Table 1.
Inhaler | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|
pMDI | (i) Portable and compact | (i) Require coordination |
(ii) Multidose device | (ii) High deposition in mouth and oropharynx | |
(iii) Metered dose | (iii) “Cold Freon” effect | |
(iv) Established/familiar | (iv) Contain propellants | |
(v) Available for most inhaled medications | ||
| ||
pMDI + spacer | (i) Lower dependency on inspiratory effort | (i) Less portable than pMDI |
(ii) Easier to coordinate | (ii) Certain spacers may acquire electrostatic charge | |
(iii) Higher lung deposition than pMDI | (iii) Additional cost to pMDI | |
(iv) Reduced mouth and oropharynx deposition | (iv) Requires regular maintenance | |
| ||
BA-MDI | (i) Portable and compact | (i) Contain propellants |
(ii) Multidose device | (ii) “Cold Freon” effect | |
(iii) Breath-actuated | (iii) Requires a moderate inspiratory effort | |
| ||
DPI | (i) Portable and compact | (i) Requires a minimum inspiratory effort |
(ii) Breath-actuated | (ii) May not be appropriate for emergency situations | |
(iii) Does not contain propellants | (iii) Multiple designs (may be confusing for the patient) | |
(iv) Multidose devices available | (iv) May be complicated to load | |
| ||
SMI | (i) Portable and compact | (i) Not breath-actuated |
(ii) Multidose device | (ii) Only one device currently available | |
(iii) Lower dependency on inspiratory effort | ||
(iv) High fine-particle fraction | ||
(v) High lung deposition; low mouth and oropharynx deposition | ||
(vi) Does not contain propellants | ||
| ||
Nebulizers | (i) Can be used at any age | (i) Most lack portability |
(ii) Can be used by acutely ill | (ii) Some require an outside energy source | |
(iii) No specific inhalation technique required | (iii) Noisy | |
(iv) Can be used to dispense drugs not available as pMDI or DPI | (iv) Can result in longer treatment times | |
(v) Can be expensive |
Adapted from [28]. BA-MDI, breath-actuated metered-dose inhaler; DPI, dry powder inhaler; pMDI, pressurized metered-dose inhaler; SMI, soft mist inhaler.