Skip to main content
. 2015 Sep 29;76(5):741–770. doi: 10.1177/0013164415607618

Table 4.

ANOVA Models, Using Normally Distributed Data.

Effect df Successful replications Bias Standardized bias Efficiency
I 2 1253.97*** 43.37*** 105.00*** 271.22***
γ 2 0.00 264.20*** 722.37*** 1192.35***
CD 5 839.31*** 154.10*** 412.64*** 3131.66***
Method 4 48.24*** 265.33*** 230.36*** 310.78***
n 3 1.41 0.16 0.18 15202.77***
Method *CD 20 43.35*** 74.21*** 67.21*** 127.58***
Method *γ 8 0.00 131.22*** 113.74*** 3.92**
Method * I 8 40.24*** 17.73 *** 16.52*** 32.96***
Method *n 12 2.22* 0.02 0.012 12.15***
CD 10 0.00 74.66*** 202.22*** 389.46***
CD*I 10 800.24*** 10.60*** 26.21*** 204.36***
CD*n 15 7.21*** 0.03 0.04 181.63***
γ*I 4 0.00 20.55*** 50.20*** 0.88
γ*n 6 0.00 0.70 0.33 50.27***
I*n 6 3.11* 0.08 0.08 70.98***
Effect df MSE Standard error bias Type I error rate Power
I 2 38.98*** 14.13*** 47.11*** 55.84***
γ 2 144.13*** 1122.45*** / 921.72***
CD 5 164.28*** 531.54*** 2.92+ 177.54***
Method 4 40.55*** 62.15*** 9.33*** 0.22
n 3 65.76*** 79.20*** 38.13*** 429.60***
Method *CD 20 25.57*** 32.43*** 1.42 0.17
Method *γ 8 44.50*** 65.25*** / 0.22
Method *I 8 8.14*** 1.64 0.16 0.05
Method *n 12 0.37 1.35 0.22 0.04
CD*γ 10 83.48*** 355.61*** / 177.66***
CD*I 10 23.48*** 12.22*** 15.40*** 24.47***
CD*n 15 3.33*** 28.90*** 3.41*** 48.33***
γ*I 4 18.90*** 0.97 / 56.01***
γ*n 6 1.01 50.96*** / 429.17***
I*n 6 0.65 0.99 5.89*** 13.17***
Residuals 2,044 634 1,339

Note. ANOVA= analysis of variance; MSE = mean square error; CD = coefficient of determination.

+

p = .01-.05.*p = .001-.01. **p = .000-.001. ***p < .000.