Table 3.
References | Population | N | Kinetic parameter | Measured outcome | p-value |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vehreschild et al., 2017d | Majority hematological | 40 | Mean sGM at day 7 | 0.3 in week 12 survivors vs. 1.1 in week 12 non-survivors | 0.354 |
Mean sGM at day 14 | 0.3 in week 12 survivors vs. 1.3 in week 12 non-survivors | 0.559 | |||
Mean of (day 14 sGM – day 7 sGM) | 1.26 in week 12 survivors vs. 0.82 in non-survivors | 0.617 | |||
Neofytos et al., 2015 | SOT, hematological, solid tumor | 47 | Baseline sGM – Week 2 sGM | Mean difference 0.58 between week 6 responders vs. week 6 non-responders | 0.03 |
Baseline sGM – Week 6 sGM | Mean difference 0.65 between week 6 responders vs. week 6 non-responders | 0.03 | |||
Baseline sGM – Week 2 sGM | Mean difference 0.72 between week 12 responders vs. week 12 non-responders | 0.02 | |||
Baseline sGM – Week 6 sGM | Mean difference 0.98 between week 12 responders vs. week 12 non-responders | 0.01 | |||
sGM remaining < 0.5 | OR 4.1 for week 6 response | 0.07 | |||
sGM remaining < 0.5 | OR 4.5 for week 12 response | 0.05 | |||
sGM remaining < 0.5 | OR 4.3 for week 6 survival | 0.10 | |||
sGM remaining < 0.5 | OR 6.5 for week 12 survival | 0.02 | |||
Han et al., 2015 | Pediatric hematological | 45 | Week 1 median sGM | 0.39 in week 12 survivors vs. 1.64 in week 12 non-survivors | 0.015 |
Week 2 median sGM | 0.38 in week 12 survivors vs. 2.76 in week 12 non-survivors | 0.004 | |||
Week 1 sGM < 1.5 | Predicts week 12 survival with sensitivity 61.5%, specificity 89.3%, NPV 83.3%, PPV 72.7% | ||||
Teering et al., 2014a,e | Mixed ICU | 44 | Maximum sGM – baseline sGM | 0.11 in in-hospital survivors vs. 0.48 in non-survivors | 0.017 |
Chai et al., 2014 | Majority hematological | 147 | Week 1 sGM – baseline sGM | Greater decline in week 12 responders in voriconazole treated patients (effect size not reported) | 0.001 |
Week 2 sGM – baseline sGM | Greater decline in week 12 responders in voriconazole treated patients (effect size not reported) | 0.046 | |||
Week 4 sGM – baseline sGM | Greater decline in week 12 responders in amphotericin B treated patients (effect size not reported) | 0.072 | |||
Khanna et al., 2013f | Adults and children, no pathology specified | 57 | Increasing sGM | 5.4% of day 30 survivors vs. 64.9% of day 30 non-survivors had increasing sGM | 0.02 |
Nouér et al., 2012 | Multiple myeloma | 98 | sGM < 0.5 within 7 days | Adjusted OR 2.9 for favorable week 6 response | 0.048 |
sGM < 0.5 within 7 days | 45.5% of week 6 survivors vs. 22.6% of week 6 non-survivors had sGM < 0.5 within 7 days | 0.03 | |||
sGM < 0.5 within 7 days | Adjusted OR 2.9 for week 6 survival | 0.048 | |||
Hadrich et al., 2012 | Hematological | 58 | 7 × (Week 1 sGM – baseline sGM)/days between tests | HR 0.709 for mortality | NS |
Bergeron et al., 2012 | Hematological | 57 | sGM area under the curve | No association found with day 60 survival | |
Rate of sGM decline | No association found with day 60 survival | ||||
Park S. H. et al., 2011 | Hematological | 58 | sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.663 for week 6 clinical failure | <0.05 |
sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.819 for week 12 clinical failure | <0.05 | |||
Park S. Y. et al., 2011 | Hematological, SOT | 110 | sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 3 months | HR 7.14 day 90 mortality | <0.001 |
Nouér et al., 2011 | Hematological | 115 | sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.819 for week 6 clinical failure | <0.001 |
Koo et al., 2010 | Hematological, SOT, solid tumor | 93 | (Baseline sGM – week 1 sGM)/days between tests | Adjusted HR 0.78 for week 6 survival | 0.02 |
Maertens et al., 2009g | Neutropenic hematological | 70 | sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.588 for week 6 clinical failure | <0.05 |
sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.886 for week 12 clinical failure | <0.05 | |||
sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.752 for week 6 EORTC-MSG response failure | <0.05 | |||
Woods et al., 2007b | Hematological | 56 | sGM remaining > 0.5 for more than 2 weeks | Kappa coefficient 0.861 for mortality | <0.0001 |
Boutboul et al., 2002c | Hematological | 58 | Increase of week 1 sGM < 1.0 over baseline | Predicts favorable week 6 response with sensitivity 44%, specificity 87%, PPV 94% | |
Increase of week 2 sGM < 1.0 over baseline | Predicts favorable week 6 response with sensitivity 55%, specificity 92%, PPV 92% | ||||
Salonen et al., 2000c,h | Hematological, SOT | 18 | sGM remaining > 1.0 | 100% of non-survivors vs. 20% of survivors had sGM remaining > 1.0 | 0.002 |
SOT, Solid organ transplantation; sGM, Serum galactomannan; OR, Odds ratio; HR, Hazard ratio; NS, Not significant; PPV, Positive predictive value. N;
Modification of the 2008 EORTC-MSG classification criteria;
2002 EORTC-MSG classification criteria;
Author's own classification criteria;
Only caspofungin treated patients;
Also included possible cases;
Interval between serial sGM assessments not specified;
Only pulmonary invasive aspergillosis;
No interval specified between tests, or for outcome assessment.