Table 1.
Female 0.1 µg/ml versus Control |
Male 0.1 µg/ml versus Control |
F versus M |
Female 1 µg/ml versus Control |
Male 1 µg/ml versus Control |
F versus M |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Control | 0.1 µg/ml | p-Valuea | Control | 0.1 µg/ml | p-Valuea | p-Valueb | 1 µg/ml | p-Valuea | 1 µg/ml | p-Valuea | p-Valueb | |
Bone marrow | ||||||||||||
Cell count | 12433333 ± 742930 | 11148333 ± 1153077 | .53 | 11850000 ± 640638 | 14412500 ± 781658 | .07 | .15 | 8305000 ± 150000 | .05* | 14050000 ± 819807 | .12 | .01* |
HSC | 81.7 ± 30.3 | 123 ± 26 | .56 | 181 ± 47 | 233 ± 41 | .63 | .10 | 277 ± 40 | .02* | 232 ± 44 | .64 | .56 |
LSK | 1681.2 ± 114.3 | 1681 ± 651 | .99 | 1617 ± 154 | 1746 ± 190 | .24 | .84 | 1249 ± 189 | .76 | 1993 ± 148 | .81 | .04* |
LK | 37727 ± 3013 | 38353 ± 9465 | .99 | 40321 ± 1143 | 50790 ± 5188 | .09 | .27 | 33628 ± 192 | .89 | 50129 ± 2483 | .12 | .01* |
MPP | 1441.3 ± 111.7 | 1335 ± 565 | .97 | 1253 ± 91 | 1207 ± 214 | .97 | .82 | 745 ± 185 | .45 | 1560 ± 146 | .33 | .03* |
Lineage - | 334137 ± 40143 | 284293 ± 89951 | .81 | 313340 ± 23271 | 364988 ± 42847 | .48 | .41 | 305411 ± 16724 | .94 | 404781 ± 32400 | .15 | .12 |
CLP | 4561 ± 1431 | 4516 ± 2171 | .99 | 4639 ± 446 | 4691 ± 778 | .99 | .93 | 156 ± 38 | .25 | 4616 ± 163 | .99 | <.0001* |
GMP | 3229.2 ± 555.1 | 4890 ± 444 | .10 | 4417 ± 499 | 5646 ± 685 | .23 | .44 | 3727 ± 514 | .76 | 5258 ± 349 | .46 | .07 |
Pre-GM | 8716.2 ± 691.5 | 8785 ± 2383 | .99 | 11272 ± 316 | 14981 ± 1787 | .09 | .09 | 5484 ± 265 | .39 | 14625 ± 931 | .13 | .003* |
Pre-MegE | 15717 ± 1315 | 14403 ± 3406 | .89 | 14148 ± 331 | 17659 ± 1437 | .10 | .37 | 14119 ± 255 | .88 | 16469 ± 1344 | .31 | .31 |
Thymus | ||||||||||||
Cell count | 134700000 ± 15085534 | 7992833± 38156620 | .31 | 86075000 ± 6312702 | 84687500 ± 4441583 | .97 | .89 | 198750000 ± 33250000 | .29 | 77562500 ± 1852406 | .36 | .004* |
DN1 | 1029398 ± 128817 | 629804 ± 229799 | .22 | 652118 ± 46528 | 633010 ± 37150 | .95 | .99 | 993675 ± 50325 | .99 | 593431 ± 62092 | .63 | .02* |
DN2 | 154645 ± 17105 | 123131 ± 56585 | .78 | 82867 ± 4305 | 80256 ± 4563 | .95 | .41 | 150895 ± 41665 | .99 | 81100 ± 9931 | .98 | .08 |
DN3 | 1684308 ± 190926 | 1055676 ± 502342 | .36 | 979296 ± 62343 | 968785 ± 21799 | .97 | .84 | 1995775 ± 324225 | .79 | 933129 ± 14914 | .63 | .01* |
DN4 | 929283 ± 44022 | 1039598 ± 175690 | .81 | 927516 ± 118930 | 867171 ± 69782 | .88 | .35 | 1045175 ± 300425 | .83 | 812128 ± 111851 | .65 | .40 |
DP | 64765250 ± 4519003 | 4214308± 21474537 | .47 | 43490400 ± 3354243 | 43503338 ± 5616368 | 1 | .95 | 79919750 ± 22160250 | .75 | 41521763 ± 2323515 | .92 | .05 |
DP CD3+ | 37535 ± 4244 | 35116 ± 18488 | .98 | 94271 ± 24827 | 66288 ± 9805 | .45 | .17 | 35117.5 ± 13603 | .99 | 90209 ± 14613 | .98 | .08 |
TCRβ+ | 6829968 ± 476592 | 6791068 ± 2675537 | .99 | 6917440 ± 462168 | 5960451 ± 41223 | .34 | .73 | 7544450 ± 1619550 | .95 | 5804218 ± 724325 | .25 | .30 |
CD4+ | 5563755 ± 415844 | 4480870 ± 1974304 | .79 | 4891533 ± 349205 | 4651036 ± 137026 | .82 | .92 | 7347550 ± 1886050 | .62 | 4259121 ± 401819 | .31 | .08 |
