Table 3. Characteristics of synthetic compounds for the treatment of human cystic and alveolar echinococcosis based on the published literature.
Compound | Disease | Assay setting | Dosage | Treatment | Efficacy assessment | Toxicity | References | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
In vitro | In vivo | In patients (n) |
Initiation (p.i.) | Duration | Activity against | Successa (%) | |||||
ANTIVIRALS AND ANTIBIOTICS | |||||||||||
Benzoic acid thioureides | AE | Yes | — | — | 2–20 μM | N/A | 1 week | Cysts | Yes (30-˃50) | N/A | [20] |
Cetrimide | CE | Yes | Yesc,d | — | 1.5% (cetrimide) + 0.5% (chlorhexidine) (in vitro) | N/A | 10 min (in vitro) | PSC | Yes (93, in vitro) | No | [15,73] |
0.1–5% (in vivo)f | 1 min (in vivo) | Yes (100, in vivo) | |||||||||
Chlorhexidine gluconate | CE | — | Yesb | Yes (30) | 0.04% (in vivo)f | N/S | 5 min | PSC | Yes (100, in vivo) | N/S | [16,17] |
Fluoride | CE | Yes | — | — | 20% | N/A | 16 h | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [140] |
Glucose 50% | CE | Yes | — | — | 50% | N/A | 5 min | PSC | Yes (95) | N/A | [134] |
H2O2 | CE | Yes | — | See text | 4% | N/A | 10 min | PSC | Yes (96) | N/A | [73] |
Isoprinosine | AE | Yes | Yesb | — | 2 mM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 48 h (in vitro) | PSC, Cysts | Yes (95, in vitro) | N/S | [146,147] |
0.5 g·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 3 moths (in vivo) | 2 weeks (in vivo) | Yes (42, in vivo) | ||||||||
CE | — | Yesb | — | 1–2 g·kg-1·day-1,e | 10 months | 2 weeks to 2 months | Cysts | Yes (80–90) | N/S | [143] | |
Monensin | CE | Yes | — | — | 10 μM | N/A | 3 days | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [137] |
Nitrite and peroxynitrite | CE | Yes | — | — | 80–320 μM | N/A | 1–2 days | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [138] |
Povidone-iodine | CE | Yes | — | See text | 10% | N/A | N/S | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [90] |
Rifampicin | AE | Yes | — | — | 10 μg·mL-1 | N/A | 6 weeks | Cysts | No | N/A | [144,145] |
CE | — | Yes | — | 9 mg·kg-1,e | 3 months | 2 weeks | Cysts | No | N/S | [142] | |
Saline 20% | CE | Yes | — | See text | 20% | N/A | 10 min | PSC | Yes (99–100) | N/A | [73,90] |
Sodium arsenite | CE | Yes | — | — | 20 M | N/A | 6 days | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [141] |
Taurolidine | CE | Yes | Yesb | — | 5 mg·mL-1 (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 1.5 h (in vitro) | PSC | Yes (100, in vitro) | No | [139] |
400 mg·kg-1 (in vivo)g,h | 0–3 months (in vivo) | Single dose (in vivo) | Yes (prophylaxis) No (therapy) | ||||||||
Trimetoprim-sulfametoxazole | AE | Yes | — | — | 0.02 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 4 weeks | Cysts | No | N/A | [144] |
ANTIPROTOZOA | |||||||||||
Artemisinin and synthetic ozonide derivates | CE | Yes | — | — | 40 μM | N/A | 4 days | PSC | Yes (90) | N/A | [95] |
AE | Yes | Yesb | — | 20–40 μM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 4–5 days (in vitro) | Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | Yes | [95,149] | |
200 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 2 months (in vivo | 6 weeks (in vivo) | Yes (75–100, in vivo) | ||||||||
Mefloquine | AE | Yes | Yesb | — | 60 μM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 2–5 days (in vitro) | Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | Yes (see [152]) | [97,152] |
8 weeks (in vivo)g | |||||||||||
25 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)g | 1.5 months (in vivo)e. g | 12 weeks (in vivo)e | Yes (100g, 78e, in vivo) | ||||||||
100 mg·kg-1 3 days-1 (in vivo)e | |||||||||||
Mefloquine enantiomer DB1127 | AE | Yes | Yesb | — | 20 μM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 5 days (in vitro) | Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | Yes | [98,153] |
50 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 4 weeks (in vivo)e | No (in vivo)e | |||||||||
2 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)g | 1.5 months (in vivo) | 6 weeks (in vivo)g | Yes (70, in vivo)g | ||||||||
Miltefosine | AE | Yes | — | — | 7.5 μg·mL-1 | N/A | 6 weeks | Cysts | No | N/A | [144,145] |
Nitazoxanide | AE | Yes | Yesb | Yes (6) | 10 μg to 5 mg·mL-1 (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 10 days-6 weeks (in vitro) | Cysts | Yes (variable, in vitro and in vivo) | Yes | [5] [6] [22] [145] [150] [154] |
3 mg·day-1 (in vivo)e | 0–2 months (in vivo) | 35 days (in vivo) | |||||||||
N/S (in patients) | 15 months (in patients) | 15 months (in patients) | No (in patients) | ||||||||
CE | — | Yesc | See text | 15 mg·kg-1·week-1 or 30 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e |
N/A | 5 days to 5 weeks | Cysts | No | No | [26] | |
Nitazoxanide derivates RM4807 and RM4841 | AE | Yes | — | — | 5 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 5 days | Cysts | Yes (N/S) | N/A | [22] |
ANTIHELMINTHIC | |||||||||||
