Table 1.
Gestures | Vocalizations | |
---|---|---|
Who is studied? | Signaler (and recipient) | Recipient |
Is intentionality considered? | Yes (production) | No |
How is meaning studied? | Intended meaning | Extracted meaning |
Which signals are studied? | Context-unspecific | Context-specific |
What is the relationship between signal and referent? | No one-to-one referential meaning between pointing gestures and their varying referents | One-to-one referential meaning between functionally referential signals and their referents |
Which species are studied? | Apes | Monkeys |
Which methods are used? | Observations | Playback experiments |
Where are studies conducted? | Captivity | Natural habitats |