CD8+ | 680505 ± 55178 | 930392 ± 96601 | .16 | 885978 ± 206229 | 751826 ± 106954 | .75 | .29 | 533375 ± 185825 | .53 | 723828 ± 105159 | .67 | .38 |
TCRγδ+ | 483158 ± 45652 | 313629 ± 138319 | .33 | 378986 ± 27842 | 377249 ± 23029 | .99 | .62 | 526650 ± 30150 | .93 | 395438 ± 69299 | .95 | .28 |
Treg | 126705 ± 11419 | 120334 ± 25422 | .97 | 109801 ± 9453 | 103152 ± 7950 | .80 | .49 | 151058 ± 36863 | .69 | 88345 ± 7749 | .18 | .07 |
Spleen | ||||||||||||
Cell count | 86737500 ± 1371298 | 8221666± 31853497 | .98 | 8998750± 10669707 | 107612500 ± 8841907 | .32 | .06 | 76000000 ± 19500000 | .93 | 117512500 ± 6614390 | .10 | .42 |
CD19+ | 42901875 ± 8244859 | 4150248± 17869820 | .99 | 4446851± 10596693 | 57843813 ± 5629245 | .38 | .36 | 42249750 ± 1 3999750 | .99 | 60730938 ± 9521355 | .26 | .17 |
CD4+ | 9179363 ± 1756623 | 10686967 ± 4435512 | .91 | 11378904 ± 2552025 | 14578738 ± 865956 | .33 | .36 | 7227550 ± 1577550 | .88 | 15235463 ± 969390 | .22 | .01* |
CD8+ | 6755044 ± 1108823 | 7373400 ± 2819035 | .96 | 7579081 ± 1212533 | 9894250 ± 747637 | .18 | .36 | 4506000 ± 1042550 | .68 | 9921128 ± 642899 | .17 | .01* |
NK1.1+ | 1864925 ± 286698 | 1721660 ± 705751 | .97 | 2457671 ± 244963 | 2309921 ± 295240 | .86 | .43 | 1148275 ± 255575 | .55 | 2769471 ± 80402 | .54 | .001* |
TCRγδ+ | 1404270 ± 224021 | 1332622 ± 564340 | .99 | 1378785 ± 208629 | 1592971 ± 114013 | .49 | .62 | 1039450 ± 288000 | .77 | 1663444 ± 65032 | .31 | .04* |
Treg | 492888 ± 134031 | 572553 ± 240016 | .93 | 758630 ± 230462 | 933366 ± 142882 | .67 | .23 | 441275 ± 45775 | .97 | 995236 ± 64601 | .5 | .01* |
F4/80+ | 2736355 ± 362139 | 2959867 ± 701954 | .94 | 2526675 ± 389486 | 3384780 ± 384762 | .22 | .59 | 3851600 ± 761050 | .38 | 3708730 ± 308728 | .08 | .84 |
Gr-1+ | 4945213 ± 691402 | 5847227 ± 1601634 | .79 | 5473478 ± 1065955 | 7106785 ± 546481 | .26 | .44 | 5581725 ± 960025 | .91 | 7565911 ± 490051 | .14 | .10 |
Gr-1+CD11b+ | 449216 ± 65317 | 889747 ± 275714 | .21 | 374870 ± 33306 | 469855 ± 33816 | .14 | .13 | 1457325 ± 242575 | .02* | 542254 ± 34726 | .01* | .004* |
CD11c+MHCIIhi | 1196778 ± 203674 | 1127800 ± 425883 | .98 | 1103168 ± 222118 | 1405939 ± 137023 | .37 | .51 | 915300 ± 163850 | .78 | 1501859 ± 119692 | .21 | .04* |
CD11b+DCs | 135978 ± 38691 | 146450 ± 46234 | .98 | 140680 ± 22079 | 180088 ± 4949 | .17 | .43 | 80218 ± 12418 | .61 | 196008 ± 13632 | .54 | .01* |
CD103+DCs | 21814 ± 5846 | 29950 ± 12584 | .77 | 27152 ± 7706 | 27782 ± 9831 | .99 | .90 | 20668 ± 12758 | .99 | 40007 ± 9565 | .53 | .30 |
Lymph nodes | ||||||||||||
Cell count | 906250 ± 356587 | 1246333 ± 230860 | .88 | 1205250 ± 142966 | 1281250 ± 248510 | .95 | .92 | 1750500 ± 1279500 | .57 | 665000 ± 86920 | .12 | .24 |
NK1.1+ | 339467 ± 152821 | 376573 ± 163194 | .99 | 324370 ± 20897 | 418592 ± 103462 | .48 | .81 | 726215 ± 510026 | .49 | 194269 ± 20803 | .28 | .18 |
CD19+ | 184994 ± 89183 | 206919 ± 78508 | .99 | 195106 ± 16840 | 235362 ± 90192 | .82 | .83 | 428606 ± 319805 | .45 | 102250 ± 17897 | .41 | .17 |
TCRγδ+ | 131612 ± 57008 | 166186 ± 59364 | .95 | 143302 ± 13848 | 195615 ± 78622 | .66 | .37 | 293009 ± 219062 | .46 | 74033 ± 13529 | .49 | .24 |
