Table 1.
Study | Study period | Study setting | Duration | Place | Number of births | Number of anomaly affected births | Birth prevalence per 10,000 births |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Agarwal et al. 1991 [13] | 1981–1984 | hospital | 31.5 months | Lucknow | 9405 births | 192 | 204.15 |
Agarwal et al. 2014 [14] | 2010–2011 | hospital | 12 months | Bhubaneswar | 7268 births | 116 | 159.6 |
Aiyar and Agarwal 1969 [15] | 1966–1967 | hospital | 19 months | Mumbai | 10,000 live births | 172 | 172a |
Anand et al. 1988 [16] | NM | hospital | NM | Jamnagar | 2000 births | 40 | 200 |
Bai et al. 1982 [17] | NM | hospitalb | 12 months | Trivandrum | 7167 births | 132 | 184.18 |
Bai et al. 1990 [18] | NM | hospital | 12 months | Trivandrum | 13,964 births | 50 | 35.81 |
Baruah et al. 2015 [19] | 2010–2013 | hospital | 34 months | Dibrugarh | 18,192 births | 206 | 113.24 |
Bharucha 1998 [20] | 1993–1996 | hospitalb | 39 months | Mumbai | 42,304 births | 972 | 229.77 |
Bhat and Babu 1998 [21] | 1989–1992 | hospital | 40 months | Pondicherry | 12,797 births | 353 | 275.85 |
Chaturvedi and Banerjee 1989 [22] | 1985–1986 | hospitalb | 12 months | Wardha | 3014 births | 82 | 272.06 |
Chinara and Singh 1982 [23] | 1978–1979 | hospitalb | 12 months | Varanasi | 1774 births | 37 | 208.57 |
Choudhary et al. 1984 [24] | 1976–1980 | hospital | 60 months | Kolkata | 21,016 births | 63 | 29.98 |
Choudhary et al. 1989 [25] | 1976–1987 | hospital | 120 months | Kolkata | 126,266 births | 535 | 42.37 |
Christopher and Jadhav 1986 [26] | 1979–1983 | hospitalb | 60 months | Vellore | 21,585 births | 131 | 60.69 |
Desai and Desai 2006 [27] | NM | hospitalb | 12 months | Mumbai | 2188 births | 79 | 361.06 |
Dutta and Chaturvedi 2000 [28] | 1998–1999 | hospitalb | 13 months | Wardha | 2968 births | 37 | 124.66 |
Duttachoudhary and Pal 1997 [29] | 1991–1993 | hospital | 36 months | Durgapur | 7242 births | 26 | 35.9 |
Ghosh et al. 1979 [30] | 1974–1976 | hospital | 29 months | Kolkata | 2019 births | 29 | 143.64 |
Ghosh et al. 1985 [64] | 1969–1973 | community | 40 months | New Delhi | 7590 live births | 189 | 249.01a |
Goravalingappa and Nashi 1979 [31] | 1986–1987 | hospital | 15 months | Hubli | 2398 births | 75 | 312.76 |
Grover 2000 [32] | 1991–1995 | hospital | 60 months | Shimla | 10,100 births | 180 | 178.22 |
Hemrajani et al. 1971 [33] | 1965–1969 | hospitalb | 60 months | Jaipur | 28,511 births | 608 | 213.25 |
Jaikrishan et al. 1999 [34] | 1995–1998 | hospital | 41 months | Kerala | 36,805 births | 538 | 146.18 |
Jaikrishan et al. 2013 [35] | 1995–2011 | hospital | 191 months | Kerala | 141,540 births | 1370 | 96.79 |
Joseph et al. 2010 [65] | 2004–2005 | community | 6 months | Belgaum | 194 live births | 4 | 206.19a |
Khanna and Prasad 1967 [36] | 1964 | hospital | 9 months | Patna | 5376 births | 74 | 137.65 |
Kolah et al. 1967 [37] | 1960–1963 | hospital | 39 months | Mumbai | 23,568 births | 331 | 140.44 |
Kulkarni et al. 1987 [38] | 1984 | hospital | 6 months | Davangere | 2000 births | 81 | 405 |
