Table 1. Characteristics of the publications in the validity assessment of measurement tools on aspects of transitional patient safety.
Authors | N | Country | Measurement tool | Transition | Safety outcome type | Subject of questionnaire | Target population | Response rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patient perspective | ||||||||
Aller 2013 |
1500 | SP | Continuity of care between care Levels (CCAENA) |
Hospital<->PCP | HCP outcome | Continuity of care | Patients that have experienced a transition | 23% |
Berendsen 2009 |
1404 | NL | Consumer Quality Index Continuum of Care (CQI-COC) | PCP referral and relational continuity | HCP outcome | Collaboration between PCP and hospital | Referred patients | 65% |
Coleman 2002 |
60 | USA | Care Transition Measure (CTM) | Discharge from hospital to home/nursing home | HCP outcome | Care transition | Patients ≥65 years who were recently discharged from hospital and received subsequent skilled nursing care in facility/home. | NR |
Coleman 2005 |
200 | USA | Care Transition Measure (CTM) | Discharge from hospital to home/nursing home | HCP and patient outcome | Care transition | Adult patients discharged with primary diagnosis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, congestive heart failure, stroke, or hip fracture | 100% |
Graumlich 2008 |
460 | USA | B-prepared | Hospital discharge | HCP outcome | Patient preparedness on hospital discharge | All adult patients discharged by internal medicine hospitalists | NR |
Grimmer 2001 |
500 (patients), 431 (carers) |
AUS | PREPARED | Hospital discharge | HCP and patient outcome | Discharge | Patients ≥65 years, recently discharged from hospital | 60% (patients), 52% (care givers) |
Hadjistavropoulos 2008 | 204 | CAN | Patient continuity of care Questionnaire (PCCQ) | Hospital discharge | HCP outcome | Continuity of care at discharge | Adult patients recently discharged from hospital | NR |
Haggerty 2011 |
236–427 | CAN | 4 questionnaires with dimension management continuity: PCAS, PCAT-S, CPCI, VANOCSS | PCP<-> other specialists | HCP outcome | Management continuity | Primary care patients who had seen more than one provider in the previous month | 54–99%* |
Haggerty 2012 |
256 | CAN | Patient Perceived Continuity from Multiple Clinicians | Hos<->PCP | HCP and patient outcome | Continuity of care | Adult patients in primary care seeing other clinicians in a variety of settings | 80% |
Kollen 2010 |
1404 | NL | Consumer Quality Index Continuum of Care (CQI-COC) | PCP referral and relational continuity | HCP outcome | Continuity of care | Adult patients who had been referred and visited a specialist | 65% |
Uijen 2011 |
288 | NL | Nijmegen Continuity Questionnaire | Hos<->PCP | HCP outcome | Continuity of care | Patients with comorbidity | 72% |
Uijen 2012 |
268 | NL | Nijmegen Continuity Questionnaire | Hos<->PCP | HCP outcome | Continuity of care | Patients with comorbidity | 76% |
Healthcare professional perspective | ||||||||
Berendsen 2010 |
496 | NL | Doctors’ opinions on collaboration (DOC) questionnaire | Hos<->PCP | HCP outcome and climate | Interprofessional collaboration | PCPs and specialists | 45% |
Forster 2012 |
** | CAN | Peer review process of adverse outcome | Hospital discharge | Patient outcome | Adverse events at discharge | NA | NA |
Graumlich 2008 |
417 | USA | Modified Physician-PREPARED | Hospital discharge | HCP outcome | Discharge | Community physicians | 76% |
Hess 2009 |
12212 | USA | CRP-PIM: Communication with Referring Physicians Practice Improvement Module | PCP referral to secondary care consultants (hospital and private groups) | HCP outcomeand climate | Communication of consultants | Referring physicians | ? |
Nuno-solinis 2013 |
187 | SP | No name reported | Hos<->PCP | Climate | Interprofessional collaboration | Physicians and nurses working in integrated healthcare organisations | 16% |
Smith 2004 |
*** | USA | Medication discrepancy tool | Hospital discharge | Patient outcome | Medication discrepancies | Practitioners across the continuum of care | NA |
SP: Spain; NL: the Netherlands; USA: United States of America; AUS: Australia; CAN: Canada; HOS: hospital; PCP: Primary care practitioner; NA = not applicable; NR = not reported
* PCAS:79%, PCAT-S:91%, CPCI:99%, VANOCCS:64+54%
** Vignette study on 319 case report, 30 physicians
***Vignette study on 20 cases, 6 clinicians