Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 16;4(3):e00573. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2018.e00573

Table 2.

Occurrence of microcystin (MC) contamination in Aphanizonemon flos-aquae containing blue-green algal dietary supplements as determined by protein phosphatase inhibition assay (PPIA) and liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). LC-MS/MS values represent the average for duplicate analyses (n = 2) analyzed on separate days.

Sample Number Active Ingredient Form Recommended Consumption (g/day) PPIA (μg/g MC) LC-MS/MS (μg/g MC) BGA Source
1 AFA Powder 1 2.8 3.0 Klamath
2 AFA Capsule 1.6-as needed 1.5 1.3 Klamath
3 AFA Capsule 1.2 1.2 1.4 NA
4 AFA Tablet 1 1.1 1.4 Klamath
5 AFA Powder 0.8 (1/2 for children<12) 1.0 1.1 USA
6 AFA Powder 1.6 (1/2 for children<12) 1.0 1.1 USA
7 AFA Powder 5.5–11 0.97 0.98 Klamath
8 AFA Powder 1 0.97 0.74 Klamath
9 AFA Tablet 2 0.95 1.2 Klamath
10 AFA Capsule 1.5–3 0.92 0.80 Klamath
11 AFA Capsule 0.8-as needed 0.89 0.68 Klamath
12 AFA-Mixed Capsule 1.1-as needed 0.83 0.77 NA
13 AFA/S/C-Mixed Powder 9.8 0.61e,f NDe Klamath
14 AFA Capsule 1–3 0.56 0.60 Klamath
15 AFA Powder 1 0.43 Klamath
16 AFA-Mixed Capsule 2 0.43 NA
17 AFA Capsule 1.2 0.42 Klamath
18 AFA-Mixed Capsule 2.2–6.6 0.41 USA
19 AFA Capsule 1–3 0.38 Klamath
20 AFA Capsule 1–3 0.36 Klamath
21 AFA Capsule 1–3 0.35 Klamath
22 AFA Capsule 1–3 0.34 Klamath
23 AFA/S/C-Mixed Powder 8 0.30 USA
24a AFA Powder 1.3–2.6d -as needed 0.29 Klamath
25b AFA Powder 0.3–1d -as needed 0.27 Klamath
26 AFA/S/C-Mixed Powder 8 0.26 USA
27 AFA Capsule 0.5 <0.25 NA
28 AFA/S Tablet 0.5 <0.25 Klamath
29 AFA Capsule 1.5 <0.25 Klamath
30 AFA/S/C Capsule 3.7 <0.25 Klamath
31 AFA Capsule 1.5–3 <0.25 Klamath
32 AFA Capsule 1.5 <0.25 Klamath
33 AFA Capsule 1.5–3 <0.25 Klamath
34 AFA Tablet 0.5–1 <0.25 Klamath
35 AFA Capsule 1–2 <0.25 Klamath
36 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
37 AFA Capsule 1 <0.25 USA
38 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
39 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
40 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
41 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
42 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
43 AFA Capsule 1–3 <0.25 Klamath
44 AFA Capsule 0.6 <0.25 USA
45 AFA/C-Mixed Tablet 9.1 <0.25 NA
46 AFA/S/C-Mixed Powder 8 <0.25 USA
47 AFA/S/C-Mixed Powder 15 <0.25 NA
48 AFA-Mixed Capsule 0.6 <0.25 NA
49g AFA/S/C-Mixed Capsule 0.8 -as needed <0.25 0.12 Klamath
50c,g AFA-Mixed Powder 7–40d <0.25 0.20 USA
51a,g AFA-Mixed Tablet 0.75–6d <0.25 0.26 USA
52g C Capsule 3.69 <0.25 ND NA
53 C Capsule 2 <0.25 Japan
54 C Powder 3 <0.25 Japan
55 S Tablet 3 <0.25 USA
56 S Tablet 2 <0.25 USA
57 S Powder 13 <0.25 USA
58 S Powder 1 <0.25 NA

AFA – Aphanizomenon flos-aquae, S – Spirulina, C – Chlorella.

Mixed – Additional non-BGA active ingredients.

“–” With the exception of negative controls, only samples ≥0.50 μg/g by PPIA were confirmed by LC-MS/MS.

ND – Not Detected (below limit of detection for each congener).

NA – Information Not Available.

a

Marketed for dogs.

b

Marketed for cats.

c

Marketed for horses.

d

Recommended dosage varies depending on weight of animal, entire range shown.

e

Average of replicate measurements.

f

False positive.

g

LC-MS/MS negative controls (as defined by PPIA).