Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 6;114(40):665–672. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.2017.0665

eTable 1. Details of included studies.

Study When data collected Where data collected Sample type Definition of homelessness Recruitment strategy Accommodation status Sample size Tools Diagnostic criteria Mean age Percentage female Professional interviewer Participation rate, %
Fichter, 1996, 1997, 1999 (32, 37, 39); Meller, 2000 (29) 1989 to 1990 Munich (male participants only) Representative random sample No home in Munich area for at least 30 days before interview Common locations for the homeless (soup kitchens, emergency shelters, outdoor locations, etc.) 3 categories:
I. outdoors (49)
II. with beds
(25) III. meals/advice (72)
146 DIS-III, MMSE DSM-III 43 0 No*2 85
Greifenhagen, 1997(31); Meller, 2000 (29) 1989 to 1990 Munich (female participants only) Representative random sample No home in Munich area for at least 30 days before interview (except women‘s shelters) Common locations for the homeless (soup kitchens, emergency shelters, outdoor locations, etc.) 3 categories:
I. outdoors (12)
II. with beds (14)
III. meals/advice (6)
32 DIS-III, MMSE DSM-III 35.5 100 No*2 89
Reker, 1997 (26) 1990 Münster Data collected on all residents of a shelter for homeless men (stay >3 months) >3 months living in city shelter City shelter for homeless men City shelter for homeless men (52) 52 Semi-structured interview, GAF ICD-10 45.0 0 Yes 78.8
Podschus, 1995 (28); Dufeu, 1996 (40) 1993 to 1994 Berlin Random sample (restaurant for the homeless) Section 72 of the German FWA: homelessness due to social situation City mission soup kitchen Sleeping rough (25),
boarding houses (46), with friends (8), emergency accommodation (3), hostel (3), sheltered accommodation (2)
72 CIDI*1, MMSE, GAF ICD-10 40.5 0 Not stated 85
Fichter, 2006 (36); Quadflieg, 2007 (27) 1994 to 1996 Munich Data collected longitudinally on all homeless people in line with allocation of living space At least one of the following in the last 30 days: (1) accommodation in home of friends or relatives with at least 3 changes of accommodation, (2) accommodation at emergency shelter for the homeless, (3) accommodation in places not intended as such (e.g. parks) Recruitment in line with accommodation (homes with therapeutic assistance, homeless shelters, social housing) No information on previous housing status, at time of questioning in homes with therapeutic assistance (6), homeless shelters (75), social housing (13) 129 SCID, MMSE, FPI-R (emotional lability scale), GAF, SCL-90-R (scales: compulsiveness, insecurity on social contact, depression, anxiety, aggression, hostility) DSM-IV 44.4 15.5 Not stated Not stated
Fichter, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003, 2005 (11, 33 to 35, 38) 1994 to 1996 Munich Representative random sample No home in Munich area for at least 30 days before interview Common locations for the homeless (soup kitchens, emergency shelters, outdoor locations, etc.) 3 categories:
I. outdoors (12)
II. with beds (158)
III. meals/advice (95)
265 SCID, MMSE DSM-IV 44.7 0 No*2 88
Völlm, 2004 (12, 21) 1997 to 1999 Mannheim repräsentative Zufallsstichprobe No room or home on basis of rent agreement (refugees excluded) Common locations for the homeless (streets, shelters, soup kitchens, advice centers) 3 categories:
I. sleeping rough (18)
II. homes and shelters for the homeless (66)
III. hostels providing rehabilitation/therapy (18)
102 SCID, MLDL, physical examination DSM-IV 40.0 13,7 Not stated Not stated
Salize, 2001, 2002 (23, 24, e3) 1996 Dortmund Representative random sample Only „literally homeless“ as defined by Rossi (e2) Advice centers and city shelters „Sleeping rough“ (82) 82 CIDI*1, semi-structured interview in line with AMDP, physical examination ICD-10 41.4 0 Yes 81.5
Torchalla, 2004 (22) 2001 Tübingen Data collected on all homeless women in Tübingen Section 72 of German FWA: persons without adequate or permanent accommodation, extended to less obvious forms, e.g. shared accommodation Advice centers, recruitment by professional support workers Hospital (1), motor home (2), friends/acquaintances (6), women‘s shelter (5), assigned accommodation (2) 17 SCID, BeLP DSM-IV 29 100 Not stated 77.3
Längle, 2005 (30) 2002 to 2003 Tübingen Data collected on all appropriate individuals Section 72 of German FWA: persons without adequate or permanent accommodation Common locations for the homeless (soup kitchens, emergency shelters, outdoor locations, etc.), recruitment by professional support workers Homeless shelters and emergency accommodation 91 SCID, BML, MMSE, MWT-B, WAIS-R, GAF, BeLP ICD-10 40.0 0 Yes 60. 3
Brönner, 2013 (e1); Jahn 2014 (2) 2010 to 2012 Munich Representative random sample Residents of homeless shelters in Munich and surrounding areas (long-term assistance, reintegration, low-threshold assistance, assistance in line with Section 53 et seq. of SSC XII, counseling/emergency accommodation, sheltered accommodation) Facilities for the homeless in Munich and surrounding areas Long-term assistance (61), housing according to Section 53 (52), low-threshold assistance (40), reintegration (32), emergency accommodation (28), sheltered accommodation complexes (19) 232 SCID, MALT, BDI, mini ICF-APP, SF-36, B-L, CGI, MMSE, WAIS DSM-IV 48.1 20,7 Not stated 55

*1Parts on dependency disorders and psychosomatic disorders; *2Trained laypeople

AMDP, Working Group for Methods and Documentation in Psychiatry (Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Methodik und Dokumentation in der Psychiatrie); BDI: Beck Depression Inventory; BeLP: Berlin Quality of Life Profile (Berliner Lebensqualitätsprofil); B-L: Complaints List (Beschwerdeliste): BML: Brunswick List of Features (Braunschweiger Merkmalsliste) for chronic, multiply-impaired alcoholics FWA: Federal Welfare Act; CIDI: Composite International Diagnostic Interview; CGI: Clinical Global Impression Scale; DIS: Diagnostic Interview Schedule; FPI-R: Freiburg Personality Inventory (Freiburger Persönlichkeitsinventar) – Revision; GAF: Global Assessment of Functioning; WAIS-R: Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale – Revision; MALT: Munich Alcoholism Test (Münchner Alkoholismustest); Mini-ICF-APP: Mini-ICF-APP Social Functioning Scale; MLDL: Munich Quality of Life List (Münchner Lebensqualitäts-Dimensionen-Liste); MMSE: Mini-Mental Status Examination; MWT-B: Multiple-Choice Vocabulary Test (Mehrfachwahl-Wortschatztest), version B; SCID: Structured Clinical Interview for DSM; SCL-90-R: Symptom Checklist 90 – Revised; SF-36: Short-Form Health Survey; SSC: Social Security Code; WAIS: Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale