Table 2.
Treatment | Outcome* | Locus | Marker | N (MM, mM, mm) | Effect Size (SE)¶ | P-value† | MAF | Function |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Combination | ΔFEV1%pred§ | HSPA8 | rs1461496 | 61 (24, 30, 7) | 8.41 (2.62) | 1.28x10−3 | 0.308 | intron |
| ||||||||
ACQ slope§ | CHRM2 | rs8191992 | 61 (18, 29, 14) | 2.45x10−2 (6.26x10−3) | 8.92x10−5‡ | 0.435 | untranslated-3' | |
CHRM2 | rs6962027 | 61 (17, 28, 16) | 2.52x10−2 (6.04x10−3) | 2.98x10−5‡ | 0.431 | near-gene-3' | ||
CHRM2 | rs6967953 | 61 (17, 28, 16) | 2.56x10−2 (6.11x10−3) | 2.81x10−5‡ | 0.420 | unknown | ||
ABCC1 | rs119774 | 61 (52, 9, 0) | 3.57x10−2 (1.36x10−2) | 8.69x10−3 | 0.043 | intron | ||
| ||||||||
Fluticasone | ΔFEV1%pred§ | CRHR1 | rs242941 | 64 (34, 26, 4) | −9.98 (3.24) | 2.07x10−3 | 0.341 | intron |
CRHR1 | rs739645 | 63 (36, 19, 8) | 1.03x101 (2.82) | 2.61x10−4‡ | 0.156 | intron | ||
CRHR1 | rs1876831 | 64 (37, 19, 8) | 1.04x101 (2.79) | 1.89x10−4‡ | 0.159 | intron | ||
CRHR1 | rs1876829 | 63 (36, 19, 8) | 1.03x101 (2.82) | 2.62x10−4‡ | 0.156 | intron | ||
CRHR1 | rs1876828 | 64 (37, 19, 8) | 1.04x101 (2.79) | 1.89x10−4‡ | 0.154 | intron | ||
HAL | rs17024981 | 64 (56, 8, 0) | 2.15x101 (6.22) | 5.46x10−4 | 0.078 | intron | ||
| ||||||||
ΔFEV1%pred|| | COL2A1 | rs2276458 | 64 (15, 37, 12) | −1.71x101 (6.00) | 4.25x10−3 | 0.347 | intron | |
COL2A1 | rs2276455 | 63 (17, 34, 12) | −1.71x101 (6.00 ) | 4.25x10−3 | 0.400 | intron | ||
COL2A1 | rs2276454 | 64 (17, 34, 13) | −1.71x101 (6.04) | 4.61x10−3 | 0.412 | coding-synon | ||
| ||||||||
Montelukast | ΔFEV1%pred§ | CRHR1 | rs739645 | 54 (34, 17, 3) | −6.26 (2.38) | 8.61x10−3 | 0.156 | intron |
CRHR1 | rs1876831 | 54 (34, 16, 4) | −6.26 (2.38) | 8.61x10−3 | 0.159 | intron | ||
CRHR1 | rs1876829 | 54 (34, 17, 3) | −6.26 (2.38) | 8.61x10−3 | 0.156 | intron | ||
CRHR1 | rs1876828 | 53 (34, 16, 3) | −6.26 (2.38) | 8.61x10−3 | 0.154 | intron | ||
HDAC2 | rs3757016 | 54 (17, 25, 12) | 5.57 (2.12) | 8.63x10−3 | 0.460 | untranslated-3' | ||
| ||||||||
ACQ slope§ | CRHR1 | rs242950 | 55 (10, 45, 0) | −3.54x10−2 (1.21x10−2) | 3.57x10−3 | 0.126 | intron |
Abbreviations: MAF, minor allele frequency; N, number of patients; SE, Standard Error; synon, synonymous.
ΔFEV1%pred, change in percent predicted FEV117 defined as (%predicted FEV1 (week 16) - %predicted FEV1 (enrollment) / %predicted FEV1 (enrollment)) × 100 (unit-less); ACQ slope, slope of the least squares regression line fit to a plot of Asthma Control Questionnaire16 score versus time at weeks 0, 2, 4, 8, 12, 16 (ACQ units / week). The ACQ score ranges from 0 to 6, with lower values indicating less-severe asthma and 0.5 unit as the minimal clinically important difference16.
P-values were determined from general linear models correcting for age, gender, height, and height2 (see Methods). Reported p-values for each treatment – phenotype combination are for the maximum set of associated markers for which less than one false positive is predicted by the method of Storey and Tibshirani23;
associated markers that are significant by the Bonferroni multiple testing correction57.
Additive model;
Recessive model.
Effect size is calculated as the slope of the line between the adjusted means of the response variable for each genotype group.