Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Proteins. 2017 Dec 4;86(Suppl 1):321–334. doi: 10.1002/prot.25425

Table 2.

Results of the head-to-head comparisons of the bottom 20 groups on commonly predicted targets: (A) all groups on ‘human’ targets and (B) server-only groups on all targets. The table shows the percentage of targets Pij where the combined z-score of the group listed in the row i was higher than z-score of the group listed in the column j. Values Pij and Pji may not sum up to 100% as ties are omitted. Shaded cells highlight pairs of groups for which difference between the percentages of wins and losses is comparable (less than 25%). Server groups are in italics.

(A)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
McGuffin 1 - 45 48 48 62 59 54 59 66 90 90 69 74 75 100 62 78 93 90 100
VoroMQA-select 2 55 - 55 62 69 79 57 62 69 93 97 66 78 82 93 72 81 97 90 97
Zhang 3 52 45 - 55 69 72 50 69 69 93 97 72 70 75 97 66 89 93 86 97
ProQ2 4 52 38 45 - 69 62 57 66 55 83 83 59 70 68 93 72 70 93 90 93
Wallner 5 38 31 31 31 - 45 46 52 48 93 93 55 67 68 93 62 67 93 86 100
MULTICOM 6 41 21 28 38 55 - 50 45 41 83 83 45 67 68 93 55 63 93 83 100
wfRos-ProQ-ModF6 7 43 43 50 43 54 50 - 57 61 75 82 71 62 68 82 64 69 82 82 86
Seok-refine 8 41 38 31 34 48 55 43 - 52 76 76 48 59 61 90 59 70 86 83 90
Zhang-Server 9 34 31 31 45 52 59 39 48 - 90 93 66 56 50 90 59 70 97 79 97
LEEab 10 10 7 7 17 7 17 25 24 10 - 55 21 15 36 83 45 48 86 55 97
LEE 11 10 3 3 17 7 17 18 24 7 45 - 10 15 36 76 34 52 83 52 90
QUARK 12 31 34 28 41 45 55 29 52 34 79 90 - 48 46 86 52 48 93 76 93
wfAll-Cheng 13 26 22 30 30 33 33 38 41 44 85 85 52 - 58 93 59 68 93 78 93
raghavagps 14 25 18 25 32 32 32 32 39 21 64 64 43 42 - 82 54 69 79 61 89
BAKER 15 0 7 3 7 7 7 18 10 10 17 24 14 7 18 - 31 33 41 14 62
Jones-UCL 16 38 28 34 28 38 45 36 41 41 55 66 48 41 46 69 - 59 76 66 90
Chicken_George 17 22 19 11 30 33 37 31 30 11 52 48 30 32 12 63 41 - 63 48 74
MUFOLD 18 7 3 7 7 7 7 18 14 3 14 17 7 7 21 59 24 37 - 24 79
wfMESHI-Seok 19 10 10 14 10 14 17 18 17 21 45 48 24 22 39 86 34 52 76 - 86
Pcomb-domain 20 0 3 3 7 0 0 14 10 3 3 10 7 7 11 38 10 26 21 14 -
(B)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Zhang-Server 1 - 60 89 61 70 93 70 72 84 100 91 98 93 96 100 80 100 98 96 98
QUARK 2 40 - 88 56 67 84 68 72 86 95 93 96 95 93 100 79 100 100 98 98
BAKER-Rosettaserv 3 11 12 - 35 28 53 40 39 46 81 60 74 65 65 94 64 93 86 75 84
Seok-server 4 39 44 65 - 61 72 67 63 74 82 81 86 81 84 92 77 91 88 88 88
IntFOLD4 5 30 33 72 39 - 72 56 56 72 93 82 96 95 91 96 75 96 96 86 95
GOAL 6 7 16 47 28 28 - 30 33 40 93 67 91 72 79 100 63 96 100 81 100
MULTICOM-cluster 7 30 32 60 33 44 70 - 49 74 86 81 86 81 82 100 75 100 91 86 91
MULTICOM-constr 8 28 28 61 37 44 67 51 - 77 88 79 88 79 81 98 77 96 93 88 93
MULTICOM-novel 9 16 14 54 26 28 60 26 23 - 86 70 86 72 74 94 70 96 93 86 95
RaptorX 10 0 5 19 18 7 7 14 12 14 - 42 53 37 35 96 54 95 72 74 72
myprotein-me 11 9 7 40 19 18 33 19 21 30 58 - 61 53 53 87 54 75 67 72 65
HHGG 12 2 4 26 14 4 9 14 12 14 47 39 - 26 23 94 52 89 68 74 75
HHPred0 13 7 5 35 19 5 28 19 21 28 63 47 74 - 56 96 48 91 82 77 82
HHPred1 14 4 7 35 16 9 21 18 19 26 65 47 77 44 - 96 48 91 77 77 81
ACOMPMOD 15 0 0 6 8 4 0 0 2 6 4 13 6 4 4 - 33 51 4 43 4
YASARA 16 20 21 36 23 25 38 25 23 30 46 46 48 52 52 67 - 68 46 61 48
MULTICOM-refine 17 0 0 7 9 4 4 0 4 4 5 25 11 9 9 49 32 - 18 44 12
FALCON_TOPO 18 2 0 14 12 4 0 9 7 7 28 33 32 18 23 96 54 82 - 70 51
RBO_Aleph 19 4 2 25 12 14 19 14 12 14 26 28 26 23 23 57 39 56 30 - 30
FALCON_TOPOX 20 2 2 16 12 5 0 9 7 5 28 35 25 18 19 96 52 88 46 70 -