Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 30;6(4):e102. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9341

Table 1.

Checklist of important considerations associated with the evaluation of data provided by wearables.

Factor Action/recommendation
Sensor characteristics
  • Scrutiny of each sensor

Software
  • Specify calculations/algorithms

  • Report the version of software and firmware involved

Raw data
  • Report sampling frequency

  • Report filtering techniques and aggregation

Durability
  • Report the durability and age of the device

Anatomical positioning
  • Report the precise anatomical positioning of sensors

  • Report signal reproducibility upon repeated putting on and taking off

  • Report considerations concerning positioning

  • Control for and describe potential interference

Study population
  • Describe the target population

  • Specify inclusion and exclusion criteria

  • Generalize to other populations only with great care

Exercise protocol
  • Describe conditions (eg, ambient temperature, altitude) in as much detail as possible

  • Investigate different forms of exercise (running, cycling, walking, moving freely)

  • Apply different intensities (lying, sitting, low and high intensity)

Confounders
  • Report any potential confounding factors

  • Perform assessment in both controlled and real-life scenarios

  • Check for potential crosstalk between devices

Assessment of reliability
  • Determine intradevice and interdevice reliability

  • Document intrasubject standard deviation

  • Report the coefficient of variation

  • Calculate the intraclass correlation coefficient

  • Recruit at least 50 participants

  • Report systematic bias

Assessment of sensitivity
  • Calculate the smallest worthwhile change

Assessment of validity
  • Choose an appropriate criterion measure and assess the reliability of this measure as well

  • Perform linear regression analysis

  • Calculate Pearson’s product-moment correlation