Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Jul 1.
Published in final edited form as: Sleep Med. 2017 Nov 29;47:126–136. doi: 10.1016/j.sleep.2017.11.1128

Table 2.

Performance statistics of the automated artifact detector as compared to visual artifact scoring, when considering only the visually scored artifacts having total power greater than the 99% percentile.

NREM epochs (N=86,250) REM epochs (N=20,717)
Th N art sens spec acc PPV NPV K N art sens spec acc PPV NPV K
1 579 81.35 97.23 97.12 16.57 99.87 0.27 170 75.29 97.19 97.01 18.16 99.79 0.28
2 560 82.14 97.22 97.12 16.18 99.88 0.26 159 78.62 97.18 97.04 17.73 99.83 0.28
3 443 84.88 97.12 97.06 13.23 99.92 0.22 122 82.79 97.07 96.98 14.33 99.90 0.24
4 306 86.60 97.00 96.96 9.32 99.95 0.16 90 85.56 96.96 96.91 10.92 99.94 0.19
5 163 87.73 96.86 96.85 5.03 99.98 0.09 51 88.24 96.81 96.79 6.38 99.97 0.11
6 66 86.36 96.77 96.76 2.00 99.99 0.04 28 85.71 96.71 96.69 3.40 99.98 0.06
7 41 80.49 96.74 96.73 1.16 99.99 0.02 11 90.91 96.64 96.64 1.42 100.00 0.03
8 28 71.43 96.73 96.72 0.70 99.99 0.01 8 87.50 96.63 96.63 0.99 100.00 0.02
9 20 70.00 96.72 96.71 0.49 99.99 0.01 6 83.33 96.62 96.62 0.71 100.00 0.01
10 18 72.22 96.72 96.71 0.46 99.99 0.01 5 80.00 96.62 96.61 0.57 100.00 0.01

Th: sub-epoch threshold indicating the minimum number of visually identified artifactual 4-s sub-epochs that needed to be present within a 30-s epoch in order to consider this epoch as artifactual. N art: number of 30-s epochs that are considered artifactual with the corresponding sub-epoch threshold. Sens: sensitivity; spec: specificity; acc: accuracy; PPV: positive predictive value; NPV: negative predictive value; K: Cohen’s kappa. The automated pipeline detected 2843 epochs with artifact in NREM and 705 epochs with artifact in REM.