Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Apr 27.
Published in final edited form as: Curr Psychiatry Rep. 2016 Dec;18(12):111. doi: 10.1007/s11920-016-0750-x

Table 1.

Summary of risk factors reported in the systematic review and meta-analysis by Caye and colleagues [48••]

Factors meta-analyzed and significantly associated with persistence
Predictor Odds ratio 95 % Confidence interval P value
 Severe ADHD 2.33 1.6–3.39 <0.001
 Treatment for ADHD 2.09 1.04–4.18 0.037
 Comorbid major depressive disorder 1.80 1.1–2.95 0.019
 Comorbid Conduct Disorder 1.85 1.06–3.24 0.03
Factors meta-analyzed nonsignificantly associated with persistencea
Predictor Odds ratio 95 % Confidence interval P value
 Female gender 1.23 0.84–1.81 0.295
 Comorbid ODD 1.65 0.75–3.65 0.213
Factors meta-analyzed and consistently not associated with persistence
Predictor Odds ratio 95 % Confidence interval P value
 Single parent family 1.08 0.25–1.29 0.179
Predictor SMD 95 % Confidence interval P value
 Intelligence quotient 0.03 −0.18–−0.23 0.8
Factors not meta-analyzed but associated with persistence in individual studies
Combined ADHD subtype • comorbid bipolar disorder • parental ASPD

SMD standardized mean difference, ASPD antisocial personality disorder

a

Authors note that sensitive analysis or the adoption of less conservative meta-analysis techniques (fixed-effects models) would result in a positive and significant association for comorbid ODD and female gender, whereas single parent family and intelligence quotient have consistent small and not significant effects on persistence across included studies