Skip to main content
. 2017 Winter;16(Suppl):99–111.

Table 1.

Characteristic of included studies in meta-analysis.

Author(s)
&
Year of Publication
Treatment Duration
(Week(s))
Age
(Mean years)
Attrition Percent Isoflavone Dose (mg) Protein Type of Treatments Type of Control Group No. of patients in treatment groups No. of patients in control groups Randomization Technique Blinding Intention-to-treat reporting Two groups were similar before the treatment
Baird et al.,
1995
4 45-65 6% 165 No Protein Regular regimen 63 24 No Yes Yes No
D’Anna et al.,
2007
48 50-70 27 No A tablet containing isoflavone supplement placebo 198 191 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Knight et al., 2001 12 53 16% 134 Yes An isoflavone supplementation in the form of a powdered drink Placebo 9 11 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Radhakrishnan et al., 2009 24 53 15% 75 Yes Soy Powder Placebo 44 41 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Chiechi et al., 2003 24 53 43% 47 Yes Protein Regular regimen 22 41 No Yes No Yes
Levis et al., 2011 52 to 104 52 43% 200 No Soy tablet Placebo 81 71 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Murkies et al., 1995 6 to
12
54 18% Unidentified No Soy flour supplementation Wheat flour 23 24 Yes Yes No Yes
Carmignani et al., 2010 16 51 0 90 Yes Soy Powder Placebo 20 patients received conjugated estrogen
&
20 patients received
soy
20 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Knight et al., 1999 12 51 5% Low dose of 40 mgs / High dose of 160 mgs - Red clover Placebo 13 patients in high-dose group 
&
12 patients in low-dose group
12 Yes Yes No Yes
Colli et al., 2012 24 53 17% 100 mgs of flaxseed lignan extract/ flaxseed bread/ 270 mgs of lignans - Flaxseed Placebo 56 patients using flaxseed extract/ 54 patients using flaxseed bread 56 Yes Yes No Yes