Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 13;8:9076. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-27017-9

Table 2.

Results of the minimum linear mixed effects models for the transplant’s relative growth rates in height, plant projection area, leaf length and number of leaves for the three monitoring periods in 2012 and 2013 and for aboveground biomass, specific leaf area (SLA) and leaf dry matter content (LDMC) at the final harvest in September 2013.

Responses Predictors Estimate p-value Marginal R² Conditional R²
Veg. period 2012
RGR height Intercept 0.150 0.424 0.004 0.536
Multi-trait FD 0.058 0.038
RGR p. proj. area Intercept −0.018 0.865 0.008 0.419
Multi-trait FD 0.097 0.004
RGR leaf length Intercept (Scen Beals) 0.085 0.551 0.011 0.384
Height FD 0.068 0.024
Scen Dissim −0.094 0.411
Scen Random −0.225 0.005
Scen Sim −0.028 0.704
RGR leaf number Intercept (Scen Beals) 0.129 0.216 0.013 0.328
SLA FD (Scen Beals) 0.097 0.050
Scen Dissim −0.154 0.202
Scen Random −0.262 0.002
Scen Sim −0.154 0.052
SLA FD:Scen Dissim −0.102 0.126
SLA FD:Scen Random −0.236 0.002
SLA FD:Scen Sim −0.069 0.318
Winter 2012/2013
RGR height Intercept (Scen Beals) −0.039 0.918 0.069 0.634
LUI 0.250 0.000
Height FD (Scen Beals) 0.137 0.006
Height CWM (Scen Beals) −0.142 0.025
Scen Dissim −0.163 0.107
Scen Random −0.194 0.009
Scen Sim 0.065 0.340
Height FD:Scen Dissim −0.178 0.013
Height FD:Scen Random −0.070 0.345
Height FD:Scen Sim −0.199 0.007
Height CWM:Scen Dissim 0.171 0.020
Height CWM:Scen Random 0.024 0.726
Height CWM:Scen Sim 0.173 0.020
RGR p. proj. area Intercept (Scen Beals) 0.014 0.957 0.061 0.492
LUI 0.215 0.001
Height FD (Scen Beals) 0.183 0.000
SLA CWM 0.130 0.006
LDMC CWM 0.092 0.035
Height CWM −0.100 0.035
Scen Dissim −0.194 0.095
Scen Random −0.185 0.025
Scen Sim −0.054 0.468
Height FD:Scen Dissim −0.146 0.027
Height FD:Scen Random −0.173 0.013
Height FD:Scen Sim −0.153 0.026
RGR leaf length Intercept (Scen Beals) 0.060 0.863 0.051 0.544
LUI 0.210 0.001
Height FD (Scen Beals) 0.129 0.016
Height CWM (Scen Beals) −0.119 0.077
Scen Dissim −0.218 0.039
Scen Random −0.091 0.249
Scen Sim 0.001 0.984
Height FD:Scen Dissim −0.156 0.045
Height FD:Scen Random −0.079 0.326
Height FD:Scen Sim −0.213 0.008
Height CWM:Scen Dissim 0.133 0.094
Height CWM:Scen Random 0.041 0.586
Height CWM:Scen Sim 0.210 0.009
RGR leaf number Intercept (Scen Beals) −0.168 0.297 0.013 0.440
LUI 0.086 0.086
Height FD 0.057 0.075
SLA CWM (Scen Beals) 0.024 0.659
Scen Dissim 0.016 0.904
Scen Random 0.008 0.927
Scen Sim 0.045 0.554
SLA CWM:Scen Dissim −0.093 0.155
SLA CWM:Scen Random −0.068 0.308
SLA CWM:Scen Sim 0.066 0.269
Veg. period 2013
RGR height Intercept 0.079 0.864 0.012 0.682
LUI −0.126 0.046
RGR p. proj. area Intercept 0.029 0.910 0.005 0.398
SLA FD 0.086 0.020
RGR leaf length Intercept 0.017 0.967 0.026 0.568
SLA FD 0.124 0.000
Height CWM −0.138 0.001
RGR leaf number Intercept 0.040 0.729 0.014 0.357
Multi-trait FD −0.090 0.017
SLA FD 0.114 0.005
Harvest 2013
Biomass Intercept (Scen Beals) −0.016 0.865 0.064 0.423
LUI 0.170 0.002
Multi-trait FD (Scen Beals) 0.003 0.960
LDMC FD (Scen Beals) −0.116 0.076
SLA CWM (Scen Beals) −0.094 0.107
Scen Dissim −0.116 0.382
Scen Random −0.066 0.476
Scen Sim −0.048 0.535
Multi-trait FD:Scen Dissim 0.217 0.029
Multi-trait FD:Scen Random 0.064 0.514
Multi-trait FD:Scen Sim −0.080 0.333
LDMC FD:Scen Dissim 0.052 0.581
LDMC FD:Scen Random 0.018 0.854
LDMC FD:Scen Sim 0.226 0.008
SLA CWM:Scen Dissim 0.292 0.000
SLA CWM:Scen Random 0.228 0.007
SLA CWM:Scen Sim 0.185 0.016
SLA Intercept (Scen Beals) 0.095 0.683 0.044 0.509
Height CWM 0.140 0.001
LDMC CWM (Scen Beals) −0.118 0.024
Scen Dissim −0.347 0.005
Scen Random −0.040 0.644
Scen Sim 0.041 0.574
LDMC CWM:Scen Dissim 0.196 0.003
LDMC CWM:Scen Random 0.212 0.003
LDMC CWM:Scen Sim −0.013 0.825
LDMC Intercept (Scen Beals) 0.062 0.557 0.036 0.556
SLA FD −0.080 0.030
LDMC FD 0.077 0.042
SLA CWM (Scen Beals) −0.020 0.757
LDMC CWM (Scen Beals) 0.065 0.300
Scen Dissim 0.275 0.041
Scen Random 0.037 0.682
Scen Sim 0.046 0.531
SLA CWM:Scen Dissim −0.005 0.952
SLA CWM:Scen Random −0.076 0.362
SLA CWM:Scen Sim 0.164 0.027
LDMC CWM:Scen Dissim −0.041 0.611
LDMC CWM:Scen Random −0.268 0.001
LDMC CWM:Scen Sim 0.104 0.157

All models were simplified starting with the same suite of predictors: land-use intensity (LUI), community weighted means (CWM), functional diversity (FD), scenario (Beals, Dissim, Random, Sim, see text for explanation) and all interactions of scenario with LUI, CWM, and FD. CWM and FD were based on the single traits SLA, LDMC and height, while multi-trait FD was based on all eight traits (see Methods). All variables were scaled by mean and standard deviation, thus the estimates show the direction and magnitude of impact on the plant responses. Marginal R2 refers to the variance explained by fixed factors and conditional R2 to the variance explained by both fixed and random factors. Random factors in the model included Exploratory (Schwäbische Alb, Hainich and Schorfheide), plot (n = 54) nested in Exploratory, subplot (n = 432) nested in plot and species identity (n = 130). For variance of random factors see SI Table S5.