Skip to main content
. 2018 May 25;18:175. doi: 10.1186/s12887-018-1149-0

Table 1.

Characteristics of studies included in the review (n = 55)

Study Study period Study setting Duration Place Number of births Number of anomaly affected births Birth prevalence per 10,000 births
Agarwal et al. 1991 [13] 1981–1984 hospital 31.5 months Lucknow 9405 births 192 204.15
Agarwal et al. 2014 [14] 2010–2011 hospital 12 months Bhubaneswar 7268 births 116 159.6
Aiyar and Agarwal 1969 [15] 1966–1967 hospital 19 months Mumbai 10,000 live births 172 172a
Anand et al. 1988 [16] NM hospital NM Jamnagar 2000 births 40 200
Bai et al. 1982 [17] NM hospitalb 12 months Trivandrum 7167 births 132 184.18
Bai et al. 1990 [18] NM hospital 12 months Trivandrum 13,964 births 50 35.81
Baruah et al. 2015 [19] 2010–2013 hospital 34 months Dibrugarh 18,192 births 206 113.24
Bharucha 1998 [20] 1993–1996 hospitalb 39 months Mumbai 42,304 births 972 229.77
Bhat and Babu 1998 [21] 1989–1992 hospital 40 months Pondicherry 12,797 births 353 275.85
Chaturvedi and Banerjee 1989 [22] 1985–1986 hospitalb 12 months Wardha 3014 births 82 272.06
Chinara and Singh 1982 [23] 1978–1979 hospitalb 12 months Varanasi 1774 births 37 208.57
Choudhary et al. 1984 [24] 1976–1980 hospital 60 months Kolkata 21,016 births 63 29.98
Choudhary et al. 1989 [25] 1976–1987 hospital 120 months Kolkata 126,266 births 535 42.37
Christopher and Jadhav 1986 [26] 1979–1983 hospitalb 60 months Vellore 21,585 births 131 60.69
Desai and Desai 2006 [27] NM hospitalb 12 months Mumbai 2188 births 79 361.06
Dutta and Chaturvedi 2000 [28] 1998–1999 hospitalb 13 months Wardha 2968 births 37 124.66
Duttachoudhary and Pal 1997 [29] 1991–1993 hospital 36 months Durgapur 7242 births 26 35.9
Ghosh et al. 1979 [30] 1974–1976 hospital 29 months Kolkata 2019 births 29 143.64
Ghosh et al. 1985 [64] 1969–1973 community 40 months New Delhi 7590 live births 189 249.01a
Goravalingappa and Nashi 1979 [31] 1986–1987 hospital 15 months Hubli 2398 births 75 312.76
Grover 2000 [32] 1991–1995 hospital 60 months Shimla 10,100 births 180 178.22
Hemrajani et al. 1971 [33] 1965–1969 hospitalb 60 months Jaipur 28,511 births 608 213.25
Jaikrishan et al. 1999 [34] 1995–1998 hospital 41 months Kerala 36,805 births 538 146.18
Jaikrishan et al. 2013 [35] 1995–2011 hospital 191 months Kerala 141,540 births 1370 96.79
Joseph et al. 2010 [65] 2004–2005 community 6 months Belgaum 194 live births 4 206.19a
Khanna and Prasad 1967 [36] 1964 hospital 9 months Patna 5376 births 74 137.65
Kolah et al. 1967 [37] 1960–1963 hospital 39 months Mumbai 23,568 births 331 140.44
Kulkarni et al. 1987 [38] 1984 hospital 6 months Davangere 2000 births 81 405
Kulshetra et al. 1983 [66] 1976–1977 community 24 months Ballabhgarh 2409 live births 79 327.94a
Marwah et al. 2014 [39] 2010–2011 hospital 12 months Patiala 1554 births 69 444.02
Mathur et al. 1975 [40] 1970 hospitalb 4 months Hyderabad 1060 births 33 311.32
Mishra and Baveja 1989 [41] 1983–1987 hospital 48 months Allahabad 4098 births 60 146.41
Mital and Grewal 1969 [42] 1967–1968 hospital 15 months Kanpur 4150 births 93 224.1
Modi et al. 1998 [43] 1993–1997 hospital 40 months Baroda 31,775 births 651 204.88
Parmar et al. 2010 [44] 2006–2007 hospital 18 months Bhavngar 4210 births 37 87.89
Patel and Adhia 2005 [45] NM hospital 24 months Mumbai 17,653 births 294 166.54
Patel et al. 2014 [46] 2012–2014 hospital 24 months Ahmedabad 16,481 births 210 127.42
Rao et al. 2014 [47] 2008–2012 hospital 60 months Mangalore 28,373 births 344 121.24
Ronya et al. 2002 [48] 1999–2000 hospitalb 9 months Wardha 3000 births 62 206.67
Sachadeva et al. 2014 [49] 2010 hospital 4 months Rohtak 2862 live births 47 164.22a
Saifulla et al. 1967 [50] 1966 hospitalb 8 months Chandigarh 1000 births 36 360
Sarkar et al. 2013 [51] 2011–2012 hospitalb 12 months Kolkata 12,896 live births 286 221.77a
Savaskar et al. 2014 [52] 2011–2013 hospitalb NM Latur 10,294 births 443 430.35
Shah and Pensi 2013 [53] NM hospital 9 months Ahmedabad 4456 births 106 237.88
Sharma 1970 [54] 1967–1969 hospital 36 months Mysore 5554 births 14 25.21
Sharma et al. 1972 [55] 1963–1964 hospital 14 months Lucknow 2851 births 40 140.3
Singh and Gupta 2009 [56] 2002 hospital 12 months Jammu 9308 births 140 150.41
Singh and Sharma 1980 [57] 1975–1978 hospital 48 months New Delhi 6274 live births 170 270.96a
Stevenson et al. 1966 [58] 1961–1964 hospital NM Mumbai (Purandare VN) 39,498 births 340 86.08
Stevenson et al. 1966 [58] 1961–1964 hospital NM Kolkata (Mitra KN) 19,191 births 59 30.74
Swain et al. 1994 [59] 1988–1989 hospital 24 months Varanasi 3932 births 48 122.08
Taksande et al. 2010 [60] 2005–2007 hospitalb 31 months Wardha 9386 births 179 190.71
Tibrewala and Pai 1974 [61] 1968–1972 hospital 60 months Mumbai 12,360 live births 232 187.7a
Verma et al. 1991 [62] 1983–1989 hospital 75 months Ludhiana 10,000 births 359 359
Verma et al. 1998 [63] NM hospital 36 months New Delhi 23,367 births 433 185.3

NM not mentioned

aStudies reporting live births only. Prevalence has been reported per 10,000 live births. All other studies reported both live and stillbirths

bApart from these hospital studies which used radiological, ultrasound and some other investigations, case ascertainment was done only through physical assessment