Table 3.
LH | RH | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Region | ANCOVA a | Subgroup | M b | SD | Comparison to HC c | d d | M b | SD | Comparison to HC c | d d |
Banks of superior temporal sulcus | LH: F(3, 378) = 5.79, P = .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 3.00, P = .03 | CIQ | 2.56 | .14 | =HC | −.15 | 2.65 | .14 | =HC | 0 |
DIQ | 2.50 | .20 | <HC | −.47 | 2.61 | .20 | =HC | −.24 | ||
PIQ | 2.51 | .17 | <HC | −.46 | 2.60 | .17 | =HC | −.33 | ||
HC | 2.58 | .13 | — | 2.65 | .13 | — | ||||
Caudal anterior cingulate | RH: F(3, 378) = 3.40, P = .02 | CIQ | 2.70 | .21 | — | 2.62 | .21 | =HC | −.17 | |
DIQ | 2.66 | .20 | — | 2.58 | .20 | <HC | −.34 | |||
PIQ | 2.64 | .26 | — | 2.60 | .26 | =HC | −.23 | |||
HC | 2.68 | .26 | — | 2.66 | .26 | =HC | ||||
Caudal middle frontal | LH: F(3, 378) = 9.15, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 5.77, P = .001 | CIQ | 2.57 | .14 | <HC | −.67e | 2.57 | .14 | <HC | −.59e |
DIQ | 2.59 | .10 | <HC | −.60 | 2.61 | .10 | <HC | −.35 | ||
PIQ | 2.59 | .09 | <HC | −.62 | 2.60 | .17 | <HC | −.33 | ||
HC | 2.66 | .13 | — | 2.65 | .13 | — | ||||
Entorhinal | LH: F(3, 378) = 5.39, P = .001 | CIQ | 3.26 | .34 | <HC | −.46e | 3.43 | .34 | — | |
DIQ | 3.29 | .30 | <HC | −.40 | 3.43 | .40 | — | |||
PIQ | 3.32 | .34 | =HC | −.30 | 3.45 | .34 | — | |||
HC | 3.43 | .39 | — | 3.54 | .39 | — | ||||
Fusiform | LH: F(3, 378) = 12.97, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 11.60, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.60 | .14 | <HC | −.81e | 2.60 | .14 | <HC | −.81e |
DIQ | 2.65 | .10 | <HC | −.52 | 2.64 | .10 | <HC | −.60 | ||
PIQ | 2.63 | .17 | <HC | −.62 | 2.62 | .17 | <HC | −.59 | ||
HC | 2.71 | .13 | — | 2.71 | .13 | — | ||||
Inferior parietal | LH: F(3, 378) = 2.99, P = .03; RH: F(3, 378) = 4.06, P = .007 | CIQ | 2.58 | .14 | =HC | −.30 | 2.61 | .14 | <HC | −.37 |
DIQ | 2.59 | .10 | =HC | −.26 | 2.61 | .10 | <HC | −.43 | ||
PIQ | 2.59 | .17 | =HC | −.20 | 2.62 | .17 | =HC | −.26 | ||
HC | 2.62 | .13 | — | 2.66 | .13 | — | ||||
Inferior temporal | LH: F(3, 378) = 12.88, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 10.45, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.82 | .14 | <HC | −.81e | 2.84 | .14 | <HC | −.74 |
DIQ | 2.85 | .20 | <HC | −.69 | 2.85 | .10 | <HC | −.78 | ||
PIQ | 2.82 | .17 | <HC | −.73 | 2.87 | .17 | <HC | −.46 | ||
HC | 2.93 | .13 | — | 2.94 | .13 | — | ||||
Isthmus cingulate | LH: F(3, 378) = 5.79, P = .001 | CIQ | 2.53 | .21 | =HC | −.23 | 2.45 | .21 | — | |
DIQ | 2.52 | .20 | =HC | −.30 | 2.43 | .20 | — | |||
PIQ | 2.46 | .17 | <HC | −.73 | 2.44 | .17 | — | |||
HC | 2.57 | .13 | — | 2.49 | .13 | — | ||||
Lateral orbitofrontal | LH: F(3, 378) = 17.28, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 15.51, P = .001 | CIQ | 2.60 | .14 | <HC | −1.11e | 2.64 | .14 | <HC | −.89e |
DIQ | 2.65 | .20 | <HC | −.59 | 2.67 | .20 | <HC | −.53 | ||
PIQ | 2.64 | .17 | <HC | −.73 | 2.65 | .17 | <HC | −.73 | ||
HC | 2.75 | .13 | — | 2.76 | .13 | — | ||||
Lingual | RH: F(3, 378) = 3.14, P = .03 | CIQ | 1.98 | .14 | — | 2.02 | .14 | =HC | −.37 | |
DIQ | 1.99 | .10 | — | 2.05 | .10 | =HC | −.17 | |||
PIQ | 1.98 | .09 | — | 2.03 | .09 | =HC | −.66 | |||
