Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 4;13(4):e0195096. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0195096

Table 3. Stability of reference genes during abiotic and biotic stress.

Conditions Rank Δ Ct BestKeeper NormFinder geNorm
Gene
stability value Gene
stability value Gene
Stability
value
Gene
Stability
value
High temperature 1.00 RPS13 0.47 RPS7 0.47 RPS13 0.05 18S 0.23
2.00 18S 0.47 RPS13 0.57 18S 0.08 ACT 0.23
3.00 RPS7 0.49 18S 0.57 RPS7 0.10 RPS13 0.24
4.00 ACT 0.49 EF1-α 0.59 ACT 0.14 RPS7 0.26
5.00 GAPDH 0.55 TUB 0.64 GAPDH 0.22 GAPDH 0.28
6.00 TUB 0.71 ACT 0.71 TUB 0.36 RPL32 0.36
7.00 RPL32 0.73 RPL32 0.81 RPL32 0.44 TUB 0.45
8.00 EF1-α 1.24 GAPDH 0.89 EF1-α 0.83 EF-1α 0.64
Larval crowding 1.00 TUB 0.75 RPS13 0.14 TUB 0.14 EF1-α 0.46
2.00 RPS7 0.76 18S 0.36 RPS7 0.21 ACT 0.46
3.00 RPS13 0.82 RPS7 0.37 RPS13 0.28 TUB 0.53
4.00 ACT 0.89 TUB 0.49 18S 0.38 RPS7 0.63
5.00 18S 0.90 ACT 0.66 ACT 0.45 RPS13 0.68
6.00 EF1-α 0.96 EF-1α 0.68 EF1-α 0.51 GAPDH 0.72
7.00 GAPDH 1.02 GAPDH 0.73 GAPDH 0.59 18S 0.78
8.00 RPS32 1.45 RPL32 0.90 RPL32 0.96 RPL32 0.95
Pesticide exposure 1.00 EF1-α 1.33 GAPDH 0.30 EF1-α 0.22 RPS7 0.21
2.00 RPS7 1.36 RPS7 0.53 RPS7 0.56 RPL32 0.21
3.00 RPS32 1.39 RPL32 0.56 RPL32 0.56 18S 0.65
4.00 18S 1.60 TUB 1.01 18S 0.79 ACT 0.80
5.00 GAPDH 1.67 18S 1.20 GAPDH 0.86 EF1-α 0.94
6.00 TUB 1.88 EF1-α 1.24 TUB 1.03 GAPDH 1.05
7.00 ACT 1.93 RPS13 1.32 ACT 1.11 TUB 1.20
8.00 RPS13 1.94 ACT 2.08 RPS13 1.74 RPS13 1.60