Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 6;114(40):665–672. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.2017.0665

eTable 2. Findings of subgroup analysis.

Disorder type Pooled prevalence (random-effects model) Prevalence range [95% confidence interval] p I2 [95% confidence interval] No. of studies
All mental illness*1 77.5% 65.1 to 93.8% [72.4; 82.3] 0.000 74.61 [53.98; 86.00] 11
Axis I disorders 77.4% 65.1 to 93.8% [71.3; 82.9] 0.000 75.93 [51.8; 87.98] 8
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards 73.3% 70.6 to 74.0% [68.5; 77.9] 0.898 0.00 [0.00; 3.24] 3
Data collected before 2000 80.6% 56.7 to 93.8% [71.1; 88.5] 0.000 85.42 [67.78; 93.4] 5
Homeless women only 83.3% 70.6 to 93.8% [56.9; 100.0] 0.038 76.80 [0.00; 94.71] 2
Homeless men only 76.6 % 65.1 to 90.3% [68.7; 83.7] 0.000 80.87 [55.33; 91.81] 5
Participation rate >80% 84.0% 73.4 to 93.8% [74.7; 91.6] 0.001 81.90 [53.13; 93.01] 4
Participation rate <80% 73.3% 70.6 to 74.0% [68.5; 77.9] 0.000 0.00 [0.00; 3.24] 3
Sample size >100 73.6% 65.1 to 80.8% [68.0; 78.8] 0.034 65.31 [0.00; 88.21] 4
Sample size <100 83.4% 70.6 to 93.8% [70.1; 93.5] 0.004 77.71 [39.62; 91.77] 4
Interviewers: professional / / / / / 1
Interviewers: non-professional 81.5% 73.4 to 93.8% [71.4; 89.9] 0.009 78.9 [32.48; 93.41] 3
Psychotic illnesses 8.3% 2.3 to 34.4% [5.4; 11.8] 0.002 65.50 [32.39; 82.40] 10
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards 8.6% 7.7 to 11.8% [3.9; 14.7] 0.486 0.00 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Data collected before 2000 8.2% 2.3 to 34.4% [4.9; 12.2] 0.001 72.31 [43.22; 86.50] 8
Homeless women only 23.1% 11.8 to 34.4% [5.0; 47.7] 0.090 76.80 [0.00; 92.08] 2
Homeless men only 7.6% 4.9 to 9.6% [5.8; 9.7] 0.791 0.00 [0.00; 47.19] 6
Participation rate >80% 9.8% 4.9 to 34.4% [4.9; 16.0] 0.002 77.05 [44.38; 90.53] 5
Participation rate <80% 6.6% 2.3 to 11.8% [3.5; 10.5] 0.135 43.01 [0.00; 79.06] 5
Sample size >100 6.2% 2.3 to 9.6% [3.6; 9.5] 0.076 56.32 [0.00; 85.52] 4
Sample size <100 10.8% 4.9 to 34.4% [5.4; 17.8] 0.007 68.97 [26.91; 86.83] 6
Interviewers: professional 7.4% 4.9 to 9.6% [4.3; 11.2] 0.553 0.00 [0.00; 82.46] 3
Interviewers: non-professional 12.9% 6.6 to 34.4% [4.2; 25.1] 0.000 87.4 [64.18; 95.54] 3
Affective disorders 15.2% 5.6 to 46.9% [9.8; 21.5] 0.000 82.66 [67.18; 90.84] 8
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards / / / / / 1
Data collected before 2000 15.8% 5.6 to 46.9% [9.6; 23.1] 0.000 84.71 [70.30; 92.13] 7
Homeless women only / / / / / 1
Homeless men only 14.6% 5.6 to 24.0% [9.4; 20.6] 0.004 73.88 [35.04; 89.5] 5
Participation rate >80% 19.2% 5.6 to 46.9% [10.9; 29.0] 0.000 85.32 [67.52; 93.36] 5
Participation rate <80% / / / / / 1
Sample size >100 14.1% 6.9 to 24.0% [8.2; 21.2] 0.001 81.63 [52.29; 92.93] 4
Sample size <100 16.5% 5.6 to 46.9% [5.4; 31.4] 0.000 87.46 [70.1; 94.74] 4
Interviewers: professional 13.4% 11.0 to 15.9% [8.7; 18.9] 0.353 0.00 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Interviewers: non-professional 25.9% 16.3 to 46.9% [14.0; 39.7] 0.001 86.31 [60.44; 95.26] 3
Major depression 11.6% 0.00 to 40.6% [4.4; 21.3] 0.000 87.47 [73.15; 94.15] 5
Substance-related disorders 60.9% 47.1 to 74.0% [53.1; 68.5] 0.003 72.60 [36.88; 88.10] 6
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards / / / / / 1
Data collected before 2000 62.1% 51.9 to 74.0% [53.9; 69.9] 0.002 75.98 [41.24; 90.18] 5
Homeless women only 58.3 % 47.1 to 65.6 % [40.4; 75.2] 0.220 33.54 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Homeless men only 68.5 % 63.0 to 74.0 % [57.2; 78.7] 0.023 80.71 [17.52; 95.49] 2
Participation rate >80% 67.7 % 63.0 to 74.0 % [59.3; 75.6] 0.073 61.73 [0.00; 89.08] 3
Participation rate <80% / / / / / 1
Sample size >100 61.6 % 51.9 to 74.0 % [52.3; 70.5] 0.001 81.90 [53.01; 93.00] 4
Sample size <100 58.3 % 47.1 to 65.6 % [40.4; 75.2] 0.220 33.54 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Interviewers: professional / / / / / 0
