Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Gerontol Nurs. 2018 Jan 23;44(3):23–30. doi: 10.3928/00989134-20171206-01

Table B.

Quality Assessment of Included Studies

Name/Year published Sufficient sample size Robust sampling methodology Valid dementia measurement Valid ED measurement Controlled for confounding Comments/concerns
Amjad et al. 2016
Bloom et al. 2004 ✓✗ Did not control for survival
Brummel-Smith 2001
Deb et al. 2017 Prevalence of dementia much lower than other studies
Eaker et al. 2001 ✓✗ Did not control for comorbidities
Feng et al. 2014
Fillit et al. 2002 Unvalidated method of assessing dementia severity
Grober et al. 2012
Hill et al. 2005 Unvalidated method of assessing dementia subtype
Husaini et al. 2003
LaMantia et al. 2015 Cost was primary outcome of study
Leibson et al. 2015 Cost was primary outcome of study
Leon et al. 2000 ✓✗ Small sample sizes in subgroups
McCormick et al. 2001 Cost was primary outcome of study
Ng et al. 2014 ✓✗ ✓✗ Small sample sizes for some variables included in statistical model
Richards et al. 2000 ? Unclear if ED visits adjusted for age and sex or just cost adjusted
Sloane et al. 2017 ✓✗ Small sample sizes for some variables included in statistical model
Tian et al. 2014 Unvalidated method for assessing dementia + dysphagia
Zhao et al. 2008

✓=yes ✗=no ✓✗ = partially ✓