Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 18;68(5):336–347. doi: 10.1093/biosci/biy029

Table 3.

Applying the mitigation hierarchy to the examples of housing development and commercial fisheries bycatch, to demonstrate its applicability at multiple scales and for different sectors.

Harmful event: Housing development leading to loss of biodiversity and habitat Harmful event: Pacific leatherback sea turtles bycaught in commercial fisheries
Mitigation hierarchy step Local 
(one house built) National (state housing plan implemented) Global (human urbanization footprint increasing) Local (one turtle killed by one vessel) National (local extinctions or population reduction in a nation's Exclusive Economic Zones) Global (species sent to extinction)
Avoid Restriction of building permissions to given areas only Strategic plan identifies areas set aside for housing and areas for conservation International protected-area commitments Enforcement of small scale time or area closures Nationally legislated caps on turtle takes for countries operating fisheries in areas frequented by turtles Multinational no-take fishing zones tracking leatherback turtle migration
Minimize Drainage areas, fence to prevent overflow of extracted dirt Regulatory requirements for house building International lenders require all new housing to be ecologically friendly Gear modification resulting in increased likelihood of turtle survival Fleetwide gear changes (e.g., implementing circle hooks, branch lines long enough to allow turtles breathing at the surface, effort restrictions) Demand reduction through international education campaigns targeting consumers of Pacific-sourced tuna and swordfish
Remediate Restoration of land along digger tracks Land area restoration plans at the state scale International fund for urban greening projects Better turtle-handling and gear-removal practices resulting in higher survival rates for postcapture release Increased marine protected area monitoring and enforcement resulting in fewer illegal fishing events, allowing turtle population to recover Protection and reallocation of nests to increase hatching success at known Pacific leatherback turtle nesting sites throughout range
Offset Protect an area of existing wetland or create a new wetland nearby State supports protection of similar natural areas in other parts of the country International fund for restoration of habitat types preferentially affected by urbanization Protection of nesting turtles and their eggs at local nesting beaches and restoration of degraded nesting sites Protection of nesting turtles and their eggs at nesting beaches within another area of the country Protection of Atlantic leatherback sea turtles in an effort to ensure they don’t meet the same fate