Table 1.
Reference | Journal | Year | Period of enrollment | Country | Study type | Cytology reporting systema) | FNA category | Nodules with histologic follow-up |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Park et al. [15] | Head Neck | 2011 | Feb 2005-Jun 2009 | Korea | Pro | Not detailed | Indeterminate | 53 |
Na et al. [16] | Thyroid | 2012 | Feb 2009-Jan 2010 | Korea | Pro | Bethesda | AUS/FLUS | 104 |
Nasrollah et al. [17] | Endocrine | 2013 | Dec 2011-May 2012 | Italy | Retro | SIAPEC-IAP | TIR 3 | 40 |
Choi et al. [18] | Thyroid | 2015 | Jan 2011-Dec 2012 | Korea | Retro | Bethesda | AUS/FLUS | 159 |
Na et al. [19] | Eur Thyroid J | 2015 | Feb 2010-Jun 2013 | Korea | Retro | Bethesda | AUS/FLUS | 91 |
Trimboli et al. [20] | Endocrine | 2016 | Jun 2012-Dec 2013 | Italy | Retro | SIAPEC-IAP | TIR 3 | 74 |
Han et al. [21] | Eur J Neuroradiol | 2016 | Apr 2006-Dec 2010 | Korea | Retro | Bethesda | Indeterminate | 61 |
This table does not include the five excluded studies: four studies were excluded due to unclear data [27-30], while the study of Choi et al. [26] was excluded due to potential overlap of the period of enrollment (from October 2008 to July 2011) with that of another series [22].
FNA, fine-needle aspiration; Pro, prospective; AUS/FLUS, atypia of undetermined significance/follicular lesion of undetermined significance; Retro, retrospective; SIAPECIAP, Societá Italiana di Anatomia Patologica e Citologia diagnostica - Divisione Italiana della International Academy of Pathology (the Italian consensus for thyroid cytology classification); TIR 3, category 3 in the five-tiered system for FNA cytology.
System adopted to classify thyroid nodules on initial cytology.