Table 1.
Neurostimulation options for treatment of TRD.
Technique | Main stimulation target region | Mode of action | Evidence | Pro | Con |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
ECT | Cerebral cortex | Small currents and generalized seizure induction | Strong | First line therapy for patients who failed in pharmacotherapy, rapid antidepressive effects, long-lasting clinical experiences | Relapse rates, effort, cognitive side effects |
tDCS | Cerebral cortex | Anode and cathode sending constant low current (0.5–2 mA) directly to the brain | Weak-moderate | Non-invasive, rapid effects | Less clinical experience |
rTMS | Cerebral cortex | Magnetic pulses to depolarize cerebral neurons | Strong | Non-invasive, approved | Relapse rates, effort, small effect sizes |
DBS | Nucleus accumbens, lateral habenula, ventral striatum, inferior thalamic nucleus, peduncle, subgenual cingulate | High-frequency stimulation (130–185 Hz); reduction of neuronal transmission by inactivating voltage-dependent ion channels; modulation of neuronal circuits | Moderate, experimental | Probably highly effective | Implantation procedure |
MST | Cerebral cortex | Based on ECT, probably effects increased glucose metabolism | Weak-moderate | Less side effects than ECT | No broad evidence |
CES | Probably affects limbic system, reticular activating system, hypothalamus | Electrical currents (<1 mA) | Weak-moderate | Non-invasive, supposed antidepressive mode of action, FDA-approved | No broad evidence |
VNS | Left peripheral vagus nerve | (Long-term) modulation of neurotransmitters | Moderate-strong | Anti-suicidal effects and rates of remittance, combination option with nearly all other treatment options, FDA-approved | Latency in antidepressive efficacy |