Table 3.
Interior and Exterior Advertising by Product Type, Year and Store Type
| Interior Advertising | Exterior Advertising | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 N (%) | 2012 N (%) | 2013 N (%) | p-value | 2011 N (%) | 2012 N (%) | 2013 N (%) | p-value | ||
| Number of stores assessed | 161 | 158 | 162 | 161 | 158 | 162 | |||
| Any tobacco product | |||||||||
| All stores | 155 96.3% |
149 94.3% |
153 94.4% |
0.66 | 104 64.6% |
100 63.3% |
98 60.5% |
0.73 | |
| Convenience (with gas) | 78 100% |
73 100% |
80 98.8% |
1.0 | 72 92.3% |
67 91.8% |
69 85.2% |
0.26 | |
| Convenience (without gas) | 28 87.5% |
30 85.7% |
26 86.7% |
1.0 | 24 75% |
24 68.6% |
24 80% |
0.57 | |
| Pharmacy | 17 100% |
18 100% |
22 100% |
- | 0 0% |
1 5.6% |
0 0% |
0.61 | |
| Supermarket | 26 100% |
20 100% |
19 100% |
- | 7 26.9% |
2 10% |
2 10.5% |
0.34 | |
| Other (i.e., tobacco shop/bar/restaurant/liquor/discount) | 6 75% |
8 66.7% |
6 60% |
0.89 | 1 12.5% |
6 50% |
3 30% |
0.21 | |
| Snus | |||||||||
| All stores |
129 80.1% |
112 70.9% |
86 53.1% |
<.0001 | 7 4.4% |
5 3.2% |
4 2.5% |
0.63a | |
| Convenience (with gas) |
74 94.9% |
61 83.6% |
64 79% |
0.009a | 6 7.7% |
2 2.7% |
3 3.7% |
0.34a | |
| Convenience (without gas) | 19 59.4% |
21 60% |
16 53.3% |
0.84 | 1 3.1% |
2 5.7% |
1 3.3% |
1.00a | |
| Pharmacy |
6 35.3% |
10 55.6% |
1 4.6% |
<.001a | 0 0% |
0 0% |
0 0% |
- | |
| Supermarket |
25 96.2% |
16 80% |
5 26.3% |
<.001a | 0 0% |
0 0% |
0 0% |
- | |
| Other (i.e., tobacco shop/bar/restaurant/liquor/discount) |
5 62.5% |
4 33.3% |
0 0% |
0.01a | 0 0% |
1 8.3% |
0 0% |
1.00a | |
| Traditional Smokeless Products | |||||||||
| All stores | 135 83.9% |
129 81.7% |
123 75.9% |
0.18 | 29 18% |
37 23.4% |
40 24.7% |
0.31 | |
| Convenience (with gas) | 75 96.2% |
68 93.2% |
77 95.1% |
0.71a | 21 26.9% |
28 38.4% |
35 43.2% |
0.09 | |
| Convenience (without gas) | 23 71.9% |
25 71.4% |
20 66.7% |
0.88 | 5 15.6% |
6 17.1% |
4 13.3% |
0.94a | |
| Pharmacy | 6 35.3% |
8 44.4% |
3 13.6% |
0.08a | 0 0% |
0 0% |
0 0% |
- | |
| Supermarket | 26 100% |
20 100% |
18 94.7% |
0.29a | 2 7.7% |
0 0% |
0 0% |
0.33a | |
| Other (i.e., tobacco shop/bar/restaurant/liquor/discount) | 5 62.5% |
8 66.7% |
5 50% |
0.81a | 1 12.5% |
3 25% |
1 10% |
0.70a | |
| Cigarettes | |||||||||
| All stores | 154 95.7% |
148 93.7% |
153 94.4% |
0.73 | 100 62.1% |
95 60.1% |
96 59.3% |
0.87 | |
| Convenience (with gas) | 77 98.7% |
73 100% |
80 98.8% |
1.0b | 71 91.0% |
63 86.3% |
67 82.7% |
0.30 | |
| Convenience (without gas) | 28 87.5% |
30 85.7% |
26 86.7% |
1.0b | 22 68.8% |
23 65.7% |
24 80% |
0.42 | |
| Pharmacy | 17 100% |
18 100% |
22 100% |
- | 0 0% |
1 5.6% |
0 0% |
0.61a | |
| Supermarket | 26 100% |
19 95% |
19 100% |
0.60 a | 6 23.1% |
2 10% |
2 10.5% |
0.51a | |
| Other (i.e., tobacco shop/bar/restaurant/liquor/discount) | 6 75% |
8 66.7% |
6 60% |
0.89a | 1 12.5% |
6 50% |
3 30% |
0.21a | |
a
P-value from Fisher’s Exact test