Table 2.
Characteristics of the most commonly used bio-ink constituents.
type | cross-linker | pros | cons | references | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
agarose | natural | thermoresponsive | cheap, good printability | non-adherent and bioinert | [47] |
alginate | natural | ionic, (Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+) | good printability, tunable characteristics, fast cross-linking | difficult to control shrinking during cross-linking, bioinert | [48–51] |
chitosan | natural | pH neutralization | pH changes required | [47] | |
collagen | natural | thermoresponsive, pH | biologically relevant, adherent, reasonable printability | pH changes required or cold bed for thermal gelling, characteristic of fibrosis, must be sourced from humans for clinical use | [52] |
fibrin | natural | enzymatic (thrombin) | biologically relevant and adherent | poor printability | [24,53] |
gelatin | natural | thermoresponsive, or UV if methacryloyl | cheap, good printability, adherent and bioactive | cold bed or UV exposure required to cross-link, must be sourced from humans for clinical use, poorly defined | [13,54] |
gellan gum | natural | ionic (Ca2+) | cheap, reasonable printability, tuneable with peptide motifs | low mechanical properties, non-adherent and bioinert | [22,55] |
hyaluronic acid | natural | dependent on modification | reasonable to print, biologically active and relevant | low mechanical properties, must be human sourced for clinical use, cross-linker can be harmful (H2O2) | [18,56] |
pluronic | synthetic | thermoresponsive | good printability, highly tunable viscosity, sacrificial | mainly used for sacrificial inks, requires cold printing bed to maintain structure | [24] |
poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) | synthetic | UV exposure | good printability, tunable, well-defined polymer | potentially harmful UV and photo-initiator exposure | [57] |
poly(caprolactone) (PCL) | synthetic | thermoresponsive (high temp) | mechanically strong, bioinert | not suitable for cell printing due to high melting point | [24,58] |