Table 1.
A summary of the different studies investigating the use of steroid tape in non-scar, dermatological patients categorised based on the Joanna Briggs Institute Levels of Evidence and Grades of Recommendation Working Party levels 1–5.6
Authors | Type of study/Level of evidence | Disease | Patient no. | Age range (years) | Steroid | Total body surface area | Daily duration of application | Duration of treatment | Symptomatic response |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Labow TA et al., 196931 | Double-blinded controlled trial- 1 | Psoriasis | 21 (32 sites treated with steroid tape and 38 with placebo) | Unspecified range; median: 51 years | Flurandrenolone tape (4 μg/cm2) | Four sites treated per patient (two with active tape and two with placebo) | 24 h | 2 weeks (2 dropouts) | 26/32 steroid tape vs. 6/38 placebo sites showed overall improvement (P <0.001) |
Kikuchi I and Jono M, 197632 | Case series – 4 | Granuloma gluteale infantum | 2 | 3- and 6-month-old | 0.025% fluocinolone acetonide (case 1) and flurandrenolide tape (case 2) | Unspecified | 1–2 months of daily application (case 1), unspecified (case 2) | 1–2 months (case 1); unspecified (case 2) | Good response (noticeable flattening of lesions) |
Berger JE and Helm F, 197010 | Case series– 4 | Range of subacute and chronic dermatoses | 155 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Areas of 1–24 inches in maximum dimension | 3–24 h daily | 1 day to 6 weeks | 61/155 showed good results and 38/155 moderate results |
Gomez F and Schorr WF, 196833 | Case series– 4 | Dermatoses including psoriasis, lichen, contact dermatitis | 42 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Unspecified | 24 h | 3 weeks (one dropout at day 6) | 36/42 showed excellent to good results |
Riley K, 196918 | Case series– 4 | Dermatoses including psoriasis, lichen disorders | 39 | 8–77 years | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Maximum dimension 4 inches | Night-time or 24 h on–24 h off regimen | Unspecified | 28/39 showed good to excellent results, 7 partial improvement |
Burrows D, 196934 | Case series– 4 | Dermatoses including lupus erythematosus, psoriasis, lichen disorders | 41 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Less than 10% of total body surface area | 12–24 h | Unspecified | 19/41 obtained clearance of lesions and 12/41 showed improvement |
Sellers FM, 197035 | Case series – 4 | Psoriasis and lichen simplex/ planus | 15 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4 μg/cm2) | Unspecified | 12 h | Unspecified | All patients reported improvement |
Ronchese F, 196936 | Case series – 4 | Dermatoses including lichen chronicus, psoriasis | 126 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Unspecified | Bedtime | Unspecified | Poor reporting of outcomes but positive descriptive data provided |
Nurse DS, 197437 | Case series – 4 | Dermatoses including, psoriasis and eczema | 172 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Unspecified | Unspecified | 2–63 days | Excellent results in 63 patients and good results in 60 patients |
Fields RJ and Magpantay R, 196838 | Case series – 4 | Dermatoses including psoriasis, eczema, contact dermatitis | 56 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Unspecified | Overnight-24 h | Unspecified | Excellent response in 15/56 and good in 29/56 patients |
Boatwright H, 196939 | Case series– 4 | Dermatoses including lichen, atopic/contact dermatitis, lupus erythematosus | 915 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Unspecified | Unspecified | Unspecified | Excellent response in 42.19%, good response in 30.27% and partial improvement in 14.86% |
Kestel JL, 197140 | Case report – 4 | Neurodermatitis | 1 | 14 | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Unspecified | Overnight | Unspecified | Good response |
Azulay DR, 198541 | Case report– 4 | Isotretinoin associated granulation tissue | 1 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolide tape | Unspecified | Unspecified | Unspecified | Good response |
Ronchese F, 197442 | Case report– 4 | Recurrent periungual myxoid cysts | 5 | Unspecified | Flurandrenolone tape (4μg/cm2) | Small area corresponding to periungual myxoid cysts | Cycle of 24 h tape application followed by 24 h of steroid cream | 2–3 months | Excellent response with no recurrence for up to 3 years |