Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.
Study | Intervention Group Condition | Control Group Condition |
Primary Outcome Measures |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intensity, Model, and Systemic Interventions (SI) | Target Population | Intervention Duration, Session Length, and Format |
|||
Daley-McCoy et al., 2014e [20] |
Intensity: Universal. Model: “Psychoeducation.” SI: Communication and problem-solving skills traininga |
Women and their partners (n = 47) expecting their first baby |
Duration: 5 standard antenatal care classes with an additional session after the last class. Length: 2 hours. Format: Group. |
Standard care (n = 36) |
Depression: Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS). Family Functioning: Couple Communication Scale. |
Feinberg & Kan, 2008b [22] |
Level: Universal. Model: “Family Foundations.” SI: Communication, problem-solving, and conflict management skillsa |
Women and their partners (n = 79) expecting their first baby |
Duration: 4 prenatal classes and 4 postnatal classes. Length: 2 hours. Format: Group. |
No treatment control condition (n = 73) |
Depression: Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale. Family Functioning: Video-taped couple interactions. |
Fisher et al., 2016b,
f [21] |
Level: Universal. Model: “What Were We Thinking.” SI: Communication, conflict management skills & parenting skillsa |
First-time parents (n = 187) of infants |
Duration: 1 session integrated into standard primary care program. Length: 6 hours. Format: Group. |
Standard care (n = 177) |
Depression: Patient Health Questionnaire– 9 item. Family Functioning: Intimate Bonds Measure and a single item relationship quality measure. |
Gambrel & Piercy 2015 [23] |
Level: Universal. Model: “Mindfulness-based relationship education.” SI: Cognitive, interpersonal mindfulness skillsa |
Women and their partners (n = 32) expecting their first baby |
Duration: 4 weekly sessions. Length: 2 hours. Format: Group. |
Wait-list control group (n = 34) |
Depression: Depression Anxiety Stress Scale–Depression subscale. Family Functioning: Couple Satisfaction Index. |
Misri et al., 2000 [16] |
Level: Treatment. Model: “Psychoeducation.” SI: Supportive communication. |
Postpartum womeng diagnosed with MDDc and their partners (n = 32) |
Duration: 6 weekly sessions followed by 1 session, a month later. Partners attended 4 of the 7 sessions. Length: Not specified. Format: Individual couple sessions. |
Psychoeducation sessions with only patients (n = 25) |
Depression: EPDS. Family Functioning: Dyadic Adjustment Scale. |
Mulcahy et al., 2010b [17] |
Level: Treatment. Model: “Interpersonal Group Therapy.” SI: Partners learned to support and respond to depressed women. |
Postpartum womeng (n = 23) diagnosed with MDDc and their partners |
Duration: 8 weekly sessions and 1 partner session. Length: 2 hours. Format: Group. |
Treatment as usual (n = 27) |
Depression: EPDS. Family Functioning: Dyadic Adjustment Scale. |
Ortiz Collado et al., 2014e [26] |
Level: Indicated prevention. Model: Humanistic and cognitive-behavioral.d SI: Communication skills to strengthen affective bonds.a |
Pregnant womeng and their partners (n = 138) |
Duration: 10 weekly sessions. Length: 2 hours and 15 minutes. Format: Group. |
Standard Care (n = 116) |
Depression: EPDS. Family Functioning: Dyadic Adjustment Scale. |
aWe classified these interventions as cognitive-behavioral.
b Only included in the meta-analysis for the depression outcome. See the subsection “Managing missing quantitative data” for more details.
cMDD = Major Depressive Disorder.
dClassification of systemic interventions was confirmed through personal communication with Dr. Ortiz Collado.
eFollow-ups occurred between one month and six weeks (n = 2) after the last intervention session.
fFollow-up occurred five months after the last intervention session.
gPrimaparous and multiparous women were included.