Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 May 1.
Published in final edited form as: Cancer. 2018 Feb 7;124(9):1877–1903. doi: 10.1002/cncr.31177

Table 4.

Articles on Ethnic Density/Segregation and Cancer Mortality

Reference Ethnic Density
Measure(s)
Dataset Sample Outcome(s) Association Main Findings

Black neighborhood

Cooper (1997)13 % Black 329 US counties (1989–1991) 148,947 Medicare beneficiaries with colorectal cancer aged 65+ years 2-year mortality among CRC cases + As % Blacks in the county increased, 2-year mortality rates for both White and Black patients increased

Russell (2011)47 % Black GA Cancer Registry (1999–2003) 15,256 Black and White women with breast cancer Breast cancer- specific mortality + Increasing % Black residents was associated with higher breast cancer-specific mortality for all women

Russell (2012)48 % Black; GA Cancer Registry (1999–2003) 20,088 Black and White women with breast cancer Breast cancer- specific and all-cause mortality + Increasing % Black residents was associated with higher all-cause mortality for White (but not Black) women.
Theil Index Increasing segregation was associated with higher breast cancer-specific mortality for Black (but not White) women.

Warner (2010)8 % Black; CA Cancer Registry (1996–2004) 8,482 non-Hispanic Black and 95,672 NHW women with breast cancer Breast cancer- specific and all-cause mortality + (Whites) Among Whites, living in neighborhoods with greater % Blacks was associated with higher all-cause mortality. Among Blacks, living in neighborhoods with ≥20% Blacks was associated with lower breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality. Protective effect was observed across most segregation measures.
Dissimilarity; — (Blacks)
Delta;
Isolation;
Relative centralization;
Spatial proximity

Lim (2011)49 % Black Los Angeles County Cancer Registry (1997- 2003) 1811 women with cervical cancer Cervical cancer-specific mortality + Living in neighborhoods with a high proportion of Black households was associated with increased risk of death
% Hispanic
% Asian

Pruitt (2015)10 Location quotient TX Cancer Registry (1995–2009) 109,749 Black, Hispanic, and White women with breast cancer aged 50+ yrs Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality + Among all women, higher Black segregation was associated with greater all-cause mortality.
In analyses stratified by patient race/ethnicity, greater segregation was not associated with greater mortality among Blacks.

Bemanian (2017)11 Location quotient WI Cancer Reporting System (2002–2011) 7,164 White, 940 Black, and 252 Hispanic women with breast cancer Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality In race-stratified analyses, Black patients residing in areas of high Black isolation had lower breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality.
Local exposure & isolation (Lex/Is)
Index of concentration at extremes (ICE)

Zhou (2017)12 Location quotient WI Cancer Reporting System (2002–2011) 4,699 Whites and 682 Blacks with colorectal cancer Colorectal cancer-specific and all-cause survival No association

Haas (2008)50 Isolation index SEER-Medicare (1992–2002) 47,866 White, Black, and Hispanic women with breast cancer aged 66–85 yrs Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality No association

Johnson (2016)52 Isolation index GA Comprehensive Cancer Registry (2000–2009) 8,322 White and Black early-stage non-small cell lung cancer cases Lung cancer mortality + (Blacks) High segregation and high economic deprivation were associated with greater mortality among Blacks, but not among Whites
NA (Whites)

Hayanga (2013)51 Dissimilarity index SEER registry (2003–2007) Black and White populations per US county Race-specific lung cancer mortality rates by county + (Blacks) Dissimilarity index was associated with greater lung cancer mortality for Blacks, but lower mortality for Whites
— (Whites)

Hispanic neighborhood

Pruitt (2015)10 Location quotient TX Cancer Registry (1995–2009) 109,749 Black, Hispanic, and White women with breast cancer aged 50+ yrs Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality + Among all women, higher Hispanic segregation was associated with greater breast cancer-specific and greater all-cause mortality.
In analyses stratified by patient race/ethnicity, greater segregation was not associated with greater mortality among Hispanics.

Bemanian (2017)11 Location quotient WI Cancer Reporting System (2002–2011) 7,164 White, 940 Black, and 252 Hispanic women with breast cancer Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality + Local Hispanic isolation was associated with greater overall mortality for all women.
Local exposure & isolation (Lex/Is)
Index of concentration at extremes (ICE)

Haas (2008)50 Isolation index SEER-Medicare (1992–2002) 47,866 White, Black, and Hispanic women with breast cancer aged 66–85 yrs Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality No association

Pruitt (2016)53 % Hispanic TX Cancer Registry (1995–2009) 166,254 NHW and Hispanic women with breast cancer Breast cancer- specific and all-cause mortality + Residing in higher Hispanic density neighborhoods was generally associated with higher all-cause and breast cancer-specific mortality, although associations differed slightly by ethnicity and birthplace.

Lim (2011)49 % Black Los Angeles County Cancer Registry (1997- 2003) 1811 women with cervical cancer Cervical cancer-specific mortality No association
% Hispanic
% Asian

Keegan (2010)15 Enclave index CA Cancer Registry (1988 – 2005) 37,695 Hispanic women with breast cancer Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality No association

Banegas (2014)54 Enclave index CA Cancer Registry (2005–2010) 16,380 Hispanic women with breast cancer Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality No association

Patel (2013)55 Enclave index CA Cancer Registry (1998–2007) 14,280 NHWs and Hispanics with lung cancer Lung cancer-specific and all-cause mortality Birthplace × enclave interaction The association between birthplace and survival differed by enclave residence, with a protective effect of foreign-birth observed only among cases living in high enclave/low SES neighborhoods

Schupp (2014)56 Enclave index CA Cancer Registry (1996–2004) 35,427 Hispanic men with prostate cancer Prostate cancer-specific survival Birthplace × enclave interaction Foreign-born Hispanics had significantly better survival, but ethnic enclave modified this effect, with the survival advantage being more pronounced in the high enclave compared with low enclave neighborhoods.

Gomez (2015)14 Enclave index CA Cancer Registry (1994–2009) 7958 Hispanic women with cervical cancer Cervical cancer-specific mortality Birthplace × enclave interaction The association between birthplace and survival differed by enclave residence, with a protective effect of foreign-birth observed only among cases living in high enclave settings.

Asian neighborhood

Gomez (2010)57 Enclave index CA Cancer Registry (1988 – 2005) 20,747 Asian women with breast cancer Breast cancer-specific and all-cause mortality No association

Lim (2011)49 % Black Los Angeles County Cancer Registry (1997- 2003) 1811 women with cervical cancer Cervical cancer-specific mortality No association
% Hispanic
% Asian

Unspecified neighborhood

Keegan (2014)58 % Immigrant Neighborhoods and Breast Cancer Study (NABC), northern CA 4,345 women with breast cancer Breast cancer- specific and all-cause mortality Residing in neighborhoods with more foreign-born residents was associated with lower breast cancer-specific mortality.

Note:

a

In this column, we use “+” to indicate findings in which greater ethnic density was associated with higher mortality, whereas “—” is used to denote findings in which greater ethnic density was associated with lower mortality.