1.
纳入临床研究的一般资料
The characteristics of included studies
| Included studies | Cases | KPS scores | Clinicopathological staging | Intervention | Outcome | |
| Treatment | Control | |||||
| A: CR; B: PR; C: CR+PR; D: 1-year survival rate; E: 2-year survival rate; F: 3-year survival rate; G: radiation pneumonitis; H: radiation esophagitis; I: heart toxicity; J: hematologic toxicity; K: kidney toxicity; L: liver toxicity; M: myelosuppression; N: radiodermatitis; O: anaphylaxis; P: nausea and vomiting; Q: weight loss; R: blood biochemistry; S: nerve toxicity; (G): the two outcomes of radiation pneumonitis; 3-DCRT: 3-Dimension conformal radiation therapy; CTR: conventional radiotherapy; SR: stereotactic radiotherapy; IMRT: intensity modulation radiation therapy. CR: complete response; PR: partial response. | ||||||
| Li HX 2007[5] | 86 | > 70 | Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT | ABCDEGHIJ |
| Zhao QW 2007[6] | 48 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR plus vitamin C | ABCIJKL |
| Li ZW 2007[7] | 56 | ≥70 | Ⅱ, Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR plus vitamin C | ABC |
| Zhang XH 2009[8] | 32 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT | ABCGH |
| Deng YN 2009[9] | 152 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABC |
| Ji N 2010[10] | 90 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABCGHMN |
| Qian YH 2007[11] | 98 | ≥70 | Ⅱ, Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABCJ |
| Guo YX 2007[12] | 48 | ≥70 | Ⅰ, Ⅱ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT plus vitamin C | ABC |
| Dang YZ 2006[13] | 72 | ≥70 | Ⅱ, Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT plus vitamin C | ABC |
| Zhang N 2008[14] | 80 | ≥70 | Ⅱ, Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABC |
| Han JQ 2004[15] | 402 | ≥70 | Ⅰ, Ⅱ, Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABCO |
| Liu YC 2007[16] | 65 | Unclear | Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABCDEGHM |
| Liu JM 2010[17] | 46 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABCJIKL |
| Jia JH 2008[18] | 64 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT | ABCHMP |
| An YM 2008[19] | 120 | > 60 | Ⅲ, Ⅳ | SR plus CMNa | SR | ABCDEF |
| Chen MC 2009[20] | 60 | > 70 | Ⅱ, Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT plus vitamin C | ABCDEF |
| Chen RX 2006[21] | 42 | ≥70 | Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT | ABCGH |
| Wang TJ 2008[22] | 120 | ≥60 | Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT plus placebo | ABC(G)IJKLNQ |
| Wang JC 2009[23] | 77 | > 70 | Ⅲ | 3DCRT plus CMNa | 3DCRT | ABCGHIM |
| Gao HF 2011[24] | 56 | ≥70 | Ⅱ, Ⅲ | IMRT plus CMNa | IMRT | ABC |
| Song X 2006[25] | 80 | Unclear | Ⅲ | CTR plus CMNa | CTR | ABCGHMNQRS |