Table 1.
Advantages and disadvantages of different RNA production methods to aid, in combination with Fig. 1, in the selection of the most suitable method
Method | Advantages | Disadvantages | |
---|---|---|---|
Recombinant overexpression | tRNA scaffolds | Cost-effective, high yields | Cloning steps required, insert must not interfere with scaffold folding, extensive downstream purification |
Circular RNAs | Increased stability toward exonucleases | Not fully developed, extensive downstream purification | |
Alternative hosts | Fast and easy purification from growth medium | Not fully developed, lower yield than Escherichia coli | |
T7 in vitro transcription | Well-established method, fast, easy, and reproducible | Lower size limitation (construct >10 nt), yields and purity are construct dependent | |
Enzymatic methods | Ribozyme cleavage and T4 ligation | Allows segmental labeling, production of small constructs (<10 nt) | Multiple enzymatic and purification steps required, low yield |
PLOR | Allows segmental labeling, fast protocol | New technology, relies on a noncommercial robotic platform, low yield for multiple labels/modifications | |
PCT | Exponential amplification of DNA template, cost-efficient, fast, and can incorporate modified nucleotides | New method, 1 reaction always produces 2 RNA fragments, construct sizes are limited (12 and 25 nt) | |
Chemical synthesis | Solid-phase chemical synthesis | Modifications possible, easy purification, fast, no sequence-specific optimization | Expensive equipment required, length limited to ~100 nt, limited availability and high price of labeled or modified phosphoramidites |
nt nucleotides, PCT polymerase chain transcription, PLOR position-selective labeling of RNA, tRNA transfer RNA