Table I.
Study Characteristics
Study | Country | N | Age | Location | Needle-related procedure | Type of study | Health status of sample | If clinical, condition | Quality score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Blount (1989) | USA | 23 | 5–13 | Hospital | BMA/LP | Observational | Clinical | ALL | 11 |
Blount (1990) | USA | 22 | 5–13 | Hospital | BMA/LP | Observational | Clinical | ALL | 12 |
Blount (1991) | USA | 22 | 5–13 | Hospital | BMA/LP | Observational | Clinical | ALL | 12 |
Blount (1992) | USA | 60 | 3–7 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 14 | |
Blount (1997) | USA | 77 | 4–7 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Observational | Healthy | 12 | |
Blount (2001) | USA | 60 | 3–7 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Observational | Healthy | 16 | |
Cohen (1997) | USA | 92 | 4–6 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 15 | |
Cohen (2000) | USA | 55 | 4–6 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Observational | Healthy | 16 | |
Cohen (2002) | USA | 61 | 3–7 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 16 | |
Cohen (2015) | USA | 90 | 4–6 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 14 | |
Frank (1995) | USA | 77 | 4–7 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Observational | Healthy | 15 | |
Gonzalez (1989) | USA | 47 | 1–8 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 15 | |
Gonzalez (1993) | USA | 42 | 3–7 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 15 | |
Manimala (2000) | USA | 82 | 4–6 | Primary health care clinic | Immunization | Experimental | Healthy | 15 | |
Manne (1992) | USA | 43 | 3–9 | Hospital | Venipuncture | Observational | Clinical | Cancer | 15 |
Manne (1994) | USA | 35 | 3–9 | Hospital | Venipuncture | Observational | Clinical | Cancer | 10 |
McCarthy (2010) | USA | 542 | 4–10 | Hospital | IV insertion | Observational | Healthy | 16 | |
Spagrud (2008) | Canada | 55 | 3–18 | Hospital | Venipuncture | Observational | Clinical | Cancer | 16 |
Taylor (2011) | Australia | 66 | 3–12 | Hospital | Venipuncture | Observational | Clinical | Acute illness | 15 |
Vervoort (2011) | Belgium | 44 | 8–15 | Hospital | Finger prick | Observational | Clinical | Type I diabetes | 14 |
Note. BMA/LP = Bone marrow aspiration/lumbar puncture; ALL = Acute lymphocytic leukemia.