Interviewers: non-professional 67.7 % 63.0 to 74.0 % [59.3; 75.6] 0.073 61.73 [0.00; 89.08] 3
Alcohol dependency 55.4 % 43.1 to 68.1 % [49.2; 61.5] 0.002 69.66 [36.82; 85.43] 8
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards / / / / / 1
Data collected before 2000 55.6 % 43.1 to 68.1 % [48.5; 62.5] 0.001 73.72 [43.74; 87.73] 7
Homeless women only 52.0 % 46.9 to 53.8 % [43.2; 60.8] 0.503 0.00 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Homeless men only 61.2 % 51.2 to 68.1 % [54.2; 68.0] 0.051 61.30 [0.00; 87.03] 4
Participation rate >80% 59.6 % 46.9 to 68.1 % [52.7; 66.4] 0.038 60.58 [0.00; 85.23] 5
Participation rate <80% / / / / / 1
Sample size >100 55.1 % 43.1 to 67.1 % [45.6; 64.4] 0.001 82.08 [53.71; 93.06] 4
Sample size <100 55.8 % 46.9 to 68.1 % [47.0; 64.4] 0.097 52.52 [0.00; 84.31] 4
Interviewers: professional / / / / / 1
Interviewers: non-professional 59.7 % 46.9 to 67.1 % [50.8; 68.4] 0.061 64.28 [0.00; 89.76] 3
Drug dependency 13.9 % 4.4 to 25.3 % [7.2; 22.2] 0.000 86.07 [71.78; 93.12] 6
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards / / / / / 1
Data collected before 2000 11.7 % 4.4 to 21.9 % [6.0; 18.8] 0.000 80.14 [53.26; 91.56] 5
Homeless women only 24.6 % 21.9 to 25.3 % [17.4; 32.6] 0.746 0.00 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Homeless men only 10.1 % 4.4 to 17.1 % [4.8; 16.9] 0.002 80.27 [47.92; 92.52] 4
Participation rate >80% 11.7 % 4.4 to 21.9 % [6.0; 18.8] 0.000 80.14 [53.26; 91.56] 5
Participation rate <80% / / / / / 1
Sample size >100 6.5 % 4.4 to 10.3 % [1.9; 13.5] 0.025 80.06 [14.29; 95.36] 2
Sample size <100 19.1 % 12.5 to 25.3 % [13.6; 25.3] 0.203 34.85 [0.00; 77.23] 4
Interviewers: professional / / / / / 1
Interviewers: non-professional 9.6 % 4.4 to 21.9 % [3.0; 19.0] 0.003 83.30 [49.35; 94.49] 3
Anxiety disorders 17.6 % 11.6 to 35.3 % [12.9; 22.8] 0.034 58.66 [0.00; 83.23] 6
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards 23.7 % 18.7 to 35.3 % [9.7; 41.0] 0.139 54.38 [0.00; 88.82] 2
Data collected before 2000 15.8 % 11.6 to 28.1 % [11.1; 21.1] 0.072 57.06 [0.00; 85.75] 4
Homeless women only 30.9 % 28.1 to 35.3 % [18.7; 44.6] 0.598 0.00 [0.00; 0.00] 2
Homeless men only 14.1 % 11.6 to 18.7 % [10.5; 18.1] 0.232 31.46 [0.00; 92.87] 3
Participation rate >80% 15.3 % 11.6 to 28.1 % [9.3; 22.3] 0.062 64.08 [0.00; 89.71] 3
Participation rate <80% 23.7 % 18.7 to 35.3 % [9.7; 41.0] 0.139 54.38 [0.00; 88.82] 2
Sample size >100 14.1 % 11.6 to 17.8 % [10.7; 17.9] 0.240 29.96 [0.00; 92.72] 3
Sample size <100 24.3 % 18.7 to 35.3 % [15.4; 34.3] 0.235 30.98 [0.00; 92.82] 3
Interviewers: professional / / / / / 1
Interviewers: non-professional 15.3 % 11.6 to 28.1 % [9.3; 22.3] 0.062 64.08 [0.00; 89.71] 3
Cognitive deficit*2 11.7 % 0.00 to 35.2 % [6.0; 18.9] 0.000 86.65 [74.68; 92.96] 7
Subgroup analyses:
Data collected from 2000 onwards / / / / / 1
Data collected before 2000 9.5 % 0.00 to 15.3 % [6.2; 13.3] 0.033 58.89 [0.00; 83.32] 6
Homeless women only / / / / / 1
Homeless men only 15.5 % 8.9 to 35.2 % [8.2; 24.6] 0.000 87.08 [72.15; 94.01] 5
Participation rate >80% 9.8 % 0.00 to 15.3 % [5.8; 14.6] 0.024 64.56 [6.90; 86.51] 5
Participation rate <80% / / / / / 1
Sample size >100 9.2 % 7.4 to 9.9 % [6.9; 11.7] 0.746 0.00 [0.00; 64.44] 3
Sample size <100 13.2 % 0.00 to 35.2 % [2.3; 29.7] 0.000 90.37 [78.32; 95.72] 4
Interviewers: professional 23.1 % 14.6 to 35.2 % [5.7; 46.4] 0.002 89.83 [62.50; 97.24] 2
Interviewers: non-professional 6.8 % 0.00 to 9.99 % [2.6; 12.6] 0.040 68.98 [0.00; 90.97] 3
Personality disorders 29.1 % 14.7 to 55.1 % [5.6; 59.5] 0.000 96.84 [93.57; 98.45] 3

*1Some studies reported point prevalences of mental illness, including personality disorders, with no further differentiation of Axis I disorders. Others reported only Axis I disorders and did not record information on personality disorders. Total mental illness summarizes all 11 studies and covers all reported mental illness, regardless of whether a distinction was made between Axis I and Axis II disorders. *2Based on the Mini-Mental Status Examination.