Clorsulon | AE | Yes | — | — | 15 μg·mL-1 | N/A | 20 days | Cysts | No | N/A | [120] |
Ivermectin | AE | Yes | — | — | 1.75 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 6 weeks | Cysts | No | N/A | [144,145] |
CE | Yes | Yesb | — | 0.1 mg·mL-1 (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 50–72 h (in vitro) | PSC, Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | N/S | [160] [161] [162] [163] |
|
4 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 48 h or 4 months (in vivo) | 4 months (in vivo) | No (in vivo) | ||||||||
Levamisole | CE | Yes | — | — | 0.1 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 6 days | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [160] |
Praziquantel | CE | Yes | — | See text | 0.1 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 48 h | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [14] |
AE | Yes | Yesb | See text | 10 μg·mL-1 (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | N/S (in vivo) | PSC, Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | N/S | [164,165] | |
300 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 1 month (in vivo) | 69 days (in vivo) | No (in vivo) | ||||||||
ANTIARTHROPODA | |||||||||||
Lufenuron | CE | — | Yesb | — | 100 mg·kg-1·day-1,i | 4 months | 4 months | Cysts | No | N/S | [28] |
ANTIMYCOTIC | |||||||||||
Caspofungin | AE | Yes | — | — | 0.07 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 1.5 months | Cysts | No | N/A | [144] |
Itraconazole | AE | Yes | — | — | 0.7 mg·mL-1 | N/A | 5 weeks | Cysts | No | N/A | [144,145] |
IMMUNOMODULATORS | |||||||||||
Cyclosporin A | AE | — | Yesb | — | 40 mg·kg-1·day-1,i | 1.5 months | 80 days | Cysts | No | N/A | [170] |
CE | Yes | Yesb | — | 50 μg·mL-1 (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 15 days (in vitro) | PSC, Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | N/S | [168,169] | |
50 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)i | 4.5 months (in vivo) | 5 days (in vivo) | Yes (42, in vivo) | ||||||||
ANTINEOPLASTIC | |||||||||||
Bortezomib | AE | Yes | Yesb | — | 0.5 μM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 5 days (in vitro) | Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | N/S | [177] |
0.7 mg or 0.5 kg-1·week-1 (in vivo)g | 6 weeks (in vivo) | 3 weeks (in vivo) | No (in vivo) | ||||||||
Doxorubicin (nanoparticles) | AE | — | Yesb | — | 5 mg·kg-1,h | 70–80 days | 2 doses | Cysts | Yes (60) | N/S | [179] |
Genistein and derivates | AE, CE | Yes | — | — | 10 μg·mL-1 | N/A | 4 to 14 days | PSC, Cysts | Yes (60–100 for PSC, N/S for cysts in vitro) | N/A | [173] |
Imatinib | AE | Yes | — | — | 50 μM | N/A | 1–3 weeks | Cells, PSC, Cysts | Yes (100) | N/A | [174] |
5-fluorouracil, Paclitaxel |
CE | Yes | — | — | 10 μg·mL-1 | N/A | 7–72 days | Cells, PSC, Cysts | Yes (100, for 5-fluorouracil) | N/A | [175] |
Methotrexate, Navelbine, Vincristine | AE | Yes | — | — | 2.4–60 nM | N/A | 5 days | Cysts | No | N/A | [171] |
2-Methoxyestradiol | CE | Yes | — | — | 10 μM | N/A | 1 week | Cysts | Yes (100) | N/A | [172] |
AE | Yes | Yesb | — | 10 μM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 1 week (in vitro) | Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro) | N/A | [172] | |
200 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 2 months (in vivo) | 6 weeks (in vivo) | No (in vivo) | ||||||||
Mitomycin C | AE | — | Yesb | — | 0.1 mg·week-1,g | 1 day or 1 month | 3 weeks | Cysts | Yes (76) | N/A | [180] |
η(6)-Areneruthenium (II) phosphite | AE | Yes | — | — | 20 μM | N/A | 5 days | Cysts | Yes (100) | N/A | [176] |
Tamoxifen | CE | Yes | Yesb | — | 20 μM (in vitro) | N/A (in vitro) | 2–7 days (in vitro) | PSC, Cysts | Yes (100, in vitro | N/S | [25] |
20–200 mg·kg-1·day-1 (in vivo)e | 3–6 months (in vivo) | 32–80 days (in vivo) | Yes (61–83, in vivo) | ||||||||
GENOME-BASED | |||||||||||
Kinase inhibitor BI2536 | AE | Yes | — | — | 50 nM | N/A | 2–3 weeks | Cells, Cysts | Yes (100 for cysts; 98 for cells) | N/A | [182] |
Kinase inhibitors ML3403 and SB202190 | AE | Yes | — | — | 5 μM | N/A | 4 days (cysts), 4 weeks (cells) | Cells, Cysts | Yes (100 for cells, 50 for cysts) | N/A | [183] |
Kinase inhibitor SB202190 | CE | Yes | — | — | 80 μM | N/A | 1 day | PSC | Yes (70) | N/A | [184] |
OTHERS | |||||||||||
Chenodeoxycholic acid | CE | Yes | — | — | 2 M | N/A | 10 days | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [188] |
Selenium nanoparticles | CE | Yes | — | — | 500 μg·mL-1 | N/A | 10 min | PSC | Yes (100) | N/A | [186] |
N/A: Not applicable; N/S: Not specified; PSC: Protoscoleces.
a Defined as a significant reduction of the parasite burden or the viability of the any form of the larval stage of the parasite, including protoscoleces or cysts.
b Experimental infection in mice.
c Natural infection in sheep.
d Natural infection in cattle.
e Oral or intra-gastric administration.
f Intracystic injection administration.
g Intraperitoneal administration.
h Intravenous administration.
i Subcutaneous administration.