Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 30;5:118. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2018.00118

Table 1.

Summary table.

Description Distinguishing features “GMP” inspections International relevance
Canada (Health Canada)
  • Cell therapy products (CTPs) are considered drugs that must follow Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) requirements

  • Flexible risk-based approach is taken (i.e., accommodations to GMP may be made, as required, by the technology)

  • More stringent GMP approach throughout clinical trial phases

  • Establishment license not strictly required for any phase of clinical trials, although strategically necessary by phase 3

  • Reviewed by Biologics and Genetic Therapies Directorate (pre-market review group) under Division 5—Clinical Trial Application for all phases of clinical trials

  • No explicit evidence for meeting GMP is provided by Health Canada

  • Implicit evidence of meeting GMP standards is provided in a clinical trial “No Objection Letter”

United States (FDA)
  • CTPs are considered drugs that must follow GMP and GTP requirements

  • FDA relies on pre-market regulatory professionals to assess phase 1 products for clinical trials during Investigational New Drug (IND) submission reviews, while CT products for phase 2 and 3 require a manufacturing site registration

  • Establishment license required to manufacture phase 2 and 3 clinical trial products

  • Phase 1 clinical trial products reviewed under IND submissions by CBER (FDA)

  • Establishment registered with FDA, listed on DECRS

  • An establishment registration from US FDA indicates GMP compliance for phase 2 or 3 studies (but not phase 1)

  • This strongly supports Health Canada or EMA submissions

European Union (EMA)
  • Requirements for advanced therapy medicinal products well established, most defined out of the three ICH member jurisdictions under comparison

  • Manufacturing authorization required for all stages of clinical trial development

  • Inspections by a competent authority/qualified person (QP) of a member state

  • A QP site declaration indicates the site complies with EU GMP for all phases of study

  • This strongly supports Health Canada or US FDA submissions