Skip to main content
. 2017 Dec 26;7(12):e018811. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018811

Table 4.

Results will be summarised in table format

Study Study design Participants Computer-assisted instruction (CAI) Comparator teaching methods (not using CAI)
  • Author

  • Journal

  • Year of publication

  • Randomised control trial

  • Cohort study

  • Case–control study

  • Before-and-after study

  • Cross-sectional research

  • Students/residents

  • Year of study

  • University

  • Country

  • Number of participants

  • Response rate

  • CAI learning material/activities explained

  • Topics taught

  • Educational approaches used

  • Learning theories underpinning CAI

  • Comparator teaching method explained

  • Topics taught

  • Educational approaches used

  • Learning theories underpinning non-CAI teaching method

Study ECG knowledge that was tested Baseline ECG knowledge Acquired ECG knowledge Retention of ECG knowledge
  • Author

  • Journal

  • Year of publication

  • Measurements

  • Waveforms

  • Rhythms

  • CAI cohort

  • Cohort with comparator educational method

  • CAI cohort

  • Cohort with comparator educational method

  • CAI cohort

  • Cohort with comparator educational method

Study Modified Kirkpatrick model60–63 Quality assessment Risk of bias Significance of study results
  • Author

  • Journal

  • Year of publication

  • Level 1

  • Level 2a

  • Level 2b

  • Level 3

  • Level 4a

  • Level 4b

  • MERSQI score

  • Validity of results

  • Reliability of results

  • Psychometric properties of assessments testing ECG competence

  • Selection bias

  • Performance bias

  • Attrition bias

  • Detection bias

  • Reporting bias

  • Findings of study summarised

  • Practical significance of findings (effect size)

MERSQI, Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument.