Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Med Care. 2018 Jun;56(6):497–504. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0000000000000910

Table 2.

Comparisons of Patient and Medical Encounter (Visit) Characteristics between Respondents and Non-Respondents1

Respondents
(n=8355)
Non-Respondents
(n=28202)

Patient Characteristics

Age in Years, Mean (SD) 57.1 (17.5) 47.8 (18.1)

Charlson Score (0-11 high), Mean (SD) 0.5 (1.1) 0.8 (1.5)

Charlson Group, no. (%)
 0 (Charlson Score=0) 5937 (71.8) 15225 (59.0)
 1 (Charlson Score=1) 1343 (16.2) 5527 (21.4)
 2 (Charlson Score=2) 555 (6.7) 2390 (9.3)
 3 (Charlson Score>2) 436 (5.3) 2661(10.3)

Gender, no. (%)
 Male 3014 (36.1) 10705 (38.0)
 Female 5341 (63.9) 17497 (62.0)

Race/Ethnicity, no. (%)
 Non-Hispanic White 5593 (66.9) 15486 (54.9)
 Non-Hispanic Black 2023 (24.2) 10070 (35.7)
 Other 739 (8.9) 2646 (9.4)

Place of Residence in Low-Income Zip Code2, no. (%)
 Yes 1286 (15.4) 5545 (19.7)
 No 7069 (84.6) 22657 (80.3)

Insurance type, no. (%)
 Private 6062 (72.6) 22492 (80.1)
 Medicare 1774 (21.2) 2439 (8.7)
 Medicaid 445 (5.3) 2982 (10.6)
 Self-Pay 74 (0.9) 155 (0.6)

Medical Encounter (Visit) Characteristics

Provider Type, no. (%)
 Physician 6862 (82.1) 22244 (79.4)
 Resident 616 (7.4) 4211 (15.0)
 Nurse Practitioner/Physician Assistant 832 (10.0) 1522 (5.4)
 Other (e.g. pharmacist, social worker) 45 (0.5) 28 (0.1)

Practice Number of Providers, Mean (SD)4 9.8 (3.5) 10.1 (3.3)

Practice Number of Patients, Mean (SD)4 12977.7 (4732.8) 13322.8 (4749.4)

Practice Type, no. (%)3
 Suburban 5049 (60.4) 15818 (56.1)
 Urban 3306 (39.6) 12384 (43.9)
1

p<0.05 in all comparisons

2

Low income zip codes specifically in West Philadelphia, the area surrounding the University of Pennsylvania versus all other zip codes

3

Type of practice where medical encounter occurred (University-affiliated suburban practices versus University urban practices)

4

Size characteristics of practice attended by patient (respondent or non-respondent)