Table 4.
Ethical principles to be applied in decision making around high-cost care (HCC).
Principle | National level | Community level | Individual level |
---|---|---|---|
Respect for autonomy | Rights of nations to make decisions regarding the prioritization of health services in that country. | The rights of communities to be involved in the processes that affect what and how medical care will be delivered to them | The rights of individuals and their families to make decisions regarding issues that affect them |
Beneficence | The HCC should provide an improvement in the quality of life in that country | The HCC should improve the quality of health and life in the community which is being provided with that service | The care that is offered has to be seen to provide value to the individual child and his/her family |
Non-maleficence or “do no harm” | The provision of the particular HCC cannot be seen to endanger the delivery of other essential services | The provision of the services must not cause harm to themselves, and the removal of other services in order to afford the services must not be seen as a greater harm | Patients must be seen to benefit from the services offered. There may be a range of perceptions about what outcomes are actually acceptable |
Justice | The health-care services need to provide care to as many children as possible, within the resources available. All care cannot be provided to all | There are different communities that are affected by decisions around HCC, and communities should not be disadvantaged by the provision of HCC to individuals or to other communities | Patients should have access to care on the basis of need and likelihood of benefit |