Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 21;8:4989. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-22740-9

Table 1.

Synergism between Cry11Aa and Cyt1Aa-hybrid proteins against 3th instar of Aedes aegypti larvae.

Toxin S(toxin) OBSa = (R1 + R2 + R3)/n S(mixture) EXPb = S(Cyt1Aa)OBS × S(Cry11Aa)OBS Expected mortalityc = (1 − S(mixture)EXP) × 100% Observed mortality Cyt1Aa + Cry11Aad
Cyt1Aa 1 0.76 24% 97% ± 0.6
CytL3-Loop4 1 0.76 24% 70% ± 0
CytL3-Loop5 1 0.76 24% 80% ± 1.7
CytL3-Loop6 1 0.76 24% 67% ± 0.6
CytL3-Loop7 1 0.76 24% 87% ± 1.2
CytL3-loop8 1 0.76 24% 80% ± 1.0
CytL3-Loop9 1 0.76 24% 80% ± 1.0
CytL3-Loop10 1 0.76 24% 83% ± 2.1
Cry11Aa 0.76

aObserved survival of individual toxin S(toxin)OBS corresponds to the observed proportion of larvae that survived to the exposure to Cyt1Aa or Cyt1Aa-hybrid mutant toxins. Observed mortality was 20% with Cry11Aa at 108 ng per ml and 0% with Cyt1Aa or mutant toxins at 30 ng per ml. n = 30 larvae for each toxin tested.

bTheoretical proportion of larvae that survive to the toxin-mixture, S(Cyt1Aa, Cry11Aa)EXP = S(Cyt1Aa)OBS × S(Cry11Aa)OBS corresponds to the proportion of larvae expected to survive to the exposure of a mixture of toxins.

cTheoretical expected mortality was calculated with (1−S(Cyt1Aa, Cry11Aa)EXP) × 100%.

dExperimentally observed mortality with the mixture of toxins using Cry11Aa at 108 ng per ml plus each Cyt1Aa-hybrid toxin at 30 ng per ml.

These assays were performed three times. Fisher’s exact test showed values of P < 0.001 for each comparison.