CD4+ | 3744 ± 1433 | 4361 ± 1424 | .98 | 4831 ± 845 | 4884 ± 1376 | .99 | .83 | 8238 ± 6306 | .45 | 1909 ± 206 | .09 | .17 |
CD8+ | 18441 ± 10365 | 22114 ± 7900 | .95 | 29839 ± 11946 | 14580 ± 3132 | .27 | .79 | 18404 ± 13411 | 1 | 6903 ± 997 | .08 | .18 |
Treg | 13911 ± 6572 | 13545 ± 4531 | .99 | 16110 ± 3418 | 22151 ± 10075 | .73 | .52 | 34468 ± 26132 | .39 | 8232 ± 1871 | .59 | .18 |
F4/80+ | 6276 ± 2376 | 11119 ± 2556 | .55 | 6332 ± 439 | 7071 ± 773 | .61 | .14 | 10887 ± 8202 | .65 | 3314 ± 540 | .01* | .21 |
Gr-1+ | 51600 ± 20201 | 74254 ± 23100 | .91 | 62885 ± 6323 | 82352 ± 29324 | .66 | .85 | 163213 ± 117668 | .25 | 31898 ± 5218 | .39 | .14 |
Gr-1+CD11b+ | 624 ± 266 | 1992 ± 1385 | .45 | 524 ± 85 | 613 ± 196 | .84 | .30 | 1766 ± 871 | .63 | 251 ± 33 | .26 | .04* |
CD11c+MHCIIhi | 7617 ± 3016 | 11403 ± 3023 | .79 | 7074 ± 193 | 9223 ± 2031 | .38 | .56 | 15758 ± 10906 | .47 | 4117 ± 376 | .19 | .16 |
CD11b+DCs | 1933 ± 679 | 4089 ± 1484 | .35 | 1610 ± 292 | 2094 ± 144 | .18 | .17 | 2521± 1721 | .93 | 1120 ± 68 | .17 | .26 |
CD103+DCs | 1729 ± 749 | 2358 ± 1345 | .91 | 1540 ± 177 | 1925 ± 613 | .69 | .76 | 3302± 2455 | .66 | 718 ± 85 | .25 | .16 |
The table depicts the mean number (±SEM) of the indicated cell population in primary and secondary immune organs from immunologically naïve male and female offspring at maturity (6 weeks of age). There were 4–8 mice of each sex per group, and same-sex offspring within each group were from different dams. Bone marrow, thymus, and peripheral lymph nodes (PLN) were isolated and cell populations identified using multiparametric analytical flow cytometry. Cells enumerated in the bone marrow include: HSC (Lineage[Lin])negSca-1+cKit+CD105hiCD150+); LSK cells (LinnegSca-1+Kit+ cells); LK cells (LinnegKit+ cells); multipotent progenitors (MPP; LineagenegSca-1+cKit+CD105intCD150neg); common lymphocyte progenitors (CLP; LineagenegSca-1+cKit+CD105hiCD150+CD127+); granulocyte monocyte progenitors (GMP; LinnegKit+CD16/32+CD150neg); pre-granulocyte/monocyte cells (pre-GM; LinnegKit+CD16/32negCD150negCD105int); pre-megakaryocyte/erythrocyte cells (pre-MegE; LinnegKit+CD16/32negCD150+CD105hi). In the thymus, cells were defined as double negative: DN1 (CD44+CD25negCD4negCD8neg); DN2 (CD44+CD25+CD4negCD8neg); DN3 (CD44negCD25+CD4negCD8neg); DN4 (CD44negCD25negCD4negCD8neg); double positive (DP; CD3+CD4+CD8+); CD8 SP (CD3+CD4negCD8+); CD4 SP (CD3+CD4+CD8neg); Treg (Foxp3+CD25+CD4+CD8negCD3+); γδT cells (γδTCR+CD3+CD4-CD8-). In the lymph node, cells were defined as: CD8+ T cells (CD3+CD8+); CD4+ T cells (CD3+CD4+); Treg (Foxp3+CD25+CD4+); neutrophils (Gr-1+); macrophages (F4/80+); dendritic cells (DCs; CD11c+MHCIIhi), CD11b+DCs (CD11b+CD103−CD11c+MHCIIhi cells) and CD103+DCs (CD11b−CD103+CD11c+MHCIIhi cells); γδT cells (γδTCR+CD3+CD4−CD8−); NK cells (CD3negNK1.1+); B cells (CD3negCD19+).
The p-value for mixture-exposed group compared with control group within the indicated sex.
The p-value for female versus male offspring from dams given indicated concentration of the mixture.
Demarcates p ≤.05.