Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 17;90(1079):20170028. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20170028

Table 1.

Summary of in vitro studies of DNA damage indicators for blood samples exposed with, or without iodinated contrast media (ICM)

Study (year of publication) Assay type Dose (mGy) Time since exposure Equipment Quoted tube potential/filtration Iodine concentration (mg I ml–1) Foci per cell (no ICM) Foci per cell (with ICM) ICM associated increase in absolute foci (%) ICM associated increase in excess foci (%)
Callisen (1979) Lymphocyte survival Unclear   Faxitron 70 kV/4.2 mm Al 3.7c     30  
7.4c 70
18.5c 270
Hadnegy (1982) Lymphocyte dicentrics & rings 500   Not stated 250 kV/1 mm Al, 1 mm Cu 5.6c (Urografin)   0.064    
500 11.1c (Urografin) 0.073
500 22.2c (Urografin) 0.119
560 19.2c (Hexabrix) 0.135
940 19.2c (Hexabrix) 0.314
1250 19.2c (Hexabrix) 0.465
1880 19.2c (Hexabrix) 1.024
Jost (2009) Lymphocyte dicentrics 0   Siemens Sensation 64 (CT) n/a 5.0 0.0003 0    
25 120 kV 5.0 0.0011 0.0014 27
50 120 kV 5.0 0.0021 0.0025 19
100 120 kV 5.0 0.0042 0.0059 40
1000 120 kV 5.0 0.0920 0.1603 74
0 n/a 50.0 0.0003 0  
25 120 kV 50.0 0.0011 0.0082 645
50 120 kV 50.0 0.0021 0.0213 914
100 120 kV 50.0 0.0042 0.0444 957
1000 120 kV 50.0 0.0920 0.9094 888
Jost (2009) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX56 25   Siemens Sensation 64 (CT) 120 kV 5.0 0.580 0.952 64  
50 120 kV 5.0 0.911 0.726 −20
100 120 kV 5.0 1.503 1.547 3
1000 120 kV 5.0 4.697 6.351 35
25 120 kV 50.0 0.580 0.892 54
50 120 kV 50.0 0.911 2.232 145
100 120 kV 50.0 1.503 3.983 165
1000 120 kV 50.0 4.697 11.709 149
Grudzenski (2009) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX 10 5 min Philips PW2184 (radiography tube) 90 kV/1 mm Al 33.0 (Iopromide) 0.217a,d 0.359a,d   66
30 m 0.133a,d 0.266a,d 100
2.5 h 0.080a,d 0.190a,d 138
5 h 0.032a,d 0.109ad 241
500 5 min Philips PW2184 (radiography tube) 90 kV/1 mm Al 33.0 (Iopromide) 9.27a,d 15.00a,d   62
30 min 5.51a,d 9.90a,d 80
2.5 h 3.20 a,d 6.58a,d 106
5 h 1.56a,d 3.29a,d 111
500 5 min 662 keV γ source (Cs-137) n/a 33.0 (Iopromide) 8.34 a,d 7.62ad   10
30 min 5.77ad 5.51a,d 5
2.5 h 4.08a,d 4.52ad −10
5 h 2.00a,d 1.92a,d 4
Grudzenski (2009) Fibroblast γ-H2AX 1500 30 min Philips PW2184 (radiography tube) 90 kV/1 mm Al 33.0 (Iopromide) 26.7a,d 36.5a,d   37
2.5 h 10.6a,d 18.6a,d 75
5 h 5.9a,d 8.4a,d 42
Fibroblast γ-H2AX 1500 30 min 90 kV/1 mm Al 33.0 (Iomeprol) 26.7a,d 37.2a,d   39
2.5 h 10.6a,d 16.9a,d 59
5 h 5.9a,d 8.4a,d 42
Fibroblast 53bp1 1500 30 min 90 kV/1 mm Al 33.0 (Iopromide) 26.5a,d 34.8a,d   31
2.5 h 10.9a,d 17.2a,d 58
5 h 5.9a,d 9.5a,d 61
Fibroblast 53bp1 1500 30 min 90 kV/1 mm Al 33.0 (Iomeprol) 26.5a,d 35.9a,d   36
2.5 h 10.9a,d 17.2a,d 58
5 h 5.9a,d 10.2a,d 73
Pathe (2011) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX 0 Immediate n/a n/a 37.0c (Iopromide 370) 0.18 0.12 −33  
30 min 0.05 0.10 100  
1 h 0.04 0.11 175  
2 h 0.05 0.10 100  
24 h 0.08 0.03 −63  
20 Immediate Siemens Multix M (radiography) 102 kV 0.55 1.29 135 216
30 min 0.63 1.23 95 95
1 h 0.51 0.9 76 68
2 h 0.53 0.81 53 48
24 h 0.28 0.3 7 35
100 Immediate 102 kV 1.57 2.98 90 106
30 min 1.92 3.18 66 65
1 h 1.50 2.39 59 56
2 h 1.05 2.11 101 101
24 h 0.42 0.36 −14 −3
200 Immediate 102 kV 3.73 4.31 16 18
30 min 3.24 4.79 48 47
1 h 2.38 3.38 42 40
2 h 2.37 2.59 9 7
24 h 0.52 0.36 −31 −25
1000 Immediate 102 kV 6.10 9.09 49 52
30 min 6.32 8.49 34 34
1 h 4.65 5.94 28 26
2 h 4.56 5.01 10 9
24 h 1.26 1.99 58 66
Beels (2012) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX 5   Philips MG420 generator, MCN420 tube 100 kV/2 mm Al 5.0 0.73d 0.71d −4d  
10.0 0.73d 0.80d 9d
20.0 0.73d 0.70d −5d
10   5.0 0.96d 1.13d 16d
10.0 0.96d 0.89d −8d
20.0 0.96d 0.89d −8d
50   5.0 1.41d 1.51d 6d
10.0 1.41d 1.55d 9d
20.0 1.41d 1.51d 6d
Deinzer (2014) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX 20   Siemens Axiom Multix MT 102 kV 7.5 0.240 0.313b 30  
15.0 0.240 0.379b 58
500   7.5 3.581 3.956b 10
15.0 3.581 4.926b 38
Gould (2015) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX 70   Carestream DRX-Evolution (radiography) 120 kV 15.0     44  
17.5 82
30.0 89
35.0 111
45.0 89
52.5 99
Gould (2015) Lymphocyte γ-H2AX 140   Carestream DRX-Evolution (radiography) 120 kV 15.0     42  
17.5 50
30.0 75
35.0 64
45.0 86
52.5 76
250   120 kV 15.0     14  
17.5 31
30.0 35
35.0 35
45.0 49
52.5 49
450   120 kV 15.0     11  
17.5 36
30.0 25
35.0 48
45.0 33
52.5 59
a

Foci numbers in excess of baseline levels.

b

Mean of 7 contrast media products.

c

Calculated by current authors based on data quoted in original paper.

d

Data not quoted numerically. Read from figure(s).