Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 20;9:505. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2018.00505

Table 3.

Ranking of 66 plant introductions (PIs) based on plant mortality (PM) using drop-mycelium method in our greenhouse evaluations and the disease severity index (DSI) from Hoffman et al. (2002) study.

Plant mortalitya Disease severity indexb
Plant introduction 2009 Rank 2010 Rank Across-year Rank DSI Rank
PI 506733A 8.3 7 30.6 2 19.4 1 21 58
PI 504502 5.6 2 37.8 3 21.7 2 18 49
PI 506654 5.6 2 47.2 10 26.4 3 13 37
PI 506728 22.9 18 30.0 1 26.4 4 23 62
PI 361059B 18.9 15 41.1 5 30.0 5 6 6
PI 358318A 19.1 17 41.7 6 30.4 6 10 21
PI 417201 6.7 5 55.6 22 31.1 7 14 40
PI 594286 0.0 1 64.4 32 32.2 9 20 57
FC 030233 26.7 22 41.7 6 34.2 10 7 13
PI 416805 8.3 7 63.9 31 36.1 11 9 17
PI 427143 31.1 31 41.7 6 36.4 12 7 13
PI 189919 16.7 14 57.8 23 37.2 13 7 13
PI 196157 9.5 9 65.6 35 37.5 14 16 43
PI 507222 26.2 20 50.0 13 38.1 15 18 49
PI 184042 11.1 11 67.2 41 39.2 16 19 55
PI 548539 27.8 25 52.8 16 40.3 17 16 43
PI 132207 42.2 49 40.0 4 41.1 18 0 1
PI 507353 28.6 27 54.4 19 41.5 19 4 3
PI 506892 9.5 9 75.6 50 42.5 20 15 42
PI 561367 13.3 13 75.0 47 44.2 21 6 6
PI 506784 5.6 2 83.3 55 44.4 22 11 29
PI 548407 24.5 19 65.6 36 45.0 23 6 6
PI 232996 36.1 41 54.2 18 45.1 24 24 63
PI 081775 35.3 38 55.6 20 45.4 25 14 40
PI 438267 35.6 39 55.6 20 45.6 26 18 49
PI 507352 26.7 22 65.0 34 45.8 27 3 2
PI 416776 33.3 33 58.3 24 45.8 28 10 21
PI 243547 32.2 32 60.0 26 46.1 29 4 3
PI 549066 18.9 15 75.0 47 46.9 30 10 21
PI 153259 50.0 52 45.6 9 47.8 31 21 58
PI 567157A 6.7 5 88.9 63 47.8 32 6 6
PI 506652 26.5 21 70.0 44 48.3 33 11 29
PI 091733 45.0 50 52.8 16 48.9 34 11 29
PI 404180 38.0 44 60.5 27 49.2 35 18 49
PI 398637 31.0 30 68.3 42 49.6 36 17 46
PI 561353 36.7 42 63.3 30 50.0 37 6 6
PI 153282 35.7 40 65.7 37 50.7 38 6 6
PI 548312 37.8 43 64.4 32 51.1 39 6 6
PI 561345 52.2 55 50.0 13 51.1 40 13 37
PI 548404 41.7 46 66.7 38 54.2 41 16 43
PI 594289 28.3 26 80.6 53 54.4 42 30 66
PI 417245 26.7 22 83.3 55 55.0 43 21 58
PI 548380 41.7 46 68.9 43 55.3 44 19 55
PI 189899 50.0 52 61.1 28 55.6 45 10 21
PI 578501 50.0 52 61.1 28 55.6 45 12 35
PI 567650B 33.3 33 81.1 54 57.2 47 8 16
PI 417533 66.7 65 50.0 11 58.3 48 11 29
PI 189896 33.3 33 83.3 55 58.3 49 10 21
PI 506868 33.3 33 83.3 55 58.3 49 17 46
PI 506519 66.7 65 50.6 15 58.6 51 26 65
PI 153316 60.0 59 58.3 24 59.2 52 11 29
PI 417449 30.0 28 88.9 63 59.4 53 9 17
PI 391589B 34.3 37 86.7 60 60.5 54 5 5
PI 437764 46.0 51 76.4 52 61.2 55 10 21
PI 561284 30.0 28 94.4 65 62.2 56 11 29
PI 189931 60.0 60 66.7 38 63.3 57 17 46
PI 229324 41.9 48 86.7 60 64.3 58 12 35
PI 437072 57.9 58 72.2 45 65.1 59 13 37
PI 189861 66.7 65 66.7 38 66.7 60 21 58
PI 437527 53.2 56 83.3 55 68.2 61 9 17
PI 423818 38.9 45 100.0 67 69.4 62 24 63
PI 291319B 63.9 63 75.6 50 69.7 64 9 17
PI 561331 54.8 57 86.7 60 70.7 65 18 49
PI 417507 70.0 68 75.0 47 72.5 66 10 21
PI 567721 63.3 62 94.4 65 78.9 67 34 67
PI 548354 62.8 61 100.0 67 81.4 68 18 49
NKS 19-90® 12.5 12 50.0 11 31.3 8 10 21
Olympus (S) 66.7 64 77.8 46 72.3 63
Mean 34.3 65.3 49.8 13.2
STDEV 18.6 16.6 13.7 6.7
CV (%)
LSD0.05
54.2 25.5 27.5
32.9
50.8
a

Plant mortality that ranged from 0 = all plants survived to 100 = all plants dead.

b

Disease severity index that ranged from 0 = all healthy plants with no disease to 100 = all plants killed by disease. The DSI means are based on the disease ratings of 30 plants in two replications according to (Hoffman et al., 2002).