Table 2.
Study ID | Country | Year | Condition | Guideline recommendation (summary) | |
Tyrstrup et al 14 | Sweden | 2010 | Children 1–12 years with uncomplicated AOM | First line | Wait-and-see for 3 days |
Second line | Penicillin V (first choice antibiotic) | ||||
Palma et al 11 | Italy | 2010 | Children >2 years with uncomplicated, non-severe AOM |
First line | Analgesics, wait-and-see for 3 days |
Second line | First choice: high-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) Second choice: cephalosporin |
||||
Children 6 months–2 years with uncomplicated AOM Children >2 years with severe AOM* | First line | First choice: high-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) Second choice: cephalosporin |
|||
Levy et al 9 | France | 2011 | Children >2 years with uncomplicated AOM | First line | Wait-and-see, reassessment after 48–72 hours |
Second line | High-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) | ||||
Children <2 years with uncomplicated AOM Children >2 years with severe AOM* |
First line | High-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) | |||
Second line | Amoxicillin/clavulanic-acid or cefpodoxime in case of treatment failure | ||||
McGrath et al 10 | USA | 2004 | Children >2 years with uncomplicated, non-severe AOM |
First line | Analgesics, wait-and-see for 3 days |
Second line | First choice: high-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) Second choice: cephalosporin |
||||
Children 6 months–2 years with uncomplicated AOM Children >2 years with severe AOM* | First line | First choice: high-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) Second choice: cephalosporin |
|||
Coco et al 8 | USA | 2004 | Children >2 years with uncomplicated, non-severe AOM |
First line | Analgesics, wait-and-see for 3 days |
Second line | First choice: high-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) Second choice: cephalosporin |
||||
Children 6 months–2 years with uncomplicated AOM Children >2 years with severe AOM* | First line | First choice: high-dose amoxicillin (80–90 mg per kg per day) Second choice: cephalosporin |
|||
Thompson et al 13 | UK | 2003 2004 |
Children >2 years with uncomplicated, non-severe AOM |
First line | Analgesics, wait-and-see for 24–72 hours |
Second line | Amoxicillin thrice daily 125–250 mg, for 5 days Second choice: erythromycin, azithromycin or clarithromycin |
||||
Children <2 years or severe AOM or recurrent infections | First line | Amoxicillin thrice daily 125–250 mg, for 5 days | |||
Rios, et al 12 | Spain | 2001 | Children >6 months with uncomplicated AOM | First line | High-dose amoxicillin for a minimum of 5 days |
Second line | Amoxicillin/clavulanic-acid or ceftriaxone if no response within 48–72 hours | ||||
Children <6 months with uncomplicated AOM Children >6 months with severe AOM |
First line | Amoxicillin/clavulanic-acid or ceftriaxone | |||
Second line | Tympanocentesis and treatment according to results of Gram staining and antibiotic sensitivity |
*Severe AOM is defined as moderate to severe otalgia with fever >39°C.
AOM, acute otitis media; N/A, not available.