Table 1.
Study | Participants | Intervention | Outcomes |
Risk of bias assessment
a
|
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3b | 4 | 5 | 6 | ||||
Sutton
et al. [1979]
Study design: randomized controlled, data analyzer blinded, crossover |
9 healthy trekkers M/F 5/4 Age range 22–36 years |
ACZ 250 mg/8 h (oral), total 5 doses Final altitude: 5360 m in North America |
Oxygen saturation Breathing frequency |
U | U | A | A | A | U |
Hackett
et al. [1987]
Study design: randomized controlled, double-blind, crossover |
4 healthy trekkers Male Age range 26–35 years |
ACZ 250 mg/8 h (oral), total 3 doses Final altitude: 4400 m in North America |
Hypoxic ventilatory response Sleep study |
U | U | A | U | A | U |
Fischer
et al. [2004]
Study design: randomized controlled, double-blind |
20 healthy trekkers Male ACZ/control 10/10 BMI <25 |
ACZ 250 mg twice daily (oral), for 4 days Final altitude: 3454 m in Switzerland |
Polysomnography Acute mountain sickness Pulse rate, Arterial blood gases Oxyhemoglobin saturation |
U | U | A | A | A | U |
Rodway
et al. [2011]
Study design: randomized Controlled |
8 healthy trekkers M/F 12/3c ACZ/control 4/4 Age range 25–55 years |
ACZ 125 mg/day (oral), for 1 night Final altitude: 5300 m in Nepal |
Heart rate Respiratory rate Oxygen saturation Tidal volume, Minute volume AHI |
A | U | A | U | A | U |
Nussbaumer-Ochsner et al. [2012]
Study design: randomized controlled, double-blind, crossover |
45 OSA patients M/F 42/3 Median age 64 years |
ACZ 250 mg twice daily (oral), for 3 nights Final altitude: 2590 m in Switzerland |
Polysomnography Vigilance, Symptoms Oxygen saturation AHI |
U | A | A | A | A | A |
Latshang
et al. [2012]
Study design: randomized controlled, double-blind, crossover |
51 OSA patients M/F 48/3 Median age 63 years |
ACZ 250/500 mg (morning /evening, oral), for 3 nights Final altitude: 2590 m in Switzerland |
Oxygen saturation AHI Sleep structure Vigilance Symptoms Adverse effects Exercise performance |
U | A | A | A | A | A |
Burgess
et al. [2014],
2014 Study design: randomized controlled, single-blind, crossover |
12 healthy trekkers M/F 8/4 Mean age 30 years |
ACZ 10 mg/kg (intravenous), for 1 night Final altitude: 5050 m in Nepal |
Arterial blood gas Cerebral blood flow Ventilatory response Sleep study |
U | U | A | U | A | U |
Caravita
et al. [2015]
Study design: randomized controlled, double-blind |
41 healthy trekkers ACZ 20 (M/F 10/10) Control 21 (M/F
11/10) Mean age 36 years |
ACZ 250 mg/day (oral), for 2 days Final altitude: 4559 m in Italy |
Resting ventilation Chemoreflex Cardiorespiratory sleep study |
U | U | A | U | A | A |
M, male; F, female; ACZ, acetazolamide; AHI, Apnea–Hypopnea Index; BMI, body mass index; OSA, obstructive sleep apnea; U, unclear; A, adequate.
Risk of bias assessment determined by the Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias, including: (1) random sequence generation; (2) allocation concealment; (3) blinding of participants and personnel; (4) blinding of outcome assessment; (5) incomplete outcome data; (6) selective reporting.
Though six studies that included healthy participants did not provide adequate information to permit the assessment of performance bias or were not double-blinded, the outcomes were judged not likely to be influenced by lack of blinding because sleep apnea and nocturnal oxygenation were unlikely to have a placebo effect.
The total 15 participants in the study that were assigned to 4 different treatment groups, of which ACZ and control group were included in this meta-analysis.