HC | 2.01 | .13 | — | 2.07 | .13 | =HC | ||||
Medial orbitofrontal | LH: F(3, 378) = 9.52, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 11.50, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.53 | .14 | <HC | −.96e | 2.50 | .14 | <HC | −.89e |
DIQ | 2.59 | .20 | <HC | −.42 | 2.55 | .20 | <HC | −.42 | ||
PIQ | 2.58 | .17 | <HC | −.53 | 2.53 | .17 | <HC | −.59 | ||
HC | 2.66 | .13 | — | 2.62 | .13 | — | ||||
Middle temporal | LH: F(3, 378) = 13.14, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.92 | .14 | <HC | −.67 | 2.95 | .14 | <HC | −.74 |
DIQ | 2.91 | .10 | <HC | −.86 | 2.96 | .10 | <HC | −.77 | ||
PIQ | 2.90 | .17 | <HC | −.73 | 2.98 | .17 | <HC | −.46 | ||
HC | 3.01 | .13 | — | 3.05 | .13 | — | ||||
Parahippocampal | LH: F(3, 378) = 7.71, P < .001 RH: F(3, 378) = 11.21, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.46 | .34 | <HC and DIQ and PIQ | −.83e | 2.53 | .27 | <HC | −.49e |
DIQ | 2.61 | .30 | <HC | −.36 | 2.59 | .30 | =HC | −.25 | ||
PIQ | 2.64 | .34 | =HC | −.23 | 2.60 | .26 | =HC | −.23 | ||
HC | 2.71 | .26 | — | 2.66 | .26 | — | ||||
Pars opercularis | LH: F(3, 378) = 6.42, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 13.80, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.58 | .14 | <HC | −.59e | 2.59 | .14 | <HC | −.34e |
DIQ | 2.60 | .10 | <HC | −.52 | 2.61 | .10 | <HC | −.25 | ||
PIQ | 2.59 | .17 | <HC | −.46 | 2.60 | .17 | <HC | −.27 | ||
HC | 2.66 | .13 | — | 2.70 | .13 | — | ||||
Pars orbitalis | LH: F(3, 378) = 13.81, P < .001 RH: F(3, 378) = 7.90, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.74 | .21 | <HC | −.59 | 2.78 | .21 | <HC | −.51e |
DIQ | 2.77 | .20 | <HC | −.47 | 2.81 | .20 | <HC | −.39 | ||
PIQ | 2.73 | .17 | <HC | −.68 | 2.80 | .17 | <HC | −.46 | ||
HC | 2.88 | .26 | — | 2.90 | .26 | — | ||||
Pars triangularis | LH: F(3, 378) = 8.72, P < .001 RH: F(3, 378) = 8.76, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.53 | .14 | <HC | −.59e | 2.55 | .14 | <HC | −.59 |
DIQ | 2.52 | .20 | <HC | −.53 | 2.57 | .10 | <HC | −.52 | ||
PIQ | 2.53 | .17 | <HC | −.53 | 2.54 | .17 | <HC | −.59 | ||
HC | 2.61 | .13 | — | 2.63 | .13 | — | ||||
Posterior cingulate | LH: F(3, 378) = 3.41, P = .02 | CIQ | 2.57 | .14 | =HC | −.37e | 2.53 | .14 | — | |
DIQ | 2.57 | .20 | =HC | −.30 | 2.53 | .10 | — | |||
PIQ | 2.57 | .17 | =HC | −.33 | 2.54 | .17 | — | |||
HC | 2.62 | .13 | — | 2.56 | .13 | — | ||||
Precentral | LH: F(3, 378) = 4.28, P = .005; RH: F(3, 378) = 4.88, P = .002 | CIQ | 2.46 | .14 | <HC | −.44e | 2.45 | .14 | <HC | −.52e |
DIQ | 2.47 | .10 | <HC | −.43 | 2.47 | .10 | <HC | −.43 | ||
PIQ | 2.47 | .17 | <HC | −.33 | 2.47 | .17 | <HC | −.33 | ||
HC | 2.52 | .13 | — | 2.52 | .13 | — | ||||
Precuneus | LH: F(3, 378) = 3.67, P = .01 | CIQ | 2.41 | .14 | =HC | −.44e | 2.41 | .14 | — | |
DIQ | 2.43 | .10 | <HC | −.34 | 2.43 | .10 | — | |||
PIQ | 2.46 | .09 | =HC | −.09 | 2.45 | .09 | — | |||
HC | 2.47 | .13 | — | 2.46 | .13 | — | ||||
Rostral anterior cingulate | LH: F(3, 378) = 6.65, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.83 | .21 | <HC and DIQ and PIQ | −.68e | 2.96 | .21 | — | |
DIQ | 2.92 | .20 | <HC | −.30 | 2.97 | .20 | — | |||
PIQ | 2.92 | .26 | <HC | −.27 | 3.01 | .17 | — | |||
