Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 4;13(6):e0197312. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0197312

Table 1. Characteristics of the publications in the validity assessment of measurement tools on aspects of transitional patient safety.

Level of outcome = the level of outcome in culture-behaviour-outcome continuum.

Authors N Country Measurement tool Transition Safety outcome type Subject of questionnaire Target population Response rate
Patient perspective
Aller
2013
1500 SP Continuity of care between care
Levels (CCAENA)
Hospital<->PCP HCP outcome Continuity of care Patients that have experienced a transition 23%
Berendsen
2009
1404 NL Consumer Quality Index Continuum of Care (CQI-COC) PCP referral and relational continuity HCP outcome Collaboration between PCP and hospital Referred patients 65%
Coleman
2002
60 USA Care Transition Measure (CTM) Discharge from hospital to home/nursing home HCP outcome Care transition Patients ≥65 years who were recently discharged from hospital and received subsequent skilled nursing care in facility/home. NR
Coleman
2005
200 USA Care Transition Measure (CTM) Discharge from hospital to home/nursing home HCP and patient outcome Care transition Adult patients discharged with primary diagnosis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, congestive heart failure, stroke, or hip fracture 100%
Graumlich
2008
460 USA B-prepared Hospital discharge HCP outcome Patient preparedness on hospital discharge All adult patients discharged by internal medicine hospitalists NR
Grimmer
2001
500 (patients), 431
(carers)
AUS PREPARED Hospital discharge HCP and patient outcome Discharge Patients ≥65 years, recently discharged from hospital 60% (patients), 52% (care givers)
Hadjistavropoulos 2008 204 CAN Patient continuity of care Questionnaire (PCCQ) Hospital discharge HCP outcome Continuity of care at discharge Adult patients recently discharged from hospital NR
Haggerty
2011
236–427 CAN 4 questionnaires with dimension management continuity: PCAS, PCAT-S, CPCI, VANOCSS PCP<-> other specialists HCP outcome Management continuity Primary care patients who had seen more than one provider in the previous month 54–99%*
Haggerty
2012
256 CAN Patient Perceived Continuity from Multiple Clinicians Hos<->PCP HCP and patient outcome Continuity of care Adult patients in primary care seeing other clinicians in a variety of settings 80%
Kollen
2010
1404 NL Consumer Quality Index Continuum of Care (CQI-COC) PCP referral and relational continuity HCP outcome Continuity of care Adult patients who had been referred and visited a specialist 65%
Uijen
2011
288 NL Nijmegen Continuity Questionnaire Hos<->PCP HCP outcome Continuity of care Patients with comorbidity 72%
Uijen
2012
268 NL Nijmegen Continuity Questionnaire Hos<->PCP HCP outcome Continuity of care Patients with comorbidity 76%
Healthcare professional perspective
Berendsen
2010
496 NL Doctors’ opinions on collaboration (DOC) questionnaire Hos<->PCP HCP outcome and climate Interprofessional collaboration PCPs and specialists 45%
Forster
2012
**  CAN Peer review process of adverse outcome Hospital discharge Patient outcome Adverse events at discharge NA NA
Graumlich
2008
417 USA Modified Physician-PREPARED Hospital discharge HCP outcome Discharge Community physicians 76%
Hess
2009
12212 USA CRP-PIM: Communication with Referring Physicians Practice Improvement Module PCP referral to secondary care consultants (hospital and private groups) HCP outcomeand climate Communication of consultants Referring physicians ?
Nuno-solinis
2013
187 SP No name reported Hos<->PCP Climate Interprofessional collaboration Physicians and nurses working in integrated healthcare organisations 16%
Smith
2004
***  USA Medication discrepancy tool Hospital discharge Patient outcome Medication discrepancies Practitioners across the continuum of care NA

SP: Spain; NL: the Netherlands; USA: United States of America; AUS: Australia; CAN: Canada; HOS: hospital; PCP: Primary care practitioner; NA = not applicable; NR = not reported

* PCAS:79%, PCAT-S:91%, CPCI:99%, VANOCCS:64+54%

** Vignette study on 319 case report, 30 physicians

***Vignette study on 20 cases, 6 clinicians