Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 15;40(1):27–39. doi: 10.1093/epirev/mxx012

Table 3.

Housing Segregation, Physical and Sexual Violence, and Access to Hormone Therapy Reported in International Peer-Reviewed Health Literature and Gray Literature on Infectious Diseases in Carceral Settings, 1992–2016

First Author, Year (Reference No.) Peer-Reviewed Literature or Gray Literature Access to Gender-Affirming Hormones and/or Surgery Housing Segregation Violence
Colchero, 2015 (63) Peer reviewed NR “In three of the centers, transgender women and gay men live in an independent wing, which is separated from where other men live. In the remaining center, most of the transgender women were found at the same wing where people with HIV live. All people living with HIV and AIDS in prisons in Mexico City are transferred to this wing in this prison” (p. s101). “In detention centers, as verbally expressed by transgender women that declined to participate, non-participation was related to the fear of getting an HIV-positive result, and particularly associated with the anxiety of been transferred to the only prison that offers HIV treatment in the city, which is perceived as having a very violent environment” (p. s102).
Crepet, 2016 (62) Peer reviewed NR NR NR
Varella, 1996 (60) Peer reviewed NR NR NR
Valenta, 1992 (61) Peer reviewed “In 1987, prison policy was for inmates who presented proof of being treated with estrogens or progestogens prior to incarceration to continue to receive treatment while in prison. This was discontinued in 1988 due to concerns about risk of high blood pressure, elevated lipids, and thromboembolic disease. Hormone therapy was abruptly stopped in all inmates” (p. 242). NR NR
Lydon, 2015 (43)a Gray
  • 35% (n = 222)b of TW, TS, and NBG respondents received hormone therapy before incarceration.

  • 23.0%c of TW, TS, and NBG respondents received hormone therapy in prison.

  • 44.0%c of TW, TS, and NBG requested hormone therapy and were denied access while in prison.

  • 40.0%c were denied access to surgery during incarceration.

  • 76.0% of TW (n = 114)b,d placed in solitary confinement for safety

  • 70.0% of TS (n = 46)b,d placed in solitary confinement for safety

  • 65.0% of NBG (n = 52)b,d placed in solitary confinement for safety

  • Violence by staff:

  • 22.0% (n = 137)b raped by staff 14.0% of TS (n = 51)b raped by staff

  • 23.0% of NBG (n = 62)b raped by staff

  • Violence by inmates:

  • 79.0% of TW (n = 137)b raped by inmates

  • 57.0% of TS (n = 51)b raped by inmates

  • 68.0% of NBG (n = 62)b raped by inmates

Hariga, 2011 (59) Gray NR “A specific unit with trained staff has been established to hold the transgender population” (p. 14). “Proposed education, work and other activities are designed based on the needs of the population. All detainees expressed their great satisfaction with this arrangement in the classification. Their specific needs are addressed, including in terms of commodities” (p. 14). NR
Emmer, 2011 (58) Gray
  • 18.9% (n = 37)b,e continued receiving hormone therapy during incarceration.

  • 37.8% (n = 37)b,e received hormone therapy off and on during incarceration.

  • 43.2% (n = 37)b,e have not received hormone therapy while incarcerated.

  • 69.5% (n = 59)b in general population

  • 5.1% (n = 59)b in administrative segregation

  • 17.0% (n = 59)b in protective custody

  • 6.8% (n = 59)b in solitary confinementf

  • Violence by staff:

  • 79.7% (n = 59)b verbally harassed by staff owing to gender

  • 44.1% (n = 59)b sexually harassed

  • 27.1% (n = 59)b physically assaulted

  • 27.1% (n = 59)b sexually assaulted

  • Violence by inmates:

  • 90.0% (n = 59)b verbally harassed

  • 72.9% (n = 59)b sexually harassed

  • 52.5% (n = 59)b physically assaulted

  • 44.1% (n = 59)b sexually assaulted

Abbreviations: HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; NBG, nonbinary gender; NR, not reported; TW, transgender women; TS, 2-spirit.

a A total of 950 participants reported on gender identity: 15% TW, 5% TS, 7% NBG.

b Total sample size.

c Sample size information not reported in article (i.e., numerator and denominator not reported).

d Number represents number of participants placed in solitary confinement for safety or other reasons.

e A total of 37 participants were taking hormones before incarceration.

f Also called “restricted housing” in report (p. 19).