Table 1.
Study | No. of patients | Mean age (range), years | Mean Follow-up, months | Outcomes and return to play |
---|---|---|---|---|
Agolley et al. | 46 | 26.2 (18–35) | 62 | Return to sports-specific training, 10.6 weeks; return to full competitive sport, 16.4 weeks; Tegner score, 9 |
Ahn et al. | 38 | 30 (12–68) | 51 | Lysholm score, 88; HSS score, 91; IKDC subjective score, 83; 93% normal or nearly normal PCL continuity on follow-up |
Jacobi et al. | 17 | 29.2 (17–60) | 24 | Lysholm score, 94; Tegner score, 7.2; IKDC subjective score, 95; 94% normal PCL continuity on follow-up MRI |
Kocher et al. | 11 | 14.4 (7–18) | 44 | Pedi-IKDC, 87.4; Lysholm, 89.0; Tegner, 7.5; 100% return to play rate |
Patel et al. | 57 | 27.9 (13–49) | 83 | Lysholm score, 85.2; Tegner score, 6.6; degenerative changes of the medial compartment in 17% of knees and of the patellofemoral joint in 7% of knees |
Shelbourne et al. | 68 | 26.2 (10–60) | 211 | IKDC subjective score, 79.4; modified CKRS subjective score, 81.3; 11% prevalence of moderate to severe osteoarthritis |
CKRS Cincinnati Knee Rating System, HSS Hospital for Special Surgery, IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee, PCL posterior cruciate ligament