Shifts in whether a positive net biodiversity effect is explained by (A) complementarity effects at a local scale, but selection effects at a larger scale or (B) selection effects at a local scale, but complementarity effects at a larger scale Example levels of ecosystem functioning (arbitrary units) in monoculture (Mik) and mixture (Yik) for species i at place k. Biodiversity effects are quantified by Equations E1 and E2 in Box 2, assuming equal initial proportions RYE,ik = 0.5 for all i and k. For simplicity, only one time is considered. Values shown in B are approximate.