Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 25;13(4):e0195697. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0195697

Table 3. Discriminatory capabilities of body silhouettes for identifying obesity (BMI≥30) retrospectively, according to sex and recall time in women and men age 30(±2) or 45(±2) years in ECRHS I or II with objectively measured height and weight and in RHINE II with self-reported height and weight.

Results of ROC curve analysis.

Reporting of body silhouette
ECRHS III
Age n AUC
(95% CI)
OC* Youden Index Sensitivity, %
(95% CI)
Specificity, %
(95% CI)
Correctly classified %
Women
Recall 9-15y 30±2y 172 0.92 (.87, .97) 5 .715 88.2 (.64, .99) 83.2 (.76, .89) 83.7
(ECRHS II) 45±2y 296 0.82 (.75, .89) 5 .511 72.7 (.54, .87) 78.3(.73, .83) 77.7
Recall 16-23y 30±2y 442 0.88 (.80, .96) 5 .633 75.0 (.48, .93) 88.3 (.85, .91) 87.8
(ECRHS I) 45±2y 305 0.80 (.72, .89) 4 .416 96.4 (.82, .99) 45.1 (.39, .51) 49.8
Men
Recall 9–15 y 30±2y 138 0.85 (.75, .95) 6 .533 66.7 (.41, .87) 86.7(.79, .92) 84.1
(ECRHS II) 45±2y 362 0.79 (.73, .85) 5 .433 85.2 (.73, .93) 59.1(.73, .83) 63.0
Recall 16–23 y 30±2y 365 0.78 (.63, .93) 5 .548 73.3 (.45, .92) 81.4(.45, .92) 81.1
(ECRHS I) 45±2y 362 0.80 (.72, .87) 5 .463 77.4 (.82, .99) 68.9 (.64, .74) 69.6
Reporting of body silhouette
RHINE III
Age n AUC
(95% CI)
OC* Youden Index Sensitivity, %
(95% CI)
Specificity, %
(95% CI)
Correctly classified %
Women
Recall 9-13y 30±2y 1145 0.92 (.88, .95) 5 .715 85.5 (.74, .93) 86.0 (.84, .88) 86.0
45±2y 439 0.87 (.79, .94) 5 .679 85.7 (.70, .95) 82.2 (.78, .86) 82.5
Men
Recall 9-13y 30±2y 829 0.90 (.85, .96) 6 .689 77.3 (.62, .89) 91.6 (.89, .93) 90.8
45±2y 997 0.84 (.80, .88) 6 .505 67.9 (.74, .93) 82.6 (.80, .85) 81.4

Abbreviations: AUC, Area Under the Curve; BMI, Body Mass Index; ECRHS, European community respiratory health survey; RHINE, Respiratory Health In Northern Europe.

*OC, optimal sensitivity and specificity criterion in relation to body silhouette.