Programme delivery cost per dose Fixed 3.74
Treatment cost per episode Primary data collection
 Pneumococcal meningitis aged <1 Beta 394 157
 Pneumococcal meningitis aged 1–4 Beta 400 159
 Pneumococcal meningitis aged 5–14 Beta 410 168
 Pneumococcal meningitis aged ≥15 Beta 433 198
 Pneumococcal bacteremia aged <1 Beta 242 143
 Pneumococcal bacteremia aged 1–4 Beta 248 149
 Pneumococcal bacteremia aged 5–14 Beta 260 142
 Pneumococcal bacteremia aged ≥15 Beta 315 162
 Hospitalized pneumonia aged <1 Beta 82 19
 Hospitalized pneumonia aged 1–4 Beta 83 19
 Hospitalized pneumonia aged 5–14 Beta 83 20
 Hospitalized pneumonia aged ≥15 Beta 122 11
 Non-hospitalized pneumonia aged <1 Beta 9 3
 Non-hospitalized pneumonia aged 1–4 Beta 9 3
 Non-hospitalized pneumonia aged 5–14 Beta 9 3
 Non-hospitalized pneumonia aged ≥15 Beta 21 1
 AOM aged <1 Beta 9 2
 AOM aged 1–4 Beta 9 2
 AOM aged 5–14 Beta 9 2
 AOM aged ≥15 Beta 4 2
Treatment cost per year Primary data collection
 Epilepsy aged <1 Beta 123 46
 Epilepsy aged 1–4 Beta 122 45
 Epilepsy aged 5–14 Beta 145 53
 Epilepsy aged ≥15 Beta 170 64
 Hearing loss aged <1 Beta 129 112
 Hearing loss aged 1–4 Beta 129 112
 Hearing loss aged 5–14 Beta 129 112
 Hearing loss aged ≥15 Beta 129 112
 Neurodevelopment impairment aged <1 Beta 191 58
 Neurodevelopment impairment aged 1–4 Beta 191 58
 Neurodevelopment impairment aged 5–14 Beta 191 58
 Neurodevelopment impairment aged ≥15 Beta 189 55



Adjusted utilities for annual cycle (using HUI3) [19]
 Pneumococcal meningitis (utility = 0.34, for 20 days) Beta 0.9638 0.0046
 Pneumococcal bacteraemia (utility = 0.55, for 12 days) Beta 0.9852 0.0025
 Pneumonia (utility = 0.59, for 8 days) Beta 0.9910 0.0020
 AOM (utility = 0.71, for 2 days) Beta 0.9984 0.0001
 Epilepsy Beta 0.6400 0.0738
 Hearing loss Beta 0.5500 0.0554
 Mild mental retardation Beta 0.6900 0.0707
 Severe mental retardation Beta 0.1000 0.1085
 Mental retardation + epilepsy Gamma 0.0001 0.0943

AOM: acute otitis media. IPD: invasive pneumococcal disease. RCDC: Royal Centre for Disease Control (http://www.rcdc.gov.bt/WEB/). VPDP: Vaccine Preventable Disease Programme, Department of Public Health.

a

All-cause meningitis incidence [4] x Proportion of meningitis caused by S. pneumoniae (26.1% in child [7], 11.6% in adults [8]).

b

PCV13 values were derived based on PCV7 data. See details in the Supplementary Table 1.

c

Neurodevelopmental impairment included mild mental retardation, severe mental retardation and mental retardation with epilepsy.