Table 1.
Two ‘best cancer doctor’ selection methodologies compared in this study
| Selection by the media personnel | Selection by the peer-evaluation system | |
| Methodology | Do not have open, specified methodology | Have open, specified methodology |
| Probably through media personnel’s network or information search | Systematic peer review and endorsement through survey | |
| Example | ‘This is world’s super doctor’ (Japan, Tokyo Broadcasting System Television (TBS)) | ‘Best doctor in America’ (the USA, Best Doctors) |
| ‘Fighting doctors, this is Japanese best doctor’ (Japan, Asahi TV) | ‘Best cancer doctor and hospital’(Korea, MK news media and Deloitte) | |
| ‘Best doctor’ (Korea, Educational Broadcasting System (EBS)) |