Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 23;115(12):200–207. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.2018.0200

eTable 4. Overall results for the comparison of intraoral appliances vs placebo on the AHI.

Data Trials Effect 95% CI p 95% PrI τ2 I2 (%)
Meta-analysis MD 12 –11.69 [–15.38; –8.01] <0.001 –22.55; –0.85 20.15 93.6
Factor Data Trials Effect 95% CI p τ2 I2 (%)
Follow-up (months) Coefficient 11 0.25 [–0.24; 0.75] 0.273 21.23 94.7
Constant –14.40 [–21.20; –7.61] 0.001
% of maximum
protrusion
Coefficient 8 0.03 [–0.42; 0.48] 0.87 34.21 96.3
Constant –14.18 [–48.70; 20.34] 0.354
Appliance type
(thermoplastic vs
impression-based)
Coefficient 13 6.25 [–3.73; 16.24] 0.196 17.12 89.4
Constant –12.17 [–15.68; 8.66] <0.001
Appliance type (1- or 2-piece) Coefficient 9 –0.09 [–11.25; 11.08] 0.986 15.79 87.9
Constant –14.24 [–24.81; –4.30] 0.012
Baseline-BMI (kg/m2) Coefficient 12 1.94 [–0.84; 4.72] 0.152 17.42 88.7
Constant –68.59 [–150.39; 13.21] 0.091
Baseline AHI
(events/hour)
Coefficient 11 –0.53 [–0.72; –0.34] <0.001 2.84 46.3
Constant 1.17 [–3.64; 5.99] 0.595
Baseline age (years) Coefficient 12 0.44 [–1.05; 1.93] 0.524 21.46 91.3
Constant –33.59 [–107.42; 40.25] 0.335
Ratio of male patients Coefficient 12 –28.65 [–78.34; 21.05] 0.228 18.8 93.7
Constant 10.39 [–28.05; 48.82] 0.561
Total sample Coefficient 12 0.14 [0.04; 0.24] 0.01 9.78 73.7
Constant –19.13 [–25.29; –12.98] <0.001
Study design
(crossover or parallel)
Coefficient 12 –0.52 [–8.85; 7.81] 0.892 22.5 94.2
Constant –11.38 [–18.25; 4.51] 0.004
Data type 1 Coefficient 12 –1.20 [–10.98; 8.58] 0.79 22.39 94.2
Constant –11.49 [–15.81; –7.17] <0.001
Data type 2 Coefficient 12 8.07 [–1.72; 17.86] 0.096 15.9 89.2
Constant –12.77 [–16.47; –9.07] <0.001
Data type 1 Coefficient 12 0.22 [–9.36; 9.79] 0.274 18.15 90.2
Data type 2 Coefficient 8.12 [–2.63; 18.88]
Constant –12.82 [–17.25; –8.39 <0.001
Data Trials Effect 95% CI p
Reporting bias
(Egger’s test)
Coefficient 12 –1.24 [–5.35; 2.87] 0.516

CI. confidence interval; PrI. predictive interval; MD. mean difference; BMI. body mass index; Data type 1. origin of data used in the analysis 1 (increment calculated from parallel or cross-over trials); Data type 2. origin of data used in the analysis 2 (increment calculated from final values of cross-over trials)