ECT |
Cerebral cortex |
Small currents and generalized seizure induction |
Strong |
First line therapy for patients who failed in pharmacotherapy, rapid antidepressive effects, long-lasting clinical experiences |
Relapse rates, effort, cognitive side effects |
tDCS |
Cerebral cortex |
Anode and cathode sending constant low current (0.5–2 mA) directly to the brain |
Weak-moderate |
Non-invasive, rapid effects |
Less clinical experience |
rTMS |
Cerebral cortex |
Magnetic pulses to depolarize cerebral neurons |
Strong |
Non-invasive, approved |
Relapse rates, effort, small effect sizes |
DBS |
Nucleus accumbens, lateral habenula, ventral striatum, inferior thalamic nucleus, peduncle, subgenual cingulate |
High-frequency stimulation (130–185 Hz); reduction of neuronal transmission by inactivating voltage-dependent ion channels; modulation of neuronal circuits |
Moderate, experimental |
Probably highly effective |
Implantation procedure |
MST |
Cerebral cortex |
Based on ECT, probably effects increased glucose metabolism |
Weak-moderate |
Less side effects than ECT |
No broad evidence |
CES |
Probably affects limbic system, reticular activating system, hypothalamus |
Electrical currents (<1 mA) |
Weak-moderate |
Non-invasive, supposed antidepressive mode of action, FDA-approved |
No broad evidence |
VNS |
Left peripheral vagus nerve |
(Long-term) modulation of neurotransmitters |
Moderate-strong |
Anti-suicidal effects and rates of remittance, combination option with nearly all other treatment options, FDA-approved |
Latency in antidepressive efficacy |