HC | 2.99 | .26 | — | 3.02 | .26 | — | ||||
Rostral middle frontal | LH: F(3, 378) = 7.36, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 7.42, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.47 | .14 | <HC | −.59 | 2.48 | .14 | <HC | −.59e |
DIQ | 2.50 | .10 | <HC | −.43 | 2.52 | .10 | <HC | −.34 | ||
PIQ | 2.48 | .09 | <HC | −.63 | 2.50 | .09 | <HC | −.54 | ||
HC | 2.55 | .13 | — | 2.56 | .13 | — | ||||
Superior frontal | LH: F(3, 378) = 5.86, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 9.44, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.77 | .14 | <HC | −.74e | 2.76 | .14 | <HC | −.81e |
DIQ | 2.82 | .10 | <HC | −.43 | 2.81 | .10 | <HC | −.52 | ||
PIQ | 2.81 | .17 | <HC | −.40 | 2.80 | .17 | <HC | −.46 | ||
HC | 2.87 | .13 | — | 2.87 | .13 | — | ||||
Superior temporal | LH: F(3, 378) = 8.97, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 14.82, P < .001 | CIQ | 2.77 | .14 | <HC | −.59 | 2.79 | .14 | <HC | −.81e |
DIQ | 2.78 | .10 | <HC | −.60 | 2.82 | .10 | <HC | −.69 | ||
PIQ | 2.76 | .17 | <HC | −.59 | 2.80 | .17 | <HC | −.66 | ||
HC | 2.85 | .13 | — | 2.90 | .13 | — | ||||
Supramarginal | LH: F(3, 378) = 3.65, P = .01 RH: F(3, 378) = 7.06 P <.001 | CIQ | 2.61 | .14 | <HC | −.52e | 2.61 | .14 | <HC | −.59e |
DIQ | 2.64 | .10 | =HC | −.34 | 2.63 | .10 | <HC | −.52 | ||
PIQ | 2.65 | .17 | =HC | −.20 | 2.63 | .17 | <HC | −.40 | ||
HC | 2.68 | .13 | — | 2.69 | .13 | — | ||||
Frontal pole | RH: F(3, 378) = 4.56, P = .004 | CIQ | 2.90 | .27 | — | 2.84 | .27 | <HC | −.42 | |
DIQ | 2.96 | .30 | — | 2.87 | .30 | =HC | −.28 | |||
PIQ | 2.88 | .26 | — | 2.83 | .26 | <HC | −.46 | |||
HC | 2.96 | .26 | — | 2.95 | .26 | |||||
Temporal pole | LH: F(3, 378) = 5.28, P = .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 7.85, P < .001 | CIQ | 3.55 | .34 | <HC | −.52 | 3.66e | .34 | <HC and DIQ | −.73e |
DIQ | 3.68 | .30 | <HC | −.17 | 3.79 | .30 | <HC | −.32 | ||
PIQ | 3.61 | .34 | <HC | −.36 | 3.74 | .34 | <HC | −.46 | ||
HC | 3.74 | .39 | — | 3.88 | .26 | — | ||||
Transverse temporal | RH: F(3, 378) = 4.33, P = .005 | CIQ | 2.41 | .21 | — | −.13 | 2.43 | .21 | =HC | −.25 |
DIQ | 2.38 | .20 | — | −.26 | 2.42 | .20 | <HC | −.30 | ||
PIQ | 2.38 | .17 | — | −.27 | 2.39 | .17 | <HC | .46 | ||
HC | 2.44 | .26 | — | 2.49 | .26 | — | ||||
Insula | LH: F(3, 378) = 12.28, P < .001; RH: F(3, 378) = 8.86, P < .001 | CIQ | 3.03 | .14 | <HC | −.74 | 3.00 | .21 | <HC | −.57 |
DIQ | 3.06 | .20 | <HC | −.42 | 3.02 | .20 | <HC | −.47 | ||
PIQ | 3.02 | .17 | <HC | −.73 | 3.00 | .17 | <HC | −.66 | ||
HC | 3.13 | .13 | — | 3.10 | .13 | — |
Note: CIQ, compromised patients; DIQ, deteriorated schizophrenia patients; PIQ, putatively preserved schizophrenia patients; LH, left hemisphere; RH, right hemisphere.
aAll Ps thresholded at a false discovery rate of 5%.
bAll values are adjusted for age, gender, site.
cIf a comparison is not reported, it did not survive post hoc comparison correction. =HC (healthy controls) implies no significant difference to HCs; <HC implies significant reductions relative to HCs.
d d = Cohen’s d effect sizes for patient–control comparisons.
eRepresents qualitatively larger control–patient effect sizes in compromised patients.