Table 4.
Parameter | Baseline Mean (Range) | Enhanced Mean (Range) | Ideal Mean | Sourcea | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hand hygiene | |||||
Soap and water effectiveness | 96 (90–100) | [102–104] | |||
ABHR effectiveness | 29 (13–36) | [92, 103] | |||
Standard Room Compliance | Nurse | 60 (46–68) | 79 (74–84) | 96 | [105–115] |
Doctor | 50 (40–55) | 71 (57–80) | 91 | [105–117] | |
Visitor | 35 (20–50) | 55 (50–67) | 84 | [106, 118–124] | |
Patient | 33 (30–40) | 59 (55–65) | 84 | [120, 125–129] | |
Fraction soap and water (vs ABHR) | 10 (5–25) | [110, 130] | |||
Known C. difficile Room Compliance | Nurse | 69b | 84b | 97 | [59, 131–133] |
Doctor | 61b | 77b | 93 | [59, 131–133] | |
Visitor | 50b | 65b | 88 | [59, 131–133] | |
Patient | 48b | 68b | 88 | [59, 131–133] | |
Fraction soap and water (vs ABHR) | 80 (70–90) | 90 (80–95) | 95 | [134] | |
Contact precautions | |||||
Gown and glove effectiveness | 70 (60–80) | 86 (80–90) | 97 | [135–137] | |
Healthcare worker compliance | 67 (62–72) | 77 (71–85) | 87 | [59, 118, 138–142] | |
Visitor compliance | 50 (42–52) | 74 (70–80) | 94 | [118, 138, 139] | |
Environmental cleaning | |||||
Daily cleaning compliance | 46 (40–50) | 80 (70–85) | 94 | [29–33] | |
Terminal cleaning compliance | 47 (40–50) | 77 (70–82) | 98 | [29, 143–146] | |
Nonsporicidal effectiveness | 45 (35–50) | [147, 148] | |||
Sporicidal effectiveness | 99.6 | [148–151] | |||
Asymptomatic screening at admission | |||||
Compliance | 0 | 96 (92–99) | 98 | [38, 152] | |
PCR test sensitivity; specificity | 93 (90–94); 97 (95–99) | [153–155] | |||
Patient transfer | |||||
Intraward transfer rate | 5.7 (4–7.4) | 2.8 (2.2–3.5) | 1.4 | Internal data | |
Interward transfer rate | 13.7 (10–17.4) | 6.8 (5–8.7) | 3.4 | Internal data | |
Proportionate time between transfers | 24% (time between transfer/length of stay; 20–30) | Internal data |
Abbreviations: ABHR, alcohol-based hand rub; C.difficile, Clostridium difficile; PCR, polymerase chain reaction.
aReferences for input parameter sources are included in the Supplementary Materials.
bKnown Clostridium difficile room compliance range based on the range in standard room and standard:C. difficile infection hand hygiene noncompliance ratio (1.34).