Table 2.
|
Approach |
Subjects |
Regimen |
Reported significant (p<0.05 or less) improvement in the actively treated group vs. control group |
Reported adverse reactions |
Alvarez-Cuesta E et al. 199476 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat allergy | 28, aged 15-28 yrs, A with RC | Cat dander extract, 1 yr | Medication-symptoms score, skin prick test, conjunctival provocation, allergen bronchoprovocation | Local reaction in 7 subjects and mild systemic reactions in 3 subjects in the actively treated group |
Alvarez-Cuesta E et al. 200780 | SLIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat allergy | 50, mean age 27 yrs, RC with/without A | Cat dander extract, 1 yr | Total and nasal symptoms scores, PEF, skin test reactivity | No local or systemic reactions |
Haugaard L et al. 199283 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat and/or dog allergy | 24, aged 13–48 yrs, A | Cat and/or dog dander extract, 5 mo | Symptoms of cat-allergic subjects on cat exposure | Local reactions in about 25% of all injections, some systemic reactions in both groups, 1 severe asthma reaction and 1 anaphylactic reaction in the actively treated group |
Nelson HS et al. 199379 | SLIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat allergy | 41, aged 18-74 yrs, RC with/without A | Cat hair and epithelium extract, 105 d | Not observed | Similar number of mild reactions in both groups |
Ohman JL et al. 198484 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat allergy | 17, aged 22-48 yrs, A | Cat pelt extract, 16 wk | Skin test reactivity, pulmonary symptoms score on cat exposure, subjective allergic symptoms, allergen-specific IgG | Large local reactions in 2 subjects and systemic reactions in 4 subjects in the actively treated group, systemic reactions in 1 subject in the placebo group, all mild |
Sundin B et al. 198685 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat or dog allergy | 41, aged 8-47 yrs, A | Cat or dog dander extract, 1 yr | Allergen bronchoprovocation | Systemic reactions in all 12 children at high allergen doses (build-up in rush IT), all mild, otherwise a few mild systemic or local reactions |
Valovirta E et al. 198481, 198682 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, dog allergy | 27, aged 5-18 yrs, A | Dog dander and hair extract, 1 yr | Conjunctival provocation, skin test reactivity, allergen-specific IgG | No significant difference in mild local reactions between the groups |
Van Metre TE et al. 198886 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat allegy | 22, aged 21-52 yrs, A | Cat hair and dander extract, 1 yr | Allergen bronchoprovocation, skin test reactivity, allergen-specific IgG | Mild systemic reactions in 2 subjects and large local reactions in 6 subjects in the actively treated group |
Varney VA et al. 199777 | SCIT, RCT, DB, PC, cat allergy | 28, aged 19-50 yrs, RC with A | Cat dander extract, 3 mo | Asthma symptom score, allergen bronchoprovocation | 6 large local reactions in both groups, 3 mild systemic reactions in the actively treated group and 2 in the control group |
SCIT - subcutaneous allergen immunotherapy, RCT - randomized controlled trial, DB - double-blind, PC - placebo-controlled, A - asthma, RC - rhinoconjunctivitis, SLIT - sublingual allergen immunotherapy