Kulshetra et al. 1983 [66] | 1976–1977 | community | 24 months | Ballabhgarh | 2409 live births | 79 | 327.94a |
Marwah et al. 2014 [39] | 2010–2011 | hospital | 12 months | Patiala | 1554 births | 69 | 444.02 |
Mathur et al. 1975 [40] | 1970 | hospitalb | 4 months | Hyderabad | 1060 births | 33 | 311.32 |
Mishra and Baveja 1989 [41] | 1983–1987 | hospital | 48 months | Allahabad | 4098 births | 60 | 146.41 |
Mital and Grewal 1969 [42] | 1967–1968 | hospital | 15 months | Kanpur | 4150 births | 93 | 224.1 |
Modi et al. 1998 [43] | 1993–1997 | hospital | 40 months | Baroda | 31,775 births | 651 | 204.88 |
Parmar et al. 2010 [44] | 2006–2007 | hospital | 18 months | Bhavngar | 4210 births | 37 | 87.89 |
Patel and Adhia 2005 [45] | NM | hospital | 24 months | Mumbai | 17,653 births | 294 | 166.54 |
Patel et al. 2014 [46] | 2012–2014 | hospital | 24 months | Ahmedabad | 16,481 births | 210 | 127.42 |
Rao et al. 2014 [47] | 2008–2012 | hospital | 60 months | Mangalore | 28,373 births | 344 | 121.24 |
Ronya et al. 2002 [48] | 1999–2000 | hospitalb | 9 months | Wardha | 3000 births | 62 | 206.67 |
Sachadeva et al. 2014 [49] | 2010 | hospital | 4 months | Rohtak | 2862 live births | 47 | 164.22a |
Saifulla et al. 1967 [50] | 1966 | hospitalb | 8 months | Chandigarh | 1000 births | 36 | 360 |
Sarkar et al. 2013 [51] | 2011–2012 | hospitalb | 12 months | Kolkata | 12,896 live births | 286 | 221.77a |
Savaskar et al. 2014 [52] | 2011–2013 | hospitalb | NM | Latur | 10,294 births | 443 | 430.35 |
Shah and Pensi 2013 [53] | NM | hospital | 9 months | Ahmedabad | 4456 births | 106 | 237.88 |
Sharma 1970 [54] | 1967–1969 | hospital | 36 months | Mysore | 5554 births | 14 | 25.21 |
Sharma et al. 1972 [55] | 1963–1964 | hospital | 14 months | Lucknow | 2851 births | 40 | 140.3 |
Singh and Gupta 2009 [56] | 2002 | hospital | 12 months | Jammu | 9308 births | 140 | 150.41 |
Singh and Sharma 1980 [57] | 1975–1978 | hospital | 48 months | New Delhi | 6274 live births | 170 | 270.96a |
Stevenson et al. 1966 [58] | 1961–1964 | hospital | NM | Mumbai (Purandare VN) | 39,498 births | 340 | 86.08 |
Stevenson et al. 1966 [58] | 1961–1964 | hospital | NM | Kolkata (Mitra KN) | 19,191 births | 59 | 30.74 |
Swain et al. 1994 [59] | 1988–1989 | hospital | 24 months | Varanasi | 3932 births | 48 | 122.08 |
Taksande et al. 2010 [60] | 2005–2007 | hospitalb | 31 months | Wardha | 9386 births | 179 | 190.71 |
Tibrewala and Pai 1974 [61] | 1968–1972 | hospital | 60 months | Mumbai | 12,360 live births | 232 | 187.7a |
Verma et al. 1991 [62] | 1983–1989 | hospital | 75 months | Ludhiana | 10,000 births | 359 | 359 |
Verma et al. 1998 [63] | NM | hospital | 36 months | New Delhi | 23,367 births | 433 | 185.3 |
NM not mentioned
aStudies reporting live births only. Prevalence has been reported per 10,000 live births. All other studies reported both live and stillbirths
bApart from these hospital studies which used radiological, ultrasound and some other investigations, case ascertainment was done